WAI
Status Update
No update yet.
Comments
lb...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
ad...@google.com
ad...@google.com
What
More information
It turns out, this issue happens almost every time. If it crashes a certain way (probably if it's happening too quickly or too many times), the device will reboot. Last time, it took me to the Android recovery saying along the lines of "Can't load Android ... Your data might be corrupted" and the options were try again or factory reset.
The screen recording was done on the first attempt. Thankfully I can unlock after the lock screen crashes using the pin or fingerprint. Fingerprint can also work right from AOD.
But when after a few crashes, some worse than others (the display doesn't stay on and I had to press the power button), the device rebooted and entered me into a recovery screen. The second bug report was taken after that.
When
Time and frequency
Time when bug report was triggered: Mar 14, 2025 5:26 AM GMT+07:00
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/panther_beta/panther:16/BP22.250221.010/13193326:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250960035 (25.09.60 (260400-732198584))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 704901443 (135.0.7049.14)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Telkomsel
SIM operator: Telkomsel
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
ch...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
lf...@gmail.com
This is quite bad. Now it happens every time.
The crash also sometimes happen when turning off the screen. In which case, the AOD likely won't work. I have to turn on the display before unlocking but thankfully looks like it doesn't crash again if it crashes when turning off the screen.
New bug report and screen recording on next post.
de...@gmail.com
What
More information
While on the home screen, it crashes when turning off the display. Somehow, I can't replicate this while recording, and I had to turn on Do Not Disturb (Bedtime) for it to crash when turning off again.
Later in the recording, the crash happens repeatedly. Every time this happened previously, the lock screen and AOD didn't recover and the phone rebooted.
The last one happened while I was attempting to record this, and I saw the old white "Power Off" dialog with the spinning circle UI before it rebooted to the same recovery screen again. I couldn't find that recording after.
The bug report was taken after the attached (successful) recording.
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/panther_beta/panther:16/BP22.250221.010/13193326:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250960035 (25.09.60 (260400-732198584))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 704901443 (135.0.7049.14)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Telkomsel
SIM operator: Telkomsel
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
we...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
co...@gmail.com
Thank you for reporting this issue. We have shared this with our product and engineering team and will update this issue with more information as it becomes available.
lb...@gmail.com
it appears that turning off AOD avoids the issue for me (pixel 6a).
ar...@gmail.com
Turning off AOD seems to avoid the issue on my P7 too, so far. It's a bit inconvenient but necessary for now. Thank you for the suggestion.
ha...@okta.com
I enabled the "show all ANR" and "show all background crashes" options and found that systemui crashes at the same time (or systemui *is* the cause here)
lb...@gmail.com
What
More information
As I turned off the AOD, the unexpected shutdowns have completely disappeared
When
Time and frequency
Time when bug report was triggered: Mar 17, 2025 5:57 AM GMT+05:00
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/bluejay_beta/bluejay:16/BP22.250221.010/13193326:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250933035 (25.09.33 (260400-736501638))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699803933 (134.0.6998.39)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: PAK - PL
SIM operator: ZONG
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
go...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
he...@gmail.com
Agreed with turning off AOD fixes the issue
el...@gmail.com
What
More information
I followed the steps from the linked similar issue and turned off AOD and can confirm it no longer crashes the phone.
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/cheetah_beta/cheetah:16/BP22.250221.010/13193326:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250962035 (25.09.62 (260400-736577381))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 704901443 (135.0.7049.14)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: YES OPTUS
SIM operator: YES OPTUS
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
ch...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
ru...@gmail.com
How is this not P1?
f5...@gmail.com
What
More information
Now the phone is going to the factory reset boot screen.
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/husky_beta/husky:16/BP22.250221.010/13193326:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
- SoC Revision: Zuma B1
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250933035 (25.09.33 (260400-736501638))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699803933 (134.0.6998.39)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Koodo
SIM operator: Koodo
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
fe...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
qu...@gmail.com
redacted
cy...@gmail.com
What
More information
As the previous comment says, the issue seems to still be present on Beta 3.1 (BP22.250221.013). It happens a tiny bit less frequently on my P7, but AOD is still unusable for me on this build.
When
Time and frequency
Time when bug report was triggered: Mar 19, 2025 5:30 AM GMT+07:00
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/panther_beta/panther:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 251033035 (25.10.33 (260400-736521774))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 704901443 (135.0.7049.14)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Telkomsel
SIM operator: Telkomsel
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
te...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
ga...@gmail.com
What
More information
phone crashed again this morning triingto wake from sleep
When
Time and frequency
Time when bug report was triggered: Mar 19, 2025 8:27 AM GMT-07:00
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/lynx_beta/lynx:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250933035 (25.09.33 (260400-736501638))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699803933 (134.0.6998.39)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: ROGERS
SIM operator: ROGERS
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
an...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
ma...@marcardar.com
What
More information
Even after the update yesterday, it still does it, but less frequently
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/tokay_beta/tokay:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250933035 (25.09.33 (260400-736501638))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699803933 (134.0.6998.39)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Koodo
SIM operator: Koodo
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
p....@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
lb...@gmail.com
What
More information
Lock screen flickers does not want to open, crashes and restart.
When
Time and frequency
Time when bug report was triggered: Mar 20, 2025 10:18 AM GMT-04:00
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/tokay_beta/tokay:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250933035 (25.09.33 (260400-736501638))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699803933 (134.0.6998.39)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Koodo
SIM operator: Koodo
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
th...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
lb...@gmail.com
What
More information
Newer bug report with fresh crash just before report made.
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/caiman_beta/caiman:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 251061035 (25.10.61 (260400-738233885))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699810833 (134.0.6998.108)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Circles
SIM operator: Circles
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
lb...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
jo...@halfreal.de
Latest beta (16B3.1 IIRC) does not resolve this.
ma...@marcardar.com
What
More information
Please find the screen received after device reboot
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/husky_beta/husky:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
- SoC Revision: Zuma B1
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 251132035 (25.11.32 (260400-738162387))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699804033 (134.0.6998.40)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: mobily
SIM operator: BSNL Mobile
Network operator: stc ksa
SIM operator: stc
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
lb...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
ma...@marcardar.com
What
More information
It switches out at the lockscreen. It has become worse after the update
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/lynx_beta/lynx:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
Debugging information
Google Play services
com.google.android.gms
Version 250934035 (25.09.34 (260400-738842635))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699804033 (134.0.6998.40)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: airtel
SIM operator: airtel
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
lb...@gmail.com
Information redacted by Android Beta Feedback.
ma...@marcardar.com
What
More information
When Always on Display is disabled doesn't crashes anymore. Maybe the bug has to be with the animation when you press the power button or any form of unlocking the phone while AOD is enabled.
Where
Build and device data
- Build Number: google/husky_beta/husky:16/BP22.250221.013/13218340:user/release-keys
(Note: It is the build when sending this report. For exact build reference, please see the attached bugreport.)
- SoC Revision: Zuma B1
Debugging information
Servicios de Google Play
com.google.android.gms
Version 250934035 (25.09.34 (260400-738842635))
System App (Updated)
Android System WebView
com.google.android.webview
Version 699810933 (134.0.6998.109)
System App (Updated)
Network operator: Megamovil
SIM operator: Megamovil
Filed by Android Beta Feedback. Version (Updated): 2.46-betterbug.external_20241023_RC01 (DOGFOOD)
To learn more about our feedback process, please visit
ma...@marcardar.com
Failed to process file bugreport-husky_beta-BP22.250221.013-2025-03-28-06-15-51_GMT-07:00.zip
ma...@marcardar.com
I had this same issue, I thought it was because of something I downloaded, as there were a few zip files I download also apps. So I deleted them and didn't help. Disabled my phone from locking for a couple hours, enabled lockscreen and unlock via fingerprint again, and I haven't had the issue sense. Very odd and I'm glad I didn't whip my phone. My phone seems to be the most buggy it's ever been, down to little things that I can't even explain if I were to provide feedback. Although my contacts still are not syncing, provided feedback about that a few days ago and which started out of the blue
lb...@gmail.com
@39 I like the idea of filtering, but as I'm a user that wants to have a general clipboard manager, I would also like to have no-filtering option.
si...@gmail.com
All Clears and new update
is...@gmail.com
Really sad seeing this is how Google tries to improve Android at the expense of its usability. While there are much better solutions for the user and the developers like permission. You have to be stupid to not see the simple solution in front of you. Google please don't do this it will just make us use roundabout methods so that We can use our chipboards again. Really disappointed in you Google
cy...@gmail.com
Revoking clipboard access for apps is inconsistent with other Google policies. Just last year the Chrome team added permissions for web pages to prompt users for permission to access the clipboard (part of the Clipboard API): https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2018/03/clipboardapi
So, if that's an appropriate solution for Chrome, why is it not an appropriate solution for Android apps? Many of us (small businesses and developers) have been eagerly awaiting a response from the Android team on whether we're likely to get a permission request ability (so users can make an informed decisions about whether they want an app to be able to monitor the clipboard or not). Please respond so we can decide whether our apps and businesses have a future or not.
As a reminder, there are millions of installs of clipboard manager apps (some of them paid apps). There is clear demand for these products and this use case.
*https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.rojekti.clipper - 1M+ installs
*https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=de.halfreal.clipboardactions&hl=en_US - 500K+ installs
*https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=devdnua.clipboard&hl=en_US - 500K+ installs
*https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=jp.snowlife01.android.clipboard&hl=en_US - 100K+ PAID installs
So, if that's an appropriate solution for Chrome, why is it not an appropriate solution for Android apps? Many of us (small businesses and developers) have been eagerly awaiting a response from the Android team on whether we're likely to get a permission request ability (so users can make an informed decisions about whether they want an app to be able to monitor the clipboard or not). Please respond so we can decide whether our apps and businesses have a future or not.
As a reminder, there are millions of installs of clipboard manager apps (some of them paid apps). There is clear demand for these products and this use case.
*
*
*
*
tr...@tellient.com
@43, well put! I was curious about the inconsistency too. Our app needs clipboard access to work!
lb...@gmail.com
@43 And today I got to see an article of Chrome being able to sync clipboard data between Android and PC :
https://www.xda-developers.com/google-chrome-canary-adds-a-shared-clipboard-feature-for-android-and-pc/
See the rudeness?
Google removed any good way to monitor clipboard for clipboard managers to sync between Android and PC (and other features), and yet added something similar for its own web browser...
See the rudeness?
Google removed any good way to monitor clipboard for clipboard managers to sync between Android and PC (and other features), and yet added something similar for its own web browser...
br...@gmail.com
Removing app access to the clipboard is, frankly, bullshit. This alone is a strong reason to not adopt Android 10.
The world is moving towards and ecosystem where devices can **more easily** share files, data, and information, and where I can seamless move from one device to the other.
Just for example, I could copy text or a graphic on my desktop or laptop, and paste it in my Android device.
This policy moves us in the exact opposite and wrong direction.
It's a move back towards the days when the best way to transfer information between your computer and your mobile device was to email it to yourself.
The world is moving towards and ecosystem where devices can **more easily** share files, data, and information, and where I can seamless move from one device to the other.
Just for example, I could copy text or a graphic on my desktop or laptop, and paste it in my Android device.
This policy moves us in the exact opposite and wrong direction.
It's a move back towards the days when the best way to transfer information between your computer and your mobile device was to email it to yourself.
sl...@gmail.com
I just updated my Pixel 3 to Android 10. Can't rollback because the bootloader is locked permanently. I am now literally in the market for a Pixel 3 with Android 9 because of this "security feature" and definitely won't be buying the Pixel 4 because of this.
Hopefuly this will get fixed before Android 11.
Hopefuly this will get fixed before Android 11.
lb...@gmail.com
Currently, the only workarounds on Q:
1. If you are a clipboard-manager app developer, for some reason using SAW with focusable on-top-view will still let you monitor the clipboard. Sadly Google plan to remove this permission someday, though, and replace it with a useless API (Bubble), which looks very similar to the hated Facebook chat-heads.
2. If you are a user, try keyboard apps that offer clipboard handling, like Gboard. It's not the same at all, and many features are missing, but it's something.
1. If you are a clipboard-manager app developer, for some reason using SAW with focusable on-top-view will still let you monitor the clipboard. Sadly Google plan to remove this permission someday, though, and replace it with a useless API (Bubble), which looks very similar to the hated Facebook chat-heads.
2. If you are a user, try keyboard apps that offer clipboard handling, like Gboard. It's not the same at all, and many features are missing, but it's something.
mi...@gmail.com
Samsungs come with clipboard manager automatically and it was annoying to have to find something similar for my pixel. Now it won't even work anymore.
lb...@gmail.com
@49 Pretty sure system apps can still do it.
gr...@gmail.com
If I'd have known it was going to happen, I'd never have upgraded. Bad move Google. Let your USERS decide whether to allow this permission
rd...@gmail.com
What everyone has been saying - I support not getting rid of it.
mr...@gmail.com
Give me back my clipboard manager. Seriously, I don't want to use a fucking note pad.
za...@gmail.com
I'm seriously lost without a clipboard manager.
tr...@gmail.com
Come on Google, don't become Apple. Give users choices.
ym...@gmail.com
We follow Apple's footsteps successfully..
Take the ramp..
Take the ramp..
ra...@gmail.com
Please allow users to use clipboard apps. I use this constantly. I understand the security risk but there must be another and better way.
dv...@gmail.com
This is a pretty egregious violation of user rights (and responsibilities). I understand the reasoning behind many of the recent (in my opinion, poorly-executed) decisions, but many of these decisions--regardless of the reasoning behind them--have ultimately worked to the detriment of the user experience, and in an age where UX is becoming the product, denying users the right to digital self-determination is tantamount to suggesting we go elsewhere.
tn...@gmail.com
Give clipboard access to clip managers with no network access.
st...@gmail.com
Android has a ton of opt-in permissions for basically everything. This was a really sloppy oversight that these folks had months to deal with considering it was unpopular during the beta. Make it a permission with the numerous other permissions that you can toggle, and put the onus on the user. This can't be a difficult thing to implement considering Google allows their own apps past these restrictions already. I chose Android over iOS because of its flexibility and configurability. Google must realize that slowly taking these things away from us seriously makes it far easier to consider moving to the other side.
At the very least, you are losing revenue because of the apps that you've rendered useless and/or crippled are going away.
At the very least, you are losing revenue because of the apps that you've rendered useless and/or crippled are going away.
ru...@gmail.com
This is why I do not believe it's being done for security. That is just
their excuse. google is rotten and greedy and wants to make sure the only
thing reading our copy / paste is them, for further data mining. They had
more than ample time to add permissions, they didn't even try.
On Mon, Sep 30, 2019 at 3:45 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
their excuse. google is rotten and greedy and wants to make sure the only
thing reading our copy / paste is them, for further data mining. They had
more than ample time to add permissions, they didn't even try.
On Mon, Sep 30, 2019 at 3:45 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
--
rustygh
ha...@gmail.com
Grrrrr. +1
p....@gmail.com
Come on Google, enable selection of permission for an app to send/receive clipboard data.
gy...@gmail.com
This really needs to be fixed
cr...@gmail.com
Give it back. You do not own my content.
adb -d shell appops set com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW allow;
adb -d shell pm grant com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager android.permission.READ_LOGS;
adb shell am force-stop com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager;
adb -d shell appops set com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW allow;
adb -d shell pm grant com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager android.permission.READ_LOGS;
adb shell am force-stop com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager;
sl...@gmail.com
That's amazing, #65. I can confirm that this workaround works! However it won't work for apps that have not requested the READ_LOGS permission.
lb...@gmail.com
@66 It has nothing to do with READ_LOGS.
It's about SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW .
And it's the same workaround as I wrote on #48.
You don't need adb for it.
It's about SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW .
And it's the same workaround as I wrote on #48.
You don't need adb for it.
sl...@gmail.com
Well, at least com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager's implementation requires the READ_LOGS permission iin order to work. I tried revoking it and it wouldn't read the clipboard anymore. Granting it again fixes this.
I imagine there is some code workaround that needs to be written besides following these instructions for apps that monitor the clipboard, right? or are these instructions enough and require no further changes for apps that previously worked, besides them adding the READ_LOGS permission to their manifest?
I imagine there is some code workaround that needs to be written besides following these instructions for apps that monitor the clipboard, right? or are these instructions enough and require no further changes for apps that previously worked, besides them adding the READ_LOGS permission to their manifest?
lb...@gmail.com
@68 Again, it's not needed. I don't know about this app, but if you make your own app you will see that it's not needed.
Just use SAW instead, together with a real focusable floating View and a foreground service.
And again, this is just a workaround, because sadly Google plans to ruin SAW permission too, some day.
Just use SAW instead, together with a real focusable floating View and a foreground service.
And again, this is just a workaround, because sadly Google plans to ruin SAW permission too, some day.
he...@gmail.com
@69 I am the author of Clip Stack. Drawing a focused window continuously with SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW will break many system behavior such as the gesture navigation and back button. READ_LOGS or a11y can help to fix it. I think READ_LOGS has better performance than a11y. If you have any other method to bypass this restriction without any additional permissions, please tell us.
Also I strongly suggest to put the focus of the discussion back to Google, not any app.
Also I strongly suggest to put the focus of the discussion back to Google, not any app.
lb...@gmail.com
@70 READ_LOGS is is recommended as it requires rooted device or using adb to grant it.
At least for SAW you can have a tiny view somewhere or even almost invisible, and still allow normal users grant it.
What's "a11y " ? If you mean accessibility, I already tested it and didn't notice it doing anything.
Have you really tried using READ_LOGS alone, without SAW, and it worked for you?
If so, it's really weird, because the docs say about focused apps, and logs have nothing to do with it...
At least for SAW you can have a tiny view somewhere or even almost invisible, and still allow normal users grant it.
What's "a11y " ? If you mean accessibility, I already tested it and didn't notice it doing anything.
Have you really tried using READ_LOGS alone, without SAW, and it worked for you?
If so, it's really weird, because the docs say about focused apps, and logs have nothing to do with it...
he...@gmail.com
I don't want to elaborate on the technical details that are too detailed here. This may cause Google’s testers to treat it as a vulnerability. Although I believe that Google's programmers know what I mean.
SAW + READ_LOG / SAW + a11y works fine.
SAW only will destroy the system behavior such as back key.
I still hope that the discussion will focus on getting Google to change the current rude practices, not the specific implementation of an app.
SAW + READ_LOG / SAW + a11y works fine.
SAW only will destroy the system behavior such as back key.
I still hope that the discussion will focus on getting Google to change the current rude practices, not the specific implementation of an app.
lb...@gmail.com
@72 Again, what is a11y ?
And why do you use SAW together with others, if you said you don't want to use SAW, and I tell you that SAW is enough?
Why do you think it will destroy the back key? It has nothing to do with it.
And why do you use SAW together with others, if you said you don't want to use SAW, and I tell you that SAW is enough?
Why do you think it will destroy the back key? It has nothing to do with it.
he...@gmail.com
I didn't find any way to use the SAW to monitor the clipboard perfectly without using other permissions, without disturbing the system gestures and back key. If you know, please let us know how to do it and release an available demo apk.
lb...@gmail.com
@74 You didn't answer my questions.
One of them is why do you think it will do this ("disturbing the system gestures and back key").
One of them is why do you think it will do this ("disturbing the system gestures and back key").
gm...@gmail.com
I'm just a user of clipboard managers the ones that throw my support behind these developers. Hey Google If you're listening please find a way to loud users to take advantage of these powerful software utilities!
hw...@gmail.com
ULTRAMEGABIGWIN
sm...@gmail.com
Please give back the ability to share our data with clipboard managers!
cy...@gmail.com
Thank you, Google/Android Team, for the upgrade to a P1! We desperately need some attention and communication on this topic, even if it's to give us clarity on this subject. As developers and entrepreneurs doing creative, valuable things with clipboard access, we've come to rely on this feature to bring novel, magical experiences to users. Even if Android 10 doesn't allow developers to prompt the user for clipboard permission, we're hopeful that you'll reconsider this for future Android versions. You've got a solid pattern of letting developers prompt the user for permissions and this sort of access seems like it would fit perfectly into that pattern.
Thanks to everyone who starred this issue or left a comment to help get this on Google's radar.
Thanks to everyone who starred this issue or left a comment to help get this on Google's radar.
st...@gmail.com
Yes, thank you for the upgrade. We appreciate your attention to this folks.
ro...@gmail.com
I want to echo
lb...@gmail.com
@76 Show me a sample project. I remember I tried this sample for example and didn't notice any issues, at least in one of the beta versions of Q.
Here, attached this sample after updating to latest sdks and also added clipboard monitoring inside (shows content on logs), to show that it's possible to use SAW alone (with foreground service to keep it nicely alive).
Here, attached this sample after updating to latest sdks and also added clipboard monitoring inside (shows content on logs), to show that it's possible to use SAW alone (with foreground service to keep it nicely alive).
ba...@gmail.com
I find clipboard managers indespensible. I use them on all of my computers / devices. I understand the security point. But if I want to run a clipboard manager on my phone, that's my choice. Mobile OSs in general are a major pain point. Paying $$$ for a device that runs an OS that doesn't let you do anything beyond playing goofy little games - or whatever apps some company deems acceptible for you to run. I'm an adult, I should be able to run the apps I want - and I shouldn't have to hack my own phone to get admin rights on it. Ugh.
eb...@googlemail.com
I was not given any warning except that access to clipboard was taken away just like that. I have sensitive and important data I didn't back up. Now, how do I legally access my data once more or back them up? Thank you
cu...@gmail.com
Dear Google, please let the people who are already doing a great job making reliable clipboard apps to continue to do so.
I've been disappointef and dissatisfied with Android 10 so far. Many of the apps and features that worked great just a few days ago before updating, are now clumsy and more difficult to use. Please continue your hard work and allow others to do the same, especially if they are doing great.
I've been disappointef and dissatisfied with Android 10 so far. Many of the apps and features that worked great just a few days ago before updating, are now clumsy and more difficult to use. Please continue your hard work and allow others to do the same, especially if they are doing great.
cc...@gmail.com
I really miss my clipboard manager Google. It's just mean to take away functionality. My android phone could do way more 5 years ago than it can now (headphone jacks, IR capability and now clip manager support). Making it easier and easier to go back to IOS. Yeesh!
si...@gmail.com
Please stop breaking useful apps. Many clipboard managers use this and they are very helpful.
da...@gmail.com
Please allow us to keep this functionality!
fa...@gmail.com
Please allow advanced clipboard functionality & management
re...@googlemail.com
The clipboard feature is one that I use frequently and value greatly. Please reinstate permission fornits usage.
sg...@gmail.com
Clipboard managers are extremely helpful. Please consider allowing the user to grant permission per app in the same manner that access to camera, microphone or camera roll is granted.
Very Respectfully,
Surinder
Very Respectfully,
Surinder
ph...@gmail.com
Please restore the clipboard. I really need the clipboard to use Hanping Pro to help me to communicate effectively with Chinese students, colleagues, and friends.
ir...@gmail.com
The reason I moved from iphone to android is that Android is more open and configurable than iOS such as File manager , Root , Apps and clipboard manager , Download managers . After i upgraded to Android 10 , an app is not performing correctly ( clipboard function ) . I thought it is bug or error But not really after surfing on Internet . Pls FIX THIS issue on coming update soon. PLS .. THAT CLIPBOARD function is really needed .
si...@gmail.com
Restore the clipboard.
ba...@gmail.com
Stop ruining Android.
There's a reason I use Android and not iOS and removing functionality and locking down the OS diminishes that reason.
Removing clipboard functionality is another step closer to making iOS equal competition, damaging your user base and market attraction
There's a reason I use Android and not iOS and removing functionality and locking down the OS diminishes that reason.
Removing clipboard functionality is another step closer to making iOS equal competition, damaging your user base and market attraction
cy...@gmail.com
The evidence is clear: users love apps that can take advantage of the clipboard data to make easier copy/paste workflows and to offer other creative tools. To sum up the feedback in this issuetracker:
1. We're asking for a permission request for clipboard access, following the solid pattern that Android has developed for other sensitive data (mic, camera, location, etc.).
2. Clipboard apps are popular and some users have paid for clipboard apps. Android 10 breaks these apps and robs the user of the value that they paid for since developers don't have any path to get access to the users' clipboard in Android 10.
3. Chrome has upcoming support to prompt the user for clipboard access with the Clipboard API (https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2018/03/clipboardapi ) so if access to the clipboard is a supported use case for Chrome, why is that same access considered "too dangerous" for Android to even offer a permission request option for the user to consider?
Please help us keep Android awesome and distinct from iOS. This talk at Android Developer Conference yesterday (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7zSjDfP_xqg ) has an opening slide talking about "More transparency and control" and we couldn't agree more! Let the user control their clipboard and decide which apps should have access to it!
1. We're asking for a permission request for clipboard access, following the solid pattern that Android has developed for other sensitive data (mic, camera, location, etc.).
2. Clipboard apps are popular and some users have paid for clipboard apps. Android 10 breaks these apps and robs the user of the value that they paid for since developers don't have any path to get access to the users' clipboard in Android 10.
3. Chrome has upcoming support to prompt the user for clipboard access with the Clipboard API (
Please help us keep Android awesome and distinct from iOS. This talk at Android Developer Conference yesterday (
se...@gmail.com
Clipboard managers like clipstack are one of the things that make the Android OS better than iOS.
it's a great tool and I would like it back please. Don't restrict people from using their devices how they want to.
it's a great tool and I would like it back please. Don't restrict people from using their devices how they want to.
as...@gmail.com
I need to use clipboard app. fix it early
ym...@gmail.com
come on gooooogle
ms...@gmail.com
I just found out that one of my favorite apps, Easy Copy+, no longer works with Android 10 as you removed the access to it. Please reinstate it as I have used this app regularly, and made things for me much easier, especially with my disability.
ro...@gmail.com
Clipboard managers have to be reinstated. Please!
no...@gmail.com
Please don't remove this app.
ab...@gmail.com
Google, the thing that separated us from Apple is the freedom of choice. Which is why I have been an ardent supporter of the Android ecosystem from the very beginning.
When I eagerly updated to Android 10 on my Pixel 3, I had no idea that clipboard access was to be suddenly taken away. I'm a regular user of Clipper+.
Why is it that some IMEs like your own Gboard for example, still have the ability to access clipboard content but third party apps like Clipper+ are not trustworthy? I specifically searched out the app and installed it from the Google Play Store because I'm an end user who knows what he wants: full time access to all the text copied before. That's the reason I installed the app. I trust it with my data, I'm not copying any passwords or nuclear codes or defense secrets. I gave the app I downloaded the permission because I know what I'm doing. Now who are you to decide for me what's best for me when I expressly gave the app the permission to take care of this thing for me?
Breaks my trust in the Android ecosystem as a whole that you're now becoming more controlling than Apple, the very thing we took pride in, we're throwing away every day...
When I eagerly updated to Android 10 on my Pixel 3, I had no idea that clipboard access was to be suddenly taken away. I'm a regular user of Clipper+.
Why is it that some IMEs like your own Gboard for example, still have the ability to access clipboard content but third party apps like Clipper+ are not trustworthy? I specifically searched out the app and installed it from the Google Play Store because I'm an end user who knows what he wants: full time access to all the text copied before. That's the reason I installed the app. I trust it with my data, I'm not copying any passwords or nuclear codes or defense secrets. I gave the app I downloaded the permission because I know what I'm doing. Now who are you to decide for me what's best for me when I expressly gave the app the permission to take care of this thing for me?
Breaks my trust in the Android ecosystem as a whole that you're now becoming more controlling than Apple, the very thing we took pride in, we're throwing away every day...
st...@gmail.com
Very, very well said.
di...@gmail.com
Clip stack is basically a must feature for me plz fix the issue
rc...@gmail.com
Stop limiting what I can do with MY phone! I will be filing legal reports against Google for denying me certain access to my own property!
su...@gmail.com
Please Google, don't remove the access to clipboard!
¡Háganlo por los usuarios!
Thanks.
¡Háganlo por los usuarios!
Thanks.
cb...@gmail.com
Redmi k20 pro android 10 MIUI 11 only Starting from Android 10, Google banned all clipboard managers. More info ???😟
cb...@gmail.com
Fix pls
si...@gmail.com
This is frustrating - I use my clipper app heavily.
cj...@gmail.com
Google - please stop trying to copy iOS/iPhone so much. Android 10 locks down stuff that we as programmers could previously play with and learn from. Pixel series gets more like iPhone each release as well. We want Android to be DIFFERENT, otherwise we'll just get an iPhone.
ur...@gmail.com
the smartphone so less smart
sp...@gmail.com
Make clipboard access into a user permission for those of us that need this feature. People that think it is a security risk can disallow it for every app.
sp...@gmail.com
I have been a die-hard Android users since I switched over from Blackberry. If I wanted an inflexible locked down OS withi limited customizability, I would have gone with an iPhone. Hell even crackberry let you have more control.
pb...@gmail.com
I'm surprised more people are not complaining about this.
I think these people make a pretty strong argument that this was a bad idea.
I think these people make a pretty strong argument that this was a bad idea.
to...@gmail.com
Also the great KDE Connect app from the Plasma desktop lost it's clipboard sharing functionality. Being a developer who has to deal a lot with multi factor authentication makes it really frustrating that I can not copy the generated mfa code from my phone to my desktop anymore.
so...@gmail.com
I'm not currently a clipboard-related-app user, but I'd like to have that option in the future! +1 for restoring clipboard permissions options.
jo...@gmail.com
I strongly second each and every one of the above mentioned concerns.
yh...@gmail.com
Gboard for not save my clipboard history for more than an hour i need that
si...@gmail.com
I really miss my clipboard history app.
jt...@gmail.com
Please restore the user's ability to grant this permission
fr...@gmail.com
I really miss it!
ky...@gmail.com
kh...@gmail.com
โอนเงินเข้าบัญชี4140506669ธนาคารไทยพาณิชย์
co...@gmail.com
Constant user of kde connect. Without a usable clipboard manager, my working efficiency are much undercut. Banning clipboard access for most of the apps is not even understandable. User should be the ones to decide which app can gain access to clipboard.
ha...@gmail.com
Please remove the clipboard privacy feature Google
ra...@gmail.com
Bullshit wooow
gl...@gmail.com
What is going on over there? How did we get here?
Android used to be peerless precisely because of its flexibility. Every year, it gets less and less useful, and that's a shame.
Enough with the random, arbitrary feature deprecations. Throw clipboard access behind a security control, and bring it back.
Android used to be peerless precisely because of its flexibility. Every year, it gets less and less useful, and that's a shame.
Enough with the random, arbitrary feature deprecations. Throw clipboard access behind a security control, and bring it back.
ro...@gmail.com
I feel deeply disturbed by this change and for once wish Google would rethink the direction that they are taking with Android. Stifling the usefulness of the OS won't help anyone, especially developers that want to build groundbreaking applications that help drive the adoption of Android.
As for specifics on how to fix this issue, I support adding a new run time permission that has to be granted by the user. This still feels like overkill for something so trivial like the clipboard but it's an adequate compromise.
As for specifics on how to fix this issue, I support adding a new run time permission that has to be granted by the user. This still feels like overkill for something so trivial like the clipboard but it's an adequate compromise.
sl...@gmail.com
I agree with #130. simple users who use their android phones as if they were iPhones probably didn't even notice this change, but power users who enjoy efficiency make heavy use of apps that can interact with the clipboard in order to get repetitive tasks done faster. We need that permission as asap as possible, google!
f....@gmail.com
Ok so please refund all people paid for this simple feature ! Clipboard !!!!!
tg...@gmail.com
Add me to the chorus: for a power user, a clipboard history tool is essential, helping improve my productivity. And that's why I have an Android phone in the first place: so that I can be more effective in my business and personal life!
ha...@gmail.com
Working with an app like Clipboard Action makes many things (especially translation) much more easier. So, given new data protection requirements, it should certainly be possible to create appropriate access rights for Clipboard apps.
ra...@gmail.com
Following... Because I don't know any other way to do it 😕
a8...@gmail.com
Following.I think it is more inconvinient to use the OS without a Clipboard APP....please!!!
mc...@gmail.com
Google please allow clipboard manager apps! Some people work with copy/pasting a lot of things and those apps make it easier!
Either allow those apps or provide that function withon Android!
Either allow those apps or provide that function withon Android!
vi...@google.com
le...@gmail.com
Please change this! I need my clipboard
re...@gmail.com
I've paid for this software "Easy Copy+ The smart Clipboard" (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.camel.corp.easycopyplus&hl=en&showAllReviews=true ) because... well, it's a damn smart clipboard manager.
Now it's become pretty much USELESS due to your recent change. Please allow clipboard managers have access to the Android clipboard.
Now it's become pretty much USELESS due to your recent change. Please allow clipboard managers have access to the Android clipboard.
js...@gmail.com
As an IT professional of over 25 years now since the Novell days, network and systems administration, databases, security and Telecom I find this clipboard access blocking to be a serious overreach. Copy pasting on a phone esp, adds to safety, speed and efficiency for those of us who use it like a computer.... That just happens to make calls too.
As a business owner, my phone is definitely a computer. I run my entire business from it and my laptop which is Windows based, and if Microsoft can pull it off, you most certainly can.
Please tell me you aren't letting Microsoft, your public enemy number 1... Best you? Evidently they are because their clipboard and history manager in Windows 10 actually works quite well and I'm calling you out about it. Shame shame Google. (Wagging finger)
Blocking this is ridiculous. It makes my use of my phone MORE dangerous because when mobile I cannot QUICKLY recall common things like my signature from my clipboard. Instead I have to use another app like OneNote or Google Keep to create my own clipboards which get LOST within load time and my plethora of other notes. It's a nightmare, that you've created and that has reduced my corporate efficiency multi fold. Just makes me want to switch back to an iPhoney.
As a business owner, my phone is definitely a computer. I run my entire business from it and my laptop which is Windows based, and if Microsoft can pull it off, you most certainly can.
Please tell me you aren't letting Microsoft, your public enemy number 1... Best you? Evidently they are because their clipboard and history manager in Windows 10 actually works quite well and I'm calling you out about it. Shame shame Google. (Wagging finger)
Blocking this is ridiculous. It makes my use of my phone MORE dangerous because when mobile I cannot QUICKLY recall common things like my signature from my clipboard. Instead I have to use another app like OneNote or Google Keep to create my own clipboards which get LOST within load time and my plethora of other notes. It's a nightmare, that you've created and that has reduced my corporate efficiency multi fold. Just makes me want to switch back to an iPhoney.
di...@gmail.com
Please, restore this functionality.
sa...@gmail.com
We need clipboard
mi...@gmail.com
Please restore this permission, important app functionality depends on it. Maybe add extra confirmation or something if needed to protect users from malicious apps?
le...@gmail.com
Hey WTF! My S10 was just updated with A10 & is further again turning into a Crapple. Every update cripples more great apps. The G-Nazis strike again. Pardon me if I don't salute.
ke...@gmail.com
I cant use my clipboard any more!!!! I love you Google, but WTF !!!🙃☹😖
hs...@gmail.com
GOOGLE Please give us the ability to allow apps that we need and we trust to access the clipboard. This was one of the biggest advantages (or apps) we were using in everyday tasks.
st...@gmail.com
How the hell do I roll back android to a version that allows clipboard managers this is insanity. We demand the ability to use clipboard apps otherwise what makes Android better than iOs?
me...@gmail.com
Ruining Google and Android with call record blocking and clipboard blocking. Issues like this is why i went for Android over iCrapple. You're absolutely ruining the platform with these Nazi control tactics. As a lifelong supporter I'm disappointed and disgusted in the Android 10 downgrades.
ka...@gmail.com
One of my sons, a web developer, is switching away from Android because of
this and other stupid things the Android product managers are doing.
Karl
On Sun, Dec 22, 2019 at 11:16 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
this and other stupid things the Android product managers are doing.
Karl
On Sun, Dec 22, 2019 at 11:16 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
me...@gmail.com
Disappointed with this change and the change to call log access. Let the user decide. I use clipstack for managing clipboard items and my company's CRM stopped logging calls - which was a major feature for me
pl...@gmail.com
Seriously what the fuck?
I'm going back to 9. Who on earth signed off this utterly stupid idea?
Roll that back. Above are valid technical reasons. if they not matter, do it for emotional reasons: I hate this! I rely on clipboard 80% of my user scenarios. You added a myriad of clicks to my life. thanks for nothing, asshats.
I'm going back to 9. Who on earth signed off this utterly stupid idea?
Roll that back. Above are valid technical reasons. if they not matter, do it for emotional reasons: I hate this! I rely on clipboard 80% of my user scenarios. You added a myriad of clicks to my life. thanks for nothing, asshats.
co...@gmail.com
Why? It's ridiculous not to allow clipboard. Please roll it back. Your removing accessibility and productivity on platforms designed to help increase both.
Stop it..
Stop it..
al...@gmail.com
I hope Google will reconsider its policy of banning clipboard managers in Andriod 10.
Google should specifically examine what some of these clipboard managers do and probably address that on need basis.
Easy copy, for instance, one of the best clipboard managers can be given an exclusion.
Google should specifically examine what some of these clipboard managers do and probably address that on need basis.
Easy copy, for instance, one of the best clipboard managers can be given an exclusion.
kg...@gmail.com
You have created a HUGE inconvenience by banning clipboard access for clipboard managers in Android 10.
Who was the genius who decided to sign this off not thinking of the trade-offs of productivity and ease of use? Where was the human-centered design logic in doing this?
Really disappointed after upgrading to Android 10 and I will advise people not to do it.
Who was the genius who decided to sign this off not thinking of the trade-offs of productivity and ease of use? Where was the human-centered design logic in doing this?
Really disappointed after upgrading to Android 10 and I will advise people not to do it.
go...@gmail.com
Dear Google, I can't tolerate my android phone without clipboard access functionality. I rely on it. These features were the difference between android and iOS. These were the plus points of android. By disabling it, users have to think before buying an android smartphone. Why are you opting bad things from iOS?
di...@gmail.com
Commenting here to add my voice to this concern. Instead of all together removing access to clipboard, why can't you just implement using permission manager so that users can allow access to clipboard. There are many users out there who are more concerned about functionality rather than privacy. I agree that privacy is important but atleast let the end users decide on whether to grant access to clipboard or not. This will serve larger audience. Thank you.
te...@gmail.com
Agreed with previous commenters. This breaks apps I trust with my privacy.
95...@gmail.com
just upgraded to android 10 and was horrified to see I cannot use clipboard managers anymore. I will have to root my phone and flash a Pie rom just to be able to continue using this, dark mode be damned. stupid, stupid, stupid decision.
ie...@gmail.com
This sucks. What a terrible choice.
ja...@gmail.com
Please restore the clipboard access for apps, so that we may all have a truly happy new year.
ge...@gmail.com
It's such a terrible move by Google totally destroying so many amazing apps that we have been using for years now
ce...@gmail.com
Please restore this feature!
ja...@gmail.com
Restore please
lu...@gmail.com
Please restore this, a few of my favourite primary apps have ceased to work :(
ps...@gmail.com
Google, you have removed one of the best functionalities my phone had: copy any phone number, wait for popup to offer "WhatsApp" and just go there. Now it's horrible horrible horrible. Please bring back this feature asap!
cy...@gmail.com
Google, you've had MANY comments on this issue. Do you intend to address this issue or not? We deserve a response because as users and developers we need to know if there's a chance that this issue will be addressed or if we need to move on without any further changes. As developers we have workarounds but they all are terrible for our users (ie making the user relaunch our apps in order to let the app read the clipboard vs catching the clipboard in the background as they've been used to). So we need to know whether to hold out hope of having a permission request that our users can accept (much preferred) vs training our users to jump through hoops. We've waited long enough for a response. Google... Please help us with this.
lg...@gmail.com
It's a big letdown that Android 10 blocks all background clip managers. How's this making there phone less secure? Google is going on a slippery slope since Pichai at the helm.
sp...@gmail.com
Please restore immediately!!
as...@gmail.com
i want clipboard 😭😭😭😭😭
in...@gmail.com
I want my clipboard back!
jc...@gmail.com
Adding my voice: bring back clipboard managers.
People who actually use Android thoroughly obviously know how important this is. The restriction of this feature only tells us the devs are not using this feature at all.
People who actually use Android thoroughly obviously know how important this is. The restriction of this feature only tells us the devs are not using this feature at all.
tr...@gmail.com
One more for the chorus. Don't know why you keep making Android more like IOS, but this is something that should be built into Android, not banned from it. Almost as stupid as killing the ability to x out of an app.
im...@gmail.com
This feature was often used by me to create fast notes.. and now I can't use my clipboard manager? What the..
And why can't I decide - should I give an app access to clipboard or not?
Please bring clipboard back.
And why can't I decide - should I give an app access to clipboard or not?
Please bring clipboard back.
ju...@gmail.com
pa...@gmail.com
Frustrated and disappointed with this decision. Please reverse and allow us to choose.
tm...@gmail.com
123461156
pr...@gmail.com
Tout à fait d'accord, I really need my clipboard for my job !
le...@gmail.com
Very disappointed you guys removed accesse to the Clipboard in Android 10
ra...@gmail.com
Damn I need this back !!!!!
mo...@gmail.com
Please bring this back!!! I use this for managing my receipts on the phone. Now I'm stuck with manually typing in the text because the useful clipboard before doesn't work anymore.
gs...@gmail.com
You broke my clipboard app that makes my life so much easier! Please rescind this decision!
ev...@gmail.com
Why, just why! I really do like my clipboards. My saddest day of Microsoft was when they took away the clipboard from Office. Please, oh please rescind this.
ed...@gmail.com
My most useful, functional apps were the Clip History apps "Clipper" and "AndClip" I constantly use them in doing web research. Had I known that background clips would be disabled I would never have updated my Note 10+ to Android 10.
At the very least you should let me disable this change if I want. You sure did not warn me before the update began.
Please help me with this,
Ed Grossheim
At the very least you should let me disable this change if I want. You sure did not warn me before the update began.
Please help me with this,
Ed Grossheim
ak...@gmail.com
I am not a developer, but I am very disappointed. My favorite application for easy copying stopped working on android 10. The ease of interacting with the phone disappeared, it makes me sad
jo...@gmail.com
As a photographer, at an event, I try to post 2 or 3 times a night to social media photos from the event. I don't have time to enter hash tags and info Everytime, and rely on a clipboard to copy/cut/paste to expedite this.
Honestly this is the kinda of petty tweeking I would expect from apple not from Android. Please reinstate this function
Honestly this is the kinda of petty tweeking I would expect from apple not from Android. Please reinstate this function
ju...@gmail.com
Confused
Get Outlook for Android<https://aka.ms/ghei36 >
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2020 2:10:03 PM
To: b-system+-187731804@google.com <b-system+-187731804@google.com>
Cc: justinenicole2012@gmail.com <justinenicole2012@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
hotlist (+): Google Domain<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/710308 >
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 >
status: Assigned
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 >
duplicate issue: 128582282<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 >
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 >, Google Domain<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/710308 >, Platform<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 >
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTrackerhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 > where you have the role: starred.
Unsubscribe from this issue.<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true >
Get Outlook for Android<
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2020 2:10:03 PM
To: b-system+-187731804@google.com <b-system+-187731804@google.com>
Cc: justinenicole2012@gmail.com <justinenicole2012@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
Changed
hotlist (+): Google Domain<
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<
status: Assigned
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<
duplicate issue: 128582282<
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.<
ja...@gmail.com
Wow I just lost a ton of text finding out about this way to make your jobs easier taking our freedom away.
ni...@gmail.com
This is not funny or secure at all. This is serious enough to tempt me to switch back to ios. Undo this major mistake, please.
gi...@gmail.com
Terrible. Being able to access several clipboard items at all times without having to type it again is a must. You need to renable this function. We don't have to hack android 10 to do it. You guys are not Apple.
st...@gmail.com
For me this is the main reason not to update to android 10. For me the clipboard reader is super useful. Please add this functionality again
sp...@gmail.com
This is VERY annoying. The whole reason I use Android instead of Apple is because I have more control. Don't take that away.
ve...@gmail.com
If I had known of this clipboard issue before updating to android 10, things would have been so different. I am currently trying to find a way to downgrade, flash or remove the android 10 update. Another Google power play to remove control from their user base and more than. Likely, monitor clipboards for user data gathering, just another data mining technique one wonders?
fi...@gmail.com
Good god, google has become a joke on itself. Unbelievable.
fi...@gmail.com
Android 10 is a useless mess in so many ways. Clearly no Quality Assurance auditing going on. Brand new Pixel and I'm going to give it to relatives and get a Pinephone when released. It will be broken too but at least it's worth fixing and is a platform with a future.
ch...@gmail.com
Upgraded from the S8 to Pixel 4... where is my clipboard?!?!!?
Download an app... blocked?!?!?!
WTF?
Download an app... blocked?!?!?!
WTF?
ro...@gmail.com
One more.... Please bring it back (or have a reasonable fix) FTR
ya...@gmail.com
Yes i live in china and i rely on it. To copy paste many items and also google translates function "tap to translate"
co...@gmail.com
Please bring back
na...@gmail.com
Nil
ar...@gmail.com
this issue annoys me too
How do I starr an issue btw
How do I starr an issue btw
bi...@gmail.com
I'm also missing clipboard stack manager.
ne...@gmail.com
Please give us a fix to use a clipboard manager. Have tried several from Google Play and all fail to work. I can't get results from GBoard.
Really miss having a clipboard manager for my Pixel 2 XL.
Thank you.
Really miss having a clipboard manager for my Pixel 2 XL.
Thank you.
tu...@gmail.com
While clipboard managers may pose a security risk, they also offer extremely useful functionality. They are so useful in fact, that for those of us who are used to using them, losing them feels crippling!!!
Rather than disallowing them, please consider simply adding a checkbox--along with some information explaining the risks and how to mitigate them--that the user must check in order to grant this permission.
PLEASE GIVE BACK OUR CLIPBOARD MANAGERS ! ! !
Rather than disallowing them, please consider simply adding a checkbox--along with some information explaining the risks and how to mitigate them--that the user must check in order to grant this permission.
PLEASE GIVE BACK OUR CLIPBOARD MANAGERS ! ! !
ra...@gmail.com
Please allow kdeconnect to share clipboard between the PC and the phone. This was the most useful feature of kdeconnect,
dh...@gmail.com
Until this is fixed I share or copy everything to email. This better get fixed.
cy...@gmail.com
Google people, we saw the movement yesterday related to hotlists... but we have no way to understand what the heck that means. We app developers were encouraged when this bug go moved to a P1, but we haven't been given any other sign that all these pleas from devs and users are being heard and if we should hold out hope that Google is considering accommodation for clipboard manager apps and other novel, valuable apps or if we should give up and move on to other opportunities. Months of requests from users and devs on this thread should speak to the need for accommodation. Can we PLEASE get some status update as to whether this topic is actually open or not?
st...@gmail.com
Hear hear. It's been a while now, an update would be appreciated.
On Tue, Jan 28, 2020, 2:57 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
On Tue, Jan 28, 2020, 2:57 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ba...@gmail.com
Please android is the BEST SMART PHONE OS but PLEASE NEXT UPDATE show the POP UP FOR EASY COPY app, it's really usefull
Please.... Please
Please.... Please
mo...@gmail.com
With the next update, we need Clipboard Manager with permission, Why Google does not add it with permission to user.
dr...@gmail.com
As a user of various clipboard manager apps, I, also, really hope Google will find a way to allow apps to continue to have clipboard access. Please restore this capability.
ba...@gmail.com
This is yet another decision that Google has made on my behalf that limits use on MY device. This is yet another instance that Google is telling me as a customer that I should look into services and devices other than Google. I should not have to hack my phone after each update to maintain functionality of apps Ive decided to use. Good job Google on alienating your customer base with yet another bad decision on your customers behalf.
fi...@gmail.com
Let's face it- Android started playing badly with competing apps years ago
and Android 10 has exploded many of the best and most needed apps. At the
same time, 10 has incorporated inferior watered-down versions of these apps
as built-in features.
On Mon, Jan 27, 2020, 12:42 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
and Android 10 has exploded many of the best and most needed apps. At the
same time, 10 has incorporated inferior watered-down versions of these apps
as built-in features.
On Mon, Jan 27, 2020, 12:42 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ga...@gmail.com
Fuck you shower of bastards. I loved that app. You cannot leave well enough alone. I wouldn't have upgraded if I had known. Fuck you again
en...@gmail.com
Totally agree, "always good to see Android thinking seriously about privacy/security issues" is all well and good, but not when it's forced without exception - we should have the option to allow/deny access to these functions on a per-app basis just as we can for many other things.
eh...@gmail.com
Clipboard Tracking and call recording was cutting through GOOGLE. Since Samsung Galaxy S3 till the Note 10+ I'm an Androider.
My next Phone will be an IPHONE with IOS.
Till now doesn't any Reason to change the System, but just now. Even this features does not exist in IOS too, but there are better security and filemanagement.
Adios GOOGLE and ANDROID!
My next Phone will be an IPHONE with IOS.
Till now doesn't any Reason to change the System, but just now. Even this features does not exist in IOS too, but there are better security and filemanagement.
Adios GOOGLE and ANDROID!
be...@gmail.com
What the hell is this? Literally, who asked for this? Terrible idea. This will be a clear indicator if google listens to their users.
ju...@gmail.com
What is this
Get Outlook for Android<https://aka.ms/ghei36 >
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Sunday, February 2, 2020 11:35:07 PM
To: b-system+-187731804@google.com <b-system+-187731804@google.com>
Cc: justinenicole2012@gmail.com <justinenicole2012@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
be...@gmail.com addedhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment216 >:
What the hell is this? Literally, who asked for this? Terrible idea. This will be a clear indicator if google listens to their users.
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 >
status: Assigned
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 >
duplicate issue: 128582282<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 >
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 >, Platform<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 >
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTrackerhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 > where you have the role: starred.
Unsubscribe from this issue.<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true >
Get Outlook for Android<
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Sunday, February 2, 2020 11:35:07 PM
To: b-system+-187731804@google.com <b-system+-187731804@google.com>
Cc: justinenicole2012@gmail.com <justinenicole2012@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
Changed
be...@gmail.com added
What the hell is this? Literally, who asked for this? Terrible idea. This will be a clear indicator if google listens to their users.
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<
status: Assigned
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<
duplicate issue: 128582282<
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.<
dh...@gmail.com
(find in page) #workarounds. We need solutions and work arounds folks.
I share to email (mine) at the moment. I am looking at search and accessibility as hacks.
Note that share allows a functional programming paradigm. With one extra click.
Q: Developers: What options are available with overl ays and floating widgets?
I recommend share plus your existing UI. Am I wrong? Problems?
I share to email (mine) at the moment. I am looking at search and accessibility as hacks.
Note that share allows a functional programming paradigm. With one extra click.
Q: Developers: What options are available with overl ays and floating widgets?
I recommend share plus your existing UI. Am I wrong? Problems?
dh...@gmail.com
I think the integrated and somehow always floating keyboard is a good idea I am also looking at. Ie tiny, floating and transparent when input isn't requested. It presents other opportunities. Dunno.
ta...@gmail.com
I believe google is trying to make us safer... However, by eliminating the clipboard copy feature it seems an app I love useless. Please bring this function back and let us enable the function. What's the point of having an android if we are being limited like this? Please bring it back! So upset that I did the upgrade
sp...@gmail.com
jo...@gmail.com
I want my clipboard back!
la...@gmail.com
Ultra frustrating.
I copy paste 10 sentences and their translation into my Anki flashcard app.
Already since I got a new phone I lost the default clipboard functionality to stay available easily. Nowadays every time I lose focus by changing my entry box to get to the next one, i had to tap and tap and tap and look for the line i wanted to copy. So after searching I found this amazing app Smart Clip that has an overlay that stay on top until i close it, and it is so much quicker to do my menial tasks.
ENTER ANDROID 10 and now I have a cool black look I didnt ask for, security protection I cannot bypass, but can't use my phone to accomplish my daily tasks. I've had to use my old Samsung S7 with it's smashed screen to do my work. I have an Android phone rather than an iphone because of the freedom to do what I want, productively. If I wanted a phone for numpties I' d get an iphone.
Please make these security options bypassable for trusted apps rather than deciding for us.
Thanks for all the work so far on Android, most of my user experience has been great.
I copy paste 10 sentences and their translation into my Anki flashcard app.
Already since I got a new phone I lost the default clipboard functionality to stay available easily. Nowadays every time I lose focus by changing my entry box to get to the next one, i had to tap and tap and tap and look for the line i wanted to copy. So after searching I found this amazing app Smart Clip that has an overlay that stay on top until i close it, and it is so much quicker to do my menial tasks.
ENTER ANDROID 10 and now I have a cool black look I didnt ask for, security protection I cannot bypass, but can't use my phone to accomplish my daily tasks. I've had to use my old Samsung S7 with it's smashed screen to do my work. I have an Android phone rather than an iphone because of the freedom to do what I want, productively. If I wanted a phone for numpties I' d get an iphone.
Please make these security options bypassable for trusted apps rather than deciding for us.
Thanks for all the work so far on Android, most of my user experience has been great.
tu...@gmail.com
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE: GRANT USER APPS CLIPBOARD PERMISSION
We used to have it, we are used to having it, we want it back!
WE NEED IT !!! We DESPERATELY WANT IT BACK ! ! ! PRETTY PLEASE!?!?!?
On Tue, Jan 28, 2020 at 10:57 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
We used to have it, we are used to having it, we want it back!
WE NEED IT !!! We DESPERATELY WANT IT BACK ! ! ! PRETTY PLEASE!?!?!?
On Tue, Jan 28, 2020 at 10:57 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
sr...@gmail.com
Ditto!
jc...@gmail.com
If this will ever be FIXED (yes, it is a BUG not a feature), it must be backported to Android 10.
jo...@gmail.com
Come on, we need this, clipboard apps and a lot of other apps have been using this to provide great utilities, bring it back!
mb...@gmail.com
WTH?? There is no good reason for this. Your users are not children. Let us decide.
os...@gmail.com
The clipboard managers are apps that a lot of people use, it's true that not all the apps must have access to the clipboard because it can't be safe but... There are many apps that are useful for users and need the permission to read the clipboard. Please, manage this problem and allow clipboard manager to work as same as allways.
ra...@gmail.com
Please do not remove the permission.
I use an app that depends on it trip work.
I use an app that depends on it trip work.
ha...@gmail.com
Give us back our phones Google! We want our clipboards back!
hi...@gmail.com
Actually there is no point if doing this..
It's nonsense... please start app.. its my day to day app. Which i use for many activities...
It's nonsense... please start app.. its my day to day app. Which i use for many activities...
ju...@gmail.com
dh...@gmail.com
This is hardly a power user issue but I imagine it will ignored given the lack of traffic here. We shall see.
ka...@gmail.com
Google! How dare you keep us from seeing our own data we've put in the
clipboard? It's OURS, NOT YOURS. We decide how secure it needs to be, not
you. Stop trying to be like Apple when you grow up! My son dumped his
android phone for an iPhone last week because of this kind of evil crap. Do
No Evil used to be your slogan. It appears you dumped that and now it's "Do
Logs Of Evil To Our Users"
Do you not know we pay your salaries?
GIVE US OUR STUFF BACK!!!
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
My "ComeUntoChrist.org" profile:http://comeuntochrist.org/me/1GCM
<http://mormon.org/me/1GCM >
---
On Sun, Feb 16, 2020 at 9:32 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
clipboard? It's OURS, NOT YOURS. We decide how secure it needs to be, not
you. Stop trying to be like Apple when you grow up! My son dumped his
android phone for an iPhone last week because of this kind of evil crap. Do
No Evil used to be your slogan. It appears you dumped that and now it's "Do
Logs Of Evil To Our Users"
Do you not know we pay your salaries?
GIVE US OUR STUFF BACK!!!
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
My "ComeUntoChrist.org" profile:
<
---
On Sun, Feb 16, 2020 at 9:32 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ul...@gmail.com
Well, Apple seems to support clipboard managers AFAIK.
el...@gmail.com
Come on, Google. Give us full use of our clipboards back. I had to download a third party app to be able to copy URLs to share with friends.
cy...@gmail.com
Note that the first developer preview of Android 11 dropped today. There is an issue open in that domain that asks the Android team to solve this (and allow clipboard access again). Please weigh in at https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/132684916 . This is the period when Android team is likely to consider making changes to the policies and if accepted in Android 11, they may issue an Android 10 update to offer consistency.
as...@gmail.com
please Google support clipboard 😭😭😭
jr...@gmail.com
I didn't read all of the comments here but I am with Google on this. The clipboard is sensitive and I'd rather not have it be exploited. You can make a sharing app or bubble note taking app but these apps that overengineer a simple function simply should not have existed in the first place.
Clipboard access has slipped under the radar where any app could declare the permission yet the user is never prompted when an app feels like using the permission. LineageOS' Privacy Guard was a solution but it was clunky at best. I don't want yet another choice to toggle for all apps just because "clipboard manager" apps want to read the clipboard. It's too niche.
I realize some people are upset but you can adapt. You have no way of knowing how many apps have been reading your clipboard for the past decade.
Clipboard access has slipped under the radar where any app could declare the permission yet the user is never prompted when an app feels like using the permission. LineageOS' Privacy Guard was a solution but it was clunky at best. I don't want yet another choice to toggle for all apps just because "clipboard manager" apps want to read the clipboard. It's too niche.
I realize some people are upset but you can adapt. You have no way of knowing how many apps have been reading your clipboard for the past decade.
ro...@gmail.com
"Adapt", exactly, how, please? I use a clipboard manager to transfer
text between apps, to compose or fill forms, primarily. As it was, I
could choose from a list of copied items in the clipboard manager,
perhaps numerous copies in one app or in various apps, to perform this
task. As it is, now, I can only have one item on the clipboard to
paste, then go back to the different app to copy/paste the next, one at
a time, over and over. This usage scenario must represent a fairly
large "niche", iianm.
I appreciate there are security concerns and, always, financial
concerns. I am not a software engineer but one of the end users who
spend thousands of dollars on the end product, such as my Pixel 3. It
would be nice if Google software engineers could devise a solution that
serves security and the practical needs of end users like myself at the
same time. WRT "financial concerns", it has been my end user
experience over many years that Google "support" is more concerned with
that than anything else and I've come to believe that, were I on fire,
Sergey wouldn't be moved to piss on me to put the fire out unless there
was a nickel in it for him. So, please, "adapt", exactly, how, other
than the standard expectation of the end user to bend over and lube?
Rolf
On 2/21/20 5:29 AM, buganizer-system@google.com wrote:
text between apps, to compose or fill forms, primarily. As it was, I
could choose from a list of copied items in the clipboard manager,
perhaps numerous copies in one app or in various apps, to perform this
task. As it is, now, I can only have one item on the clipboard to
paste, then go back to the different app to copy/paste the next, one at
a time, over and over. This usage scenario must represent a fairly
large "niche", iianm.
I appreciate there are security concerns and, always, financial
concerns. I am not a software engineer but one of the end users who
spend thousands of dollars on the end product, such as my Pixel 3. It
would be nice if Google software engineers could devise a solution that
serves security and the practical needs of end users like myself at the
same time. WRT "financial concerns", it has been my end user
experience over many years that Google "support" is more concerned with
that than anything else and I've come to believe that, were I on fire,
Sergey wouldn't be moved to piss on me to put the fire out unless there
was a nickel in it for him. So, please, "adapt", exactly, how, other
than the standard expectation of the end user to bend over and lube?
Rolf
On 2/21/20 5:29 AM, buganizer-system@google.com wrote:
jr...@gmail.com
ma...@gmail.com
jr...@gmail.com: "yet the user is never prompted"
Instead of "fixing" a problem in a feature by nuking the feature and telling every user of it to suck it up, maybe the problem can be fixed instead by tackling the issue itself: make the clipboard permission explicitly granted.
People who support badly thought-out knee-jerk reactions that undermine many people's needs while a real solution that works for everyone is ignored, are why we can't have nice things.
Instead of "fixing" a problem in a feature by nuking the feature and telling every user of it to suck it up, maybe the problem can be fixed instead by tackling the issue itself: make the clipboard permission explicitly granted.
People who support badly thought-out knee-jerk reactions that undermine many people's needs while a real solution that works for everyone is ignored, are why we can't have nice things.
jr...@gmail.com
I have a note taking app called Keep. Copy text, open keep, paste text in Keep. Or I highlight the text, hit share to Keep which creates a note of the selected text.
Adapted.
Adapted.
ma...@gmail.com
jr...@gmail.com: <Keep app example>
Why should people have to adapt and change their workflow, lose the apps they're familiar with and possibly have no replacement for, when instead the problem can be solved at its root much more simply and leave everything users want to keep just as it is? Why choose an inferior solution? Storage access is also a sensitive permission, even more so than clipboard access, and that works just fine as a regular prompted permission. The same can be done with clipboard access, and then _everyone_ would be happy without losing anything (just hit a 1-time prompt as people already need to do for everything else)
Why should people have to adapt and change their workflow, lose the apps they're familiar with and possibly have no replacement for, when instead the problem can be solved at its root much more simply and leave everything users want to keep just as it is? Why choose an inferior solution? Storage access is also a sensitive permission, even more so than clipboard access, and that works just fine as a regular prompted permission. The same can be done with clipboard access, and then _everyone_ would be happy without losing anything (just hit a 1-time prompt as people already need to do for everything else)
jr...@gmail.com
That means billions of users have to manage yet another permission for the sake of a handful of users. I used to root, install XPosed, install XPrivacyLUA, and forcedly enforce such things as strict scoped storage, per-app location accuracy fuzzing (still on my wishlist), MAC address randomization, and deny clipboard to address all of these things now being solved with the most elegant solutions Google just rolled out. Sorry. Not sorry.
ro...@gmail.com
Thanks for the workaround but, as such, it adds more to my workload.
In search of efficient utility from that for which I already incur
sufficient workload to support.
On 2/21/20 5:57 AM, buganizer-system@google.com wrote:
In search of efficient utility from that for which I already incur
sufficient workload to support.
On 2/21/20 5:57 AM, buganizer-system@google.com wrote:
jp...@gmail.com
Please let's find another way, it is so usefull to have a clipboard manager
di...@gmail.com
As a workaround, I use the app clipstack which requires running command through adb for clipboard permission. It is working fine for me and I am using this as an alternative to clipper+ app which was my go-to app for managing clipboard. Here is the app I am using : https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager
ma...@gmail.com
jr...@gmail.com: tediously micromanaging every permission of every app on your phone sounds a lot more like the tiny niche usecase than using any sort of clipboard functionality like cross-device copying+pasting. Also, besides clipboard access there are dozens of other permissions, why don't we remove all of those as well then so you need not micromanage those anymore either? I find "billons of users needing to manage yet another permission for just a handful people" a ridiculous exaggeration. Bringing clipboard access in line with the dozens of other permissions introduces no new burdens, leaves all use cases intact, and uniformizes permissions, while yours/google's is a knee-jerk that ruins many basis usecases unnecessarily.
jr...@gmail.com
If you think you using a note app is more difficult than me unlocking my bootloader, flashing a custom recovery, rooting my device, installing XPosed, installing XPrivacyLUA, creating a LUA script just to deny read clipboard access... Well gee.
Do you know how many passwords are copied to the clipboard? Does your clipboard manager app have Internet access yet no apparent sync features? Could that same developer make a second app that takes the clipboard manager contents and send them elsewhere? 5 of the 5 clipboard manager I just installed all do either of those things. You do realize the Angry Birds game on your device could have been reading and uploading your clipboard contents encrypted to somewhere for the past 10 years
Do you know how many passwords are copied to the clipboard? Does your clipboard manager app have Internet access yet no apparent sync features? Could that same developer make a second app that takes the clipboard manager contents and send them elsewhere? 5 of the 5 clipboard manager I just installed all do either of those things. You do realize the Angry Birds game on your device could have been reading and uploading your clipboard contents encrypted to somewhere for the past 10 years
ma...@gmail.com
jr...@gmail.com: what on earth are you raving about? Maybe read people's words/understand their point before you use some wild counterargument that has nothing to do with what was said.
Just make clipboard access the same as the other five dozen permissions: explicit and prompted. No more sneaky access and stolen data, unless you mistakenly trust a malicious app, which is the risk users sign up for with _all_ permissions. No use cases undermined or changed, no need to re-tool yourself, no new apps needed, no technical burdens, extremely minor inconvenience added (1-time permissions prompt the likes of which everyone already expects to get with every app install). It boggles my mind that this isn't what google went with and I have no idea as what kind of ridiculous contraption you visualize my simple suggestion in your mind.
Just make clipboard access the same as the other five dozen permissions: explicit and prompted. No more sneaky access and stolen data, unless you mistakenly trust a malicious app, which is the risk users sign up for with _all_ permissions. No use cases undermined or changed, no need to re-tool yourself, no new apps needed, no technical burdens, extremely minor inconvenience added (1-time permissions prompt the likes of which everyone already expects to get with every app install). It boggles my mind that this isn't what google went with and I have no idea as what kind of ridiculous contraption you visualize my simple suggestion in your mind.
jr...@gmail.com
Best practice should outweigh the cleverness.
Let's hypothetically make both of us happy. Promote it to a user facing toggle. Toggled off by default. And it must request clipboard access per app where the originating text was copied. If I copy a bank account number from one app I would like that not to end up in my clipboard manager app. I also do not want my clipboard manager to have network access. So Internet access must also be a permission we see, toggled off by default. I also want an advanced firewall to block the third party ad networks embedded within the clipboard manager from reading the clipboard contents as well, so I would like to restrict network connectivity to just those destinations needed for clipboard syncing to function.
All of this because you want to save a few bucks
Let's hypothetically make both of us happy. Promote it to a user facing toggle. Toggled off by default. And it must request clipboard access per app where the originating text was copied. If I copy a bank account number from one app I would like that not to end up in my clipboard manager app. I also do not want my clipboard manager to have network access. So Internet access must also be a permission we see, toggled off by default. I also want an advanced firewall to block the third party ad networks embedded within the clipboard manager from reading the clipboard contents as well, so I would like to restrict network connectivity to just those destinations needed for clipboard syncing to function.
All of this because you want to save a few bucks
ma...@gmail.com
jr...@gmail.com also, if you think "you using a note app" and such trivial answers are acceptable compromises for all the existing usecases of _the clipboard_ on a device, well gee indeed.
As for your "both of us happy" post, you just made up an entire highly contrived usecase/mechanism that isn't currently in use, and then dismissed that as too contrived to be worth it. How is this an argument exactly? And what few bucks are you talking about?
I just want my clipboard history and cross-device-sharing to keep working as-is, while everyone can have privacy-consciousness in the form of clipboard access being an explicit permission just like all other data access permissions. There's really no need to overengineer these things nor nuke usecases from orbit, and highly contrived situations hardly outweigh common use cases.
As for your "both of us happy" post, you just made up an entire highly contrived usecase/mechanism that isn't currently in use, and then dismissed that as too contrived to be worth it. How is this an argument exactly? And what few bucks are you talking about?
I just want my clipboard history and cross-device-sharing to keep working as-is, while everyone can have privacy-consciousness in the form of clipboard access being an explicit permission just like all other data access permissions. There's really no need to overengineer these things nor nuke usecases from orbit, and highly contrived situations hardly outweigh common use cases.
ma...@gmail.com
jr...@gmail.com perhaps there's one thing I want to clarify, though the context of this thread should make that unnecessary: what I'm talking about (and I think most people) is making _passive listening_ to the clipboard a permission, exactly to avoid eavesdropping. User-initiated clipboard reads/writes (Copy/Paste commands on selections) should obviously not go behind an annoying prompt you have to dismiss 100 times every day (which your contrived example about super finegrained permissions seems to be about). Take the current situation on older android versions, and add a permission prompt for apps that want to eavesdrop on the clipboard. As simple as that. Privacy issue (silent eavesdropping) solved, no use cases impacted, extra burden is practically nonexistant.
bj...@gmail.com
Please allow Clip Stack on Android smartphones because it ia very productive app !!
cy...@gmail.com
jr...@gmail.com if the need for clipboard access is as niche as you claim then you'll never be bothered with the permission request. If you're not a clipboard manager app user, then it's no additional pain for you because anything asking for the permission will be obviously not something you want to allow (or, more likely, you'll never even see the permission request because you'll never install an app that needs the permission). Removing a novel use case that differentiates Android from iOS and patching a security/privacy vector that has NEVER been exploited in the first place seems like throwing the baby out with the bathwater. A permission request is not so cumbersome that a user can't tolerate it. You could say that all permission requests are overly burdensome, but that's the pattern that has become the norm and it seems to work for most people. On desktop we have NO qualms or concerns about clipboard access. Any app can read the clipboard and Chrome is ADDING a permission request to their browser, so why is it okay for desktop and not mobile? Why the inconsistent policies? Trust the user to make good decisions and uninstall apps that don't provide the value they expected. The market has an uncanny way of helping make the right apps succeed.
st...@gmail.com
Your screwing up clipboard apps is a HUGE user fuckover!!! Android only keeps 20. NOT ENOUGH!!! WHYYYYYYY???????? Re-enable Clipstack!!
wo...@gmail.com
Why is the clipboard monitoring feature gone? I use it in every single second!!! This turns Android to be useless! Terrible Android! How can I rollback to Android 9?
vo...@gmail.com
Dear Google! Why do you think that ruining working process without even asking about my opinion is ok? I used app operating with clipboard in years, and it was ok to have possibility to able one app to use my clipboard. Now, as result of of your "caring" about me without my opinion, i must to invent a new way to work in Android or consider to roll back to Android 9. It's completely wrong approach. Sincerely not thank you
du...@gmail.com
You can lie to us all you want oh, but you did this so we would be forced to use your gboard clipboard. You are working your way towards monopolizing all apps and some of us can see this. Color it any color you want but it will still be crap brown to us. So disgusted with Google I think I'm going to use iOS from now on. I never thought I'd say that.
ki...@gmail.com
I want to use my clipboard app. Please fix this.
eu...@gmail.com
This is a ridiculous and unnecessary restriction and should be reversed as soon as possible. People have been complaining for almost one year, and you have yet to budge. That is not user friendly.
ki...@gmail.com
I take it Google will be releasing their own clipboard manager ??
Get rid of the competition first ?? 🤬
This decision sucks !!
It SEVERLY impacts my ability to run / manage my FB groups
- I'll have to move back to a PC instead of mobile / tablet
Get rid of the competition first ?? 🤬
This decision sucks !!
It SEVERLY impacts my ability to run / manage my FB groups
- I'll have to move back to a PC instead of mobile / tablet
cy...@gmail.com
Fun fact: this policy change in Android 10 broke a popular feature of Google's own Google Translate app. People are pretty upset about it here: https://support.google.com/translate/thread/13522087?hl=en
Google... please listen to the people who have voiced their opposition to this policy change and rebalance the policy. Many good alternatives have been proposed at this point: exceptions for foreground services, a prominent permission request, etc. It's your job to balance security/privacy and functionality. This is an area where you clearly were beating iOS for enabling creative apps to tackle REAL use cases and deliver value to users but this policy change destroyed that competitive advantage and turned Android into a copycat of iOS. What's worse is that this policy is completely inconsistent with other platforms you control! Chrome extensions for desktop allows reading the clipboard without any permission request, even when Chrome is in the background. Even on Android, Accessibility permission allows apps to read the entire screen of a user. Yes it has a scary permission request screen, but a lot of users who want the value of an app will jump through whatever hoops are put in their way. Your argument against a clipboard permission request was that "it would be inappropriate because users wouldn't understand what they were agreeing to" (I'm paraphrasing). That argument is thin, however, because if apps like Amazon Assistant ask the user for Accessibility permission to read the user's screen and users LOVE that app (high ratings, lots of installs). That is CLEAR evidence that some developers are able to create apps that "exploit" a permission to create new, novel, VALUABLE apps. It's these apps that are only available on Android that give you and advantage over iOS, not copying their privacy policies.
Lastly: if a security vector is theoretically vulnerable but never actually exploited... is it actually a threat? I haven't heard of any bad actor ever actually using the clipboard to retrieve and build lists of passwords or other sensitive information. Can you reference a case of this ever happening? On the contrary, OnePlus had a huge story for a minute because there was suspicion that they were doing something nefarious with clipboard data (it turned out to be nothing):https://www.extremetech.com/mobile/261888-oneplus-may-accidentally-transmitted-clipboard-data-chinese-server
This is to make the point that people are more savvy than you give them credit for. Bad actors will be thwarted by either an individual user reading negative reviews/ratings, reading and understanding a required permission request that describes an app "having access to information that's copied and pasted" or a media outlet will discover a bad actor and shine light on them (at which point you can remove them from the app store).
Google... please listen to the people who have voiced their opposition to this policy change and rebalance the policy. Many good alternatives have been proposed at this point: exceptions for foreground services, a prominent permission request, etc. It's your job to balance security/privacy and functionality. This is an area where you clearly were beating iOS for enabling creative apps to tackle REAL use cases and deliver value to users but this policy change destroyed that competitive advantage and turned Android into a copycat of iOS. What's worse is that this policy is completely inconsistent with other platforms you control! Chrome extensions for desktop allows reading the clipboard without any permission request, even when Chrome is in the background. Even on Android, Accessibility permission allows apps to read the entire screen of a user. Yes it has a scary permission request screen, but a lot of users who want the value of an app will jump through whatever hoops are put in their way. Your argument against a clipboard permission request was that "it would be inappropriate because users wouldn't understand what they were agreeing to" (I'm paraphrasing). That argument is thin, however, because if apps like Amazon Assistant ask the user for Accessibility permission to read the user's screen and users LOVE that app (high ratings, lots of installs). That is CLEAR evidence that some developers are able to create apps that "exploit" a permission to create new, novel, VALUABLE apps. It's these apps that are only available on Android that give you and advantage over iOS, not copying their privacy policies.
Lastly: if a security vector is theoretically vulnerable but never actually exploited... is it actually a threat? I haven't heard of any bad actor ever actually using the clipboard to retrieve and build lists of passwords or other sensitive information. Can you reference a case of this ever happening? On the contrary, OnePlus had a huge story for a minute because there was suspicion that they were doing something nefarious with clipboard data (it turned out to be nothing):
This is to make the point that people are more savvy than you give them credit for. Bad actors will be thwarted by either an individual user reading negative reviews/ratings, reading and understanding a required permission request that describes an app "having access to information that's copied and pasted" or a media outlet will discover a bad actor and shine light on them (at which point you can remove them from the app store).
ti...@yahoo.com
Google, please figure out a way to allow these clipboard apps to work.
ka...@gmail.com
Google, please figure out a way to allow Easy Copy app to work. It absolute necessary app.
ka...@gmail.com
Please allow clipboard acces in android 10, its really necessary
pr...@gmail.com
I depend on my phone to accomplish much of my work as I am in meetings and traveling all day and away from my desktop. Not having the ability to do something as simple as copy and paste multiple things while working is absolutely ridiculous. How is this progress? How is this helping people to do more with the technology we have paid you for?? IT'S NOT. DO BETTER, GOOGLE. This may be the one instance when I really hope that someone hacks Google to work around an alleged security measure.
se...@gmail.com
This access should be option that user decide what it is..
You remove all access that makes valuable difference from ios... This is not true strategy... We like Android as flexible..
You remove all access that makes valuable difference from ios... This is not true strategy... We like Android as flexible..
dh...@gmail.com
ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!!
.
RE YOUR GARBAGE DEFAULT CLIPBOARD UI.
.ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!!
.
RE YOUR GARBAGE DEFAULT CLIPBOARD UI.
.
As a user, completing a large block of text.
As I simply type THREE CHARACTERS OF A WORD!!!
For crying out loud. You do this on most words.
.
Your random lazy clipboard control, which pops up randomly nearly anywhere when it shouldn't have been triggered...
.
RESULTS IN MY LOSING LARGE BLOCKS OF IMPORTANT TEXT!
.
HOW?
In the space to 1.5 seconds.
The first character is typed.
The CB control is wrongly popping up on top of the KB.
The strike of the second character does not hit character #2,
It hits SELECT ALL!
The garbage Google CB controls vanishes.
The rapid habituated typing of character #3 of any word...
Causes the entire text to be replaced with character #3...
Thus destroying an entire long post.
Where your only way to back this post up is to use the clipboard to make a copy.
.
YOU IDIOTS.
.
Yes. We get it. We know. You have no concern nor regard for marginal power users.
.
But you even have no regard for basic users and the developers having difficulty getting thier controls working with your unstable poorly implemented changes providing an extremely low quality CB UI control.
.
YOUR ARROGANCE IS SIMPLY ASTOUNDING.
DULY NOTED
EXPECT THIS RESPONSE TO APPEAR ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA..
NOT YOURS. THE ALTERNATE PRESS.
As a user, completing a large block of text.
As I simply type THREE CHARACTERS OF A WORD!!!
For crying out loud. You do this on most words.
.
Your random lazy clipboard control, which pops up randomly nearly anywhere when it shouldn't have been triggered...
.
RESULTS IN MY LOSING LARGE BLOCKS OF IMPORTANT TEXT!
.
HOW?
In the space to 1.5 seconds.
The first character is typed.
The CB control is wrongly popping up on top of the KB.
The strike of the second character does not hit character #2,
It hits SELECT ALL!
The garbage Google CB controls vanishes.
The rapid habituated typing of character #3 of any word...
Causes the entire text to be replaced with character #3...
Thus destroying an entire long post.
Where your only way to back this post up is to use the clipboard to make a copy.
.
YOU IDIOTS.
.
Yes. We get it. We know. You have no concern nor regard for marginal power users.
.
But you even have no regard for basic users and the developers having difficulty getting thier controls working with your unstable poorly implemented changes providing an extremely low quality CB UI control.
.
YOUR ARROGANCE IS SIMPLY ASTOUNDING.
DULY NOTED
EXPECT THIS RESPONSE TO APPEAR ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA..
NOT YOURS. THE ALTERNATE PRESS.
.
RE YOUR GARBAGE DEFAULT CLIPBOARD UI.
.ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!!
.
RE YOUR GARBAGE DEFAULT CLIPBOARD UI.
.
As a user, completing a large block of text.
As I simply type THREE CHARACTERS OF A WORD!!!
For crying out loud. You do this on most words.
.
Your random lazy clipboard control, which pops up randomly nearly anywhere when it shouldn't have been triggered...
.
RESULTS IN MY LOSING LARGE BLOCKS OF IMPORTANT TEXT!
.
HOW?
In the space to 1.5 seconds.
The first character is typed.
The CB control is wrongly popping up on top of the KB.
The strike of the second character does not hit character #2,
It hits SELECT ALL!
The garbage Google CB controls vanishes.
The rapid habituated typing of character #3 of any word...
Causes the entire text to be replaced with character #3...
Thus destroying an entire long post.
Where your only way to back this post up is to use the clipboard to make a copy.
.
YOU IDIOTS.
.
Yes. We get it. We know. You have no concern nor regard for marginal power users.
.
But you even have no regard for basic users and the developers having difficulty getting thier controls working with your unstable poorly implemented changes providing an extremely low quality CB UI control.
.
YOUR ARROGANCE IS SIMPLY ASTOUNDING.
DULY NOTED
EXPECT THIS RESPONSE TO APPEAR ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA..
NOT YOURS. THE ALTERNATE PRESS.
As a user, completing a large block of text.
As I simply type THREE CHARACTERS OF A WORD!!!
For crying out loud. You do this on most words.
.
Your random lazy clipboard control, which pops up randomly nearly anywhere when it shouldn't have been triggered...
.
RESULTS IN MY LOSING LARGE BLOCKS OF IMPORTANT TEXT!
.
HOW?
In the space to 1.5 seconds.
The first character is typed.
The CB control is wrongly popping up on top of the KB.
The strike of the second character does not hit character #2,
It hits SELECT ALL!
The garbage Google CB controls vanishes.
The rapid habituated typing of character #3 of any word...
Causes the entire text to be replaced with character #3...
Thus destroying an entire long post.
Where your only way to back this post up is to use the clipboard to make a copy.
.
YOU IDIOTS.
.
Yes. We get it. We know. You have no concern nor regard for marginal power users.
.
But you even have no regard for basic users and the developers having difficulty getting thier controls working with your unstable poorly implemented changes providing an extremely low quality CB UI control.
.
YOUR ARROGANCE IS SIMPLY ASTOUNDING.
DULY NOTED
EXPECT THIS RESPONSE TO APPEAR ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA..
NOT YOURS. THE ALTERNATE PRESS.
da...@gmail.com
I am very angry that Android 10 was forced onto me and now Clip Stack doesn't work! ***I use Clip Stack EVERY DAY!!!!!!! I use Clip Stack all of the time!!!!!!!*** You are ruining my ability to accomplish my tasks!!!!!!! Please make Clip Stack work again!!!!!!!
gp...@gmail.com
Do not remove clipboard functinality. NO. It's Essentials for many useful applications
da...@gmail.com
This forced update ruined so much of my work flow I use about 4 apps to manage my clipboard
da...@gmail.com
This is enough to make me not buy any phones above 10 I hate hate hate HATE HATE FORCED UPDATES!!!
de...@gmail.com
I rely on clipstack. This Android update has taken away so much. I rely on this app so if I copy something and I don't wish to have the information risk exposure I relied on clipstack to clear out the data.
fr...@gmail.com
Almost all of may daily smartphone activity rely on clipboard (clipstack).
Now Im having tireble time copying and pasting cells and formula in Excell.. That I have to retype all formula a hundred times or more over and over again. It seems my phone is not a smartphone anymore.
This Android 10 clipboard banned update doesnt help me at all.
Now Im having tireble time copying and pasting cells and formula in Excell.. That I have to retype all formula a hundred times or more over and over again. It seems my phone is not a smartphone anymore.
This Android 10 clipboard banned update doesnt help me at all.
ml...@gmail.com
Using a clipboard manager is extremely convenient, if you value freedom, please don't restrict.
tr...@gmail.com
I WANT MY CLIP STACK!!! I NEED MY CLIP STACK!!! PLEASE FIX IT! PRETTY PLEASE!
za...@gmail.com
let users make the choice, instead of making the choice for them! that's all about Android, and don't make it another ios, please!
----from a heavy user of dictionary apps which rely on this permission to run properly.
----from a heavy user of dictionary apps which rely on this permission to run properly.
ma...@gmail.com
I too am disgusted with Android 10. I have been a loyal new user of Android since leaving Palm OS.
I am the only Android user in my family; everyone else uses of The limited world of ios. I have stayed with Android due to the flexible operating system alarm me to utilize my device in the way I wish.
Removing third party access to the clipboard functionality is outrageous and has significantly decreased the usability of my device.
Please restore 3rd party access!
I am the only Android user in my family; everyone else uses of The limited world of ios. I have stayed with Android due to the flexible operating system alarm me to utilize my device in the way I wish.
Removing third party access to the clipboard functionality is outrageous and has significantly decreased the usability of my device.
Please restore 3rd party access!
ha...@gmail.com
From all this report issue not a single comment from google for a good faith of the user.
Omg... Why google even put issue tracker function anyway if thy dont bother to checked 😓😓😓
Omg... Why google even put issue tracker function anyway if thy dont bother to checked 😓😓😓
mo...@gmail.com
Adding my voice to this mess. I use both Clip Stack and Kdeconnect. This sucks.
cc...@google.com
Once again, thank you for submitting the feature request. This issue was discussed at length within our engineering teams, but in the end, we felt allowing applications to view the contents of the clipboard buffer while in the background posed security and privacy issues. Alternatives were discussed, but the current implementation is what we believe is the safest. We know that permission fatigue is a very real thing, and Android has a number of user permissions that were implemented in Android 10 to enhance platform safety.
lf...@gmail.com
The problem is that you continue to alienate power users. I understand catering to people who don't understand basic technology, but you need to present options for power users to actually use their devices, because it seems like Google is moving closer and closer to Apple in terms of restricting us.
Even if you had "advanced permissions", and disallowed these apps on your store (similar to UWP restricted capabilities), that would be fine. It's the fact that you're adding in OS-level restrictions that annoys me, because you are taking away functionality that I have paid for, and I do not have any good options for getting it back. If I have to sideload useful apps, so be it, but you are even getting in the way of that.
I just don't see how you can find this to be an acceptable way to treat your users or the developers building for your platform. If I wanted an iPhone, I would have bought one. It's about time that Google stopped trying to clone that experience on Android.
Even if you had "advanced permissions", and disallowed these apps on your store (similar to UWP restricted capabilities), that would be fine. It's the fact that you're adding in OS-level restrictions that annoys me, because you are taking away functionality that I have paid for, and I do not have any good options for getting it back. If I have to sideload useful apps, so be it, but you are even getting in the way of that.
I just don't see how you can find this to be an acceptable way to treat your users or the developers building for your platform. If I wanted an iPhone, I would have bought one. It's about time that Google stopped trying to clone that experience on Android.
lb...@gmail.com
@285 What "current implementation" ? There is none. You broke apps. And it's not the safest at all.
The moment that an app gets focused, it has access to the clipboard. There is no security/privacy benefit. It's not safest.
And only keyboard apps and system apps get access to the clipboard.
For no reason whatsoever.
What about all apps that developers made using official API? What about all users that got those apps?
Now I can't sync clipboard with PC anymore. Some apps had this as a core function.
What about backward compatibility?
Why not present a real alternative? Those apps can't be converted to keyboard apps.
"Android has a number of user permissions that were implemented in Android 10 to enhance platform safety"
Incorrect about clipboard. It has no user permission for clipboard. It doesn't make it safer.
It only ruins apps.
You should always present a way for apps to evolve and not let them die just because you think something could make things safer.
When you blocked HTTP, you had both HTTPS working and still presented a flag for using HTTP if you really wanted.
This is much more serious and yet you provided both alternative and backward compatibility solutions.
And there are more examples.
Even for storage permission you said that SAF can usually replace it, but then planned to still let apps get access to it if they really need it.
So there is a default behavior which you allow to override if users/developers really want.
If you want, you can be nice for developers and users.
You can enhance the OS without ruining experience, without breaking apps, and without causing harm to users and developers.
Did you compensate users and developers for this decision?
What's so hard in adding a white list management for clipboard access ?
Don't you see how many users and developers have starred this issue? How many people care about it?
Here, made an alternative request:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542
The moment that an app gets focused, it has access to the clipboard. There is no security/privacy benefit. It's not safest.
And only keyboard apps and system apps get access to the clipboard.
For no reason whatsoever.
What about all apps that developers made using official API? What about all users that got those apps?
Now I can't sync clipboard with PC anymore. Some apps had this as a core function.
What about backward compatibility?
Why not present a real alternative? Those apps can't be converted to keyboard apps.
"Android has a number of user permissions that were implemented in Android 10 to enhance platform safety"
Incorrect about clipboard. It has no user permission for clipboard. It doesn't make it safer.
It only ruins apps.
You should always present a way for apps to evolve and not let them die just because you think something could make things safer.
When you blocked HTTP, you had both HTTPS working and still presented a flag for using HTTP if you really wanted.
This is much more serious and yet you provided both alternative and backward compatibility solutions.
And there are more examples.
Even for storage permission you said that SAF can usually replace it, but then planned to still let apps get access to it if they really need it.
So there is a default behavior which you allow to override if users/developers really want.
If you want, you can be nice for developers and users.
You can enhance the OS without ruining experience, without breaking apps, and without causing harm to users and developers.
Did you compensate users and developers for this decision?
What's so hard in adding a white list management for clipboard access ?
Don't you see how many users and developers have starred this issue? How many people care about it?
Here, made an alternative request:
jo...@gmail.com
lb...@gmail.com
And the other request was marked as a duplicate of this one for some reason.
This means Google just killed plenty of apps for no good reason and no alternative, without any warning and without any compensation for both users and developers.
This means Google just killed plenty of apps for no good reason and no alternative, without any warning and without any compensation for both users and developers.
jk...@gmail.com
I've been in the computer consulting business full-time since DOS 1.0, and as an industry, the bigger the companies get, the more they try to "fix things that aren't broken," or cater to the minority, or make decisions by committees of OTHER computer programmers, that understand things and can do things that most end-users cannot. You forget that the END-USER is the ONLY one that counts, since without end-users you have no revenue and have NO JOBS. I agree with
When I design custom databases or other applications for clients, I have a rule I NEVER break when changes need to be made. I can ADD to what they have, that in some cases will help and be used, but not always. But I will NEVER take AWAY functionality, or even how to GET to that functionality, since in doing so I'll KILL some percentage of the users of my programs' ability to either use the program at ALL (like Google is trying to do as we speak), or cause them to have to waste time learning from scratch how to find and use the "new & improved" features I may have installed. If I did as Google and ALL of the other giants that were FORTUNATE ENOUGH to become giants, and have apparently forgotten how they GOT where they are, I'd be out of business! Take Microsoft Word as a simple example (really the entire company, since they make so many changes I can barely use ANYTHING they have, since I'm in perpetual relearn mode!). I'm still using Word 2003 because I can use it blindfolded. I can access the menu barely without looking. I think after that version is when they went to their new menu, which is LITERALLY, as determined by MOST users, BARELY usable in an EFFICIENT way. So MUCH so, Microsoft had to write a program that would make the newer versions revert BACK to the old menu because so many people were complaining. You people meaning ALL large companies, even beyond the computer industry), have GOT TO STOP FIXING THINGS THAT AREN'T BROKEN! You're KILLING your users, and guess what's next? LOSING your users. People can only take so much. There are only 24 hours in a day and most people can't get everything they need to do done as it is, but when companies like Google make changes based on an INTERNAL COMMITTEES of technical people, many that apparently have no COMMON SENSE, though they may otherwise be brilliant, with NO CONSIDERATION for the millions of users that have their systems setup and working EXACTLY like they want them, you're making them work HARDER for the same thing that the day before was a no-brainer, and burning up more of their VALUABLE TIME. My last example of EASILY one of the dumbest (no offense) decisions Google has EVER made (with the clipboard issue being #2 if you proceed), is KILLING Picasa! That was by far the easiest, most intuitive, most organized way to edit and store photographs, both locally AND in the Cloud. Like most, I save my 70,000 (does Google know that some people have that many, or do you "assume" that "oh, this won't matter to people with 100 photos?" photos in LOGICAL TO ME folders, consistently named and formatted for quick retrieval. It uploaded to the Google Cloud using the SAME FOLDER NAMES, so whether locally or in the Cloud out in a rowboat, I could FIND my dang photos in 2 seconds. And what was Google's genius solution to "fixing" Picasa? First it was the SO popular Google+, and we all know where that landed. Now it's Google Photos, uploads my photos ONLY AS UNORGANIZED SINGLE FILES, NO FOLDERS! The ONLY way I can find any of my MASSIVE number of photos is to know the DATE on which I took them!!!! REALLY? Who can remember the date they took a picture 10-15 years ago? My folders were tiered, meaning I had subfolders that further made it easier for me to find what I wanted. I might have a parent folder called SUNSETS, then subfolders for locations, and under locations I'd name the folder using the date at that location the photos were taken. Now what do I have? Google Photos Sync WILL sync the individual photos from ANY number of subfolders I might have locally, but it REMOVES them from ALL folders and stores them as just one gigantic "pile of files," where if I need a photos from 10 years ago, it might take me HOURS to find it... if EVER! And don't get me started on what Google KILLED in editing capabilities, and replaced it with in Google Photos! What LITTLE editing you can do, isn't the LEAST bit intuitive, so I had to abandon using editing with Google altogether and go to an outside program, which WASTES MY TIME! It's been YEARS since Picasa was killed and I'm STILL mad about it, and STILL haven't found a solution that will upload my photos retaining their FOLDER AND SUBFOLDER structure! Please pass on my thanks to whomever at Google made that genius decision.
Yes, I realize photos are not part of this discussion, but the discussion is about Google KILLING OFF programs and/or functionality in the name of "security." News Flash? No matter WHAT ANY programmer does to secure ANY system in the world, if a hacker wants in, they're going to GET in- PERIOD. Just like crime on the street, it hasn't changed and won't change, because every time the good guys zig, the bad guys zag. So I IMPLORE you Google, to FIRST, since you've "fixed" so many other things I can barely use, to at LEAST leave the Clipboard alone! As my friend
ba...@gmail.com
I'm disappointed to learn about Google's decision to limit our options for clipboard apps. I feel like this is a category that affects more than just power users; it's a simple productivity tool that saves time.
A quick glance at this thread shows how many users are impassioned to persuade you to change your minds. No doubt, my point has already been laid out more eloquently & detailed than I can, so I'm merely adding my two cents to what is already a windfall of reasons.
Let's not be like Apple; return this choice to us 🙏
A quick glance at this thread shows how many users are impassioned to persuade you to change your minds. No doubt, my point has already been laid out more eloquently & detailed than I can, so I'm merely adding my two cents to what is already a windfall of reasons.
Let's not be like Apple; return this choice to us 🙏
an...@gmail.com
Not surprising, but really, really annoying
ka...@gmail.com
Unless native clipboard functions are highly upgraded, I believe this functionality should be restored. I can no longer use my favorite clipboard app, Clip Stack, which is making it quite difficult to perform nearly all tasks I do on my phone.
st...@gmail.com
I'm not surprised that a decision to remove clipboard permission was
implemented. It's just not surprising in the least that you didn't pay
attention to what the customers actually need. Please give it back to us.
Please pay attention to real-world users.
On Wed, Mar 18, 2020, 3:36 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
implemented. It's just not surprising in the least that you didn't pay
attention to what the customers actually need. Please give it back to us.
Please pay attention to real-world users.
On Wed, Mar 18, 2020, 3:36 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ja...@gmail.com
Created issue.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
ja...@gmail.com
Created issue.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
ja...@gmail.com
Created issue.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
ja...@gmail.com
Created issue.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
sl...@gmail.com
Clipboard management apps are very important productivity tools for my day-to-day work. Please don't restrict choice to Android users. We need to have a full ecosystem of apps that we find convenient for our daily work productivity.
va...@gmail.com
i CANT USE MY FAVOURITE APP easycopy anymore, on android 10. Please restore clipboard access to android apps!!!!
mo...@gmail.com
well, I see I am late to this complaint party, but I will chime in. I would really like easy copy to work the way it used to.
kh...@gmail.com
I want the feature back. Don't know how to start this
db...@ausdbs.com
I've been using Clipper+ everyday for years and it is part of my daily you say activities. The clipboard is essential for my productivity, which took a big hit when you took this capability away. Please put it back.
ja...@gmail.com
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
ja...@gmail.com
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
ja...@gmail.com
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
ja...@gmail.com
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
ja...@gmail.com
I've read today that the clipboard permission might be removed or granted only for system apps.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dhm47.nativeclipboard&hl=en
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.
qr...@gmail.com
علوش
qr...@gmail.com
علؤش
qr...@gmail.com
علؤش الفقير
jo...@gmail.com
Jdbdkdbdlamsosndbals s
ka...@gmail.com
If GOOGLE Insists on keeping this horribly idiotic move, I will likely move
to iPhone as my kids are starting to do, one by one, as Google keeps
violating their motto, "Do No Evil"...
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
For more information:http://comeuntochrist.org <http://mormon.org/me/1GCM >
---
On Fri, Mar 27, 2020 at 4:45 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
to iPhone as my kids are starting to do, one by one, as Google keeps
violating their motto, "Do No Evil"...
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
For more information:
---
On Fri, Mar 27, 2020 at 4:45 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
dr...@gmail.com
cannot agree more with others who think that Google decision to remove access for clipboard apps to works fine in Android 10 is a total mistake.
Please grant us the possibility, at least to decide whether we would like to intentionally grant access for the Clipboard apps to read data or not..
So the decision to grant access for the apps is up to us and not Google instead..
Please consider our inputs Google
Because we love Android for its limitless capabilities to help us as users to achieve the best in everything we do,, and Clipboard application is an excellent & helpful app to help us manage our copied text much better..
Thank You
Please grant us the possibility, at least to decide whether we would like to intentionally grant access for the Clipboard apps to read data or not..
So the decision to grant access for the apps is up to us and not Google instead..
Please consider our inputs Google
Because we love Android for its limitless capabilities to help us as users to achieve the best in everything we do,, and Clipboard application is an excellent & helpful app to help us manage our copied text much better..
Thank You
ko...@gmail.com
Please fix this issue
er...@gmail.com
Hola
gl...@gmail.com
As I understand they may exist some privacy concerns about clipboard, I have a feeling that you didn't provide real solution to this problem.
Options that could be provided in this case:
0. Disallow any communication/network permission and clipboard permision to be allowed together. So app with clipboard permission could read it, but not send anywhere
1. Grant this permission explicitly only through system settings interaction
2. Periodically notify user about apps using "not safe" permissions
3. Limit number of apps who can use this permission to one
4. Leave permission only in developer options
5. Leave possibility to activate through adb
6. Leave only for rooted users
Also I'm not sure if you are aware, but workarounds for many many apps around more and more restrictive permission model in Android, use Accessibility Service. So they are still breathing. Once you will start limiting that service, many of them will start to die.
Clipboard managers are the biggest productivity improvement in general mobile phone usage. Please reconsider reopening and providing some real solution.
Options that could be provided in this case:
0. Disallow any communication/network permission and clipboard permision to be allowed together. So app with clipboard permission could read it, but not send anywhere
1. Grant this permission explicitly only through system settings interaction
2. Periodically notify user about apps using "not safe" permissions
3. Limit number of apps who can use this permission to one
4. Leave permission only in developer options
5. Leave possibility to activate through adb
6. Leave only for rooted users
Also I'm not sure if you are aware, but workarounds for many many apps around more and more restrictive permission model in Android, use Accessibility Service. So they are still breathing. Once you will start limiting that service, many of them will start to die.
Clipboard managers are the biggest productivity improvement in general mobile phone usage. Please reconsider reopening and providing some real solution.
ch...@googlemail.com
Same thing here. Productivity is severely hampered due to this. Why can't I (as the user) give a specific app like KDE Connect the right to read the clipboard?
sa...@gmail.com
PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE CLIPBOARD ACCESS TO THIRD PARTY APPLICATIONS. WORKING BADLY HAMPERED! IT BROUGHT DOWN MY EFFICIENCY TREMENDOUSLY.
ja...@atlas.cz
KDE Connect can't now synchronize clipboard. Really step back behind Apple in user experience.
st...@gmail.com
I am voicing my concerns over this choice and echoing all the other posts, especially post 15. It should be our choice. Don't become like apple who control everything. It's half the reason i came to Android after years of using Apple
od...@gmail.com
Removing background clipboard access for 3rd party is stupid and silly. Do you guys even think?
me...@gmail.com
As demands for better passwords increases the need for copy/paste is forced. After pasting password I need to clear clipboard. And there is good apps that automates this. So - please don't block access to clipboard.
si...@gmail.com
Its handy and useful features contain it so grant permission
wh...@gmail.com
Dear Google, if thee taketh away with one hand, giveth back the same or more with the other.
ja...@gmail.com
At the very least, I hope Google will let foreground apps have this ability.
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
ja...@gmail.com
At the very least, I hope Google will let foreground apps have this ability.
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
ja...@gmail.com
At the very least, I hope Google will let foreground apps have this ability.
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
ja...@gmail.com
At the very least, I hope Google will let foreground apps have this ability.
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
Focused ones is just the current app, right?
I've tested it and it seems as such.
The only workaround that I've found is to have an on-top view with foreground service, but this is too much to ask from the user. Plus what would you show the user...
zo...@gmail.com
A lot of things are broken in A10, this being one of them. I don't know why they would cripple functionality that people use in the name of privacy rather than just give people a permission option. And this is broken on purpose... but hey, at least it has this awesome redesigned notification area!
And here I was wondering why my friends have been switching to iphones.
And here I was wondering why my friends have been switching to iphones.
al...@gmail.com
Please let clip stack have access to clipboard because we can secure ourselves by firewalls.
dt...@gmail.com
Agree with the gentlemen above.
pl...@gmail.com
For 4 years I use Clip Stack app to record everything I copy, I use it to later track what I wrote. I do the same on all my PC's. I also use Kaspersky Premium to protect my self!
When I saw Clip Stack reported some moron blocked background clipboard access on Android 10, after Samsung A50 received an update, I imidietlly thought how can I downgrade to A9. If it was not for reseting it to factory setting, I would have returned it at once and never look back.
Even A9 is crap for not allowing me to store contact names with all the recorded calls I store on purpose so I can know what I promised to do or what info someone provided, and now this crap...
When I saw Clip Stack reported some moron blocked background clipboard access on Android 10, after Samsung A50 received an update, I imidietlly thought how can I downgrade to A9. If it was not for reseting it to factory setting, I would have returned it at once and never look back.
Even A9 is crap for not allowing me to store contact names with all the recorded calls I store on purpose so I can know what I promised to do or what info someone provided, and now this crap...
ja...@gmail.com
Please, please don't block clipboard managers! I depend on clipboard managers a lot!
ni...@gmail.com
Make android FREE AGAIN
jh...@gmail.com
Let the user choose
e....@gmail.com
It's really bad. We are in habit of using this app now.
And i don't understand how this small app is creating issue.
And i don't understand how this small app is creating issue.
ma...@gmail.com
I used to use the application "Clip Stack" and I really loved it!
I've always used a clipboard manager on my Windows and Linux workstations so it was great to have it on my Android smartphone too.
Please Google bring back this feature!
I've always used a clipboard manager on my Windows and Linux workstations so it was great to have it on my Android smartphone too.
Please Google bring back this feature!
di...@gmail.com
these "apple" moves from google are stupid
soon we have to create another linux based os for mobile devices
soon we have to create another linux based os for mobile devices
bl...@gmail.com
please restore full clipboard manager functionality -- I have repetitive stress injuries and clipboard managers are a key factor in my ability to compose text with minimal pain
I've lost count of how many clipboard manager applications I've purchased, but I'm currently running 4, and actively using 3 -- I have invested
more time and money in the Android ecosystem over the years compared to iOS, but this will make iPhones and iPads vastly more attractive
many thanks for your consideration=)
I've lost count of how many clipboard manager applications I've purchased, but I'm currently running 4, and actively using 3 -- I have invested
more time and money in the Android ecosystem over the years compared to iOS, but this will make iPhones and iPads vastly more attractive
many thanks for your consideration=)
to...@gmail.com
Please add a new permission for clipboard access. It will let the users decide which applications they trust and it won't break many users' workflow. I really miss KDE Connect clipboard share feature.
mo...@gmail.com
Permit clipboard managers to work
br...@gmail.com
Permit clipboard managers to work
ah...@gmail.com
make it as permission as camera phone calls microphone etc
sa...@gmail.com
Should be our own personal choice. Please make available.
bi...@gmail.com
Time to stop the monopoly.
da...@gmail.com
Please permit clipboard managers to work
ad...@gmail.com
Hello,
Clipboard manager is very useful. You could simply not allow the developers to copy content and not remove the clipboard managers from android.
Make it optional also for each user to allow or not copy content from developer.
Clipboard manager is very useful. You could simply not allow the developers to copy content and not remove the clipboard managers from android.
Make it optional also for each user to allow or not copy content from developer.
ad...@gmail.com
You are destroying android slowly with such decisions, since it seems you are creating a self business here and and not a business that serves the world. It is this phenomenon that if a business has some success, they think they are so powerful that they can do what they want. However you forget that as success comes, failure can also come, especially with such immature decisions as this one.
Soon if you continue like this, I will turn to Samsung Play Store. I hope you make clipboard managers available soon. Have you got any idea, how many hours these developers have spent to make these clipboard managers? And in a second you close all their efforts, by your immature decisions. Also have you got any idea how many hours the clipboard managers, save for the users? I am a research scientist and these applications save me a lot of hours.
Simply make optional for each user to choose that permission or simply do not allow developers to copy content from clipboards. You allow photos and videos to be viewed from developers and you thought the clipboard content to be a problem? Become logical.
Soon if you continue like this, I will turn to Samsung Play Store. I hope you make clipboard managers available soon. Have you got any idea, how many hours these developers have spent to make these clipboard managers? And in a second you close all their efforts, by your immature decisions. Also have you got any idea how many hours the clipboard managers, save for the users? I am a research scientist and these applications save me a lot of hours.
Simply make optional for each user to choose that permission or simply do not allow developers to copy content from clipboards. You allow photos and videos to be viewed from developers and you thought the clipboard content to be a problem? Become logical.
im...@gmail.com
It is really sad to see that clipboard option removed by Android developers. Just remember one thing millions of developers working hard to build an application and updating step by step. But with this act thousand developers goes dead. These type of theories will destroy the market of Android and soon some new company like Huawei will enter in this market and you'll see. Because I was using Google services 20s and observing destroying ideas by someone in Google team. Just like Orkut was the best ever social app but only with your cheap ideas and team you destroyed this application and Facebook takeover your idea and application features.
So please stop these kind of cheap ideas and think and after reviewing so something different.
Regards,
Atif
So please stop these kind of cheap ideas and think and after reviewing so something different.
Regards,
Atif
sc...@gmail.com
I too am disappointed with this decision by Google. I have been a software developer for over 40 years and one thing that I have learned is that when you err on the side of security versus usability it inevitably comes back to bite you on the back side. I hope you can see the error of your ways and make this a user settable option.
wi...@gmail.com
Please allow us to continue using our clipboard managers. There has to be a way to do this and still stay safe. I depend on Clip Stack clipboard manager for many vital reasons, as I am sure many others do. Usability is why we need apps. Google can do better than this.
I expect to see Google step up and realize that taking away our clipboard managers does not please the majority of your ccustomers.
Please address this issue quickly and maka your loyal customers very happy.
wilsona1993@gmail.com
I expect to see Google step up and realize that taking away our clipboard managers does not please the majority of your ccustomers.
Please address this issue quickly and maka your loyal customers very happy.
wilsona1993@gmail.com
st...@gmail.com
Google only cares about getting our personal information to sell to the highest bidder.
They have proven over and over again that they do not care about their users.
It's almost enough to make one hold their nose and buy Apple products.
They have proven over and over again that they do not care about their users.
It's almost enough to make one hold their nose and buy Apple products.
lb...@gmail.com
Guys you keep writing to a thread that is marked as "won't fix".
I am truly against what Google did, but I don't think Google looks here anymore.
If you really want to make it a new one, press on "Create" and publish here a link to it.
I am truly against what Google did, but I don't think Google looks here anymore.
If you really want to make it a new one, press on "Create" and publish here a link to it.
ka...@gmail.com
We need a new bug. This one was preemptive. Google destroyed the clipboard
already.
The new bug would be to demand reinstatement of user-controlled clipboard
content and access.
IT IS OUR DATA! GIVE IT BACK NOW!!!
Is someone in this recipient list in a position to raise a new bug?
Do you agree or disagree?
Thank you for your consideration. I don't think Google, or anyone there
gives a damn about this bug. Or likely, this issue. Like all of the big
tech companies, they believe they are now God and their opinion is law....
This is one time I wish the government would step in and break them up into
their component parts so they might start listening to their customers.
I've raised this issue with both my senator and congressman, and they are
working nehind the scenes to get that on the road map, and moved forward.
---
Karl | karlplds@gmail.com
For more information:http://comeuntochrist.org <http://mormon.org/me/1GCM >
---
On Sun, May 17, 2020 at 3:40 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
already.
The new bug would be to demand reinstatement of user-controlled clipboard
content and access.
IT IS OUR DATA! GIVE IT BACK NOW!!!
Is someone in this recipient list in a position to raise a new bug?
Do you agree or disagree?
Thank you for your consideration. I don't think Google, or anyone there
gives a damn about this bug. Or likely, this issue. Like all of the big
tech companies, they believe they are now God and their opinion is law....
This is one time I wish the government would step in and break them up into
their component parts so they might start listening to their customers.
I've raised this issue with both my senator and congressman, and they are
working nehind the scenes to get that on the road map, and moved forward.
---
Karl | karlplds@gmail.com
For more information:
---
On Sun, May 17, 2020 at 3:40 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
pm...@gmail.com
Bring back support for clipboard apps. It seems like every time there is an update to android it takes up more disk space and it gets more broken every time.
in...@gmail.com
I paid for the app Clipper+ which I used nearly every day for many years. Now Google have updated my Pixel phone to Android 10 and have broken the app. Please do not make changes that will obviously break things. You should at least come up with an alternative solution for app developers to use before forcing this kind of breaking change.
ra...@gmail.com
I need clip stack
lj...@gmail.com
K
Sent from Outlook Mobile<https://aka.ms/blhgte >
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 26, 2020 3:22:00 AM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
ra...@gmail.com addedhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment360 >:
I need clip stack
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 >
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 >
duplicate issue: 128513320<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 >, 128582282<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 >, 137878823<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 >, 151168542<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 >
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 >, Platform<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 >
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTrackerhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 > where you have the role: starred.
Unsubscribe from this issue.<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true >
Sent from Outlook Mobile<
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 26, 2020 3:22:00 AM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
Changed
ra...@gmail.com added
I need clip stack
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<
duplicate issue: 128513320<
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.<
ab...@gmail.com
F
lj...@gmail.com
Awesome. Thanks.
Sent from Outlook Mobile<https://aka.ms/blhgte >
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Wednesday, May 27, 2020 8:05:46 AM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
ab...@gmail.com addedhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment362 >:
F
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 >
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 >
duplicate issue: 128513320<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 >, 128582282<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 >, 137878823<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 >, 151168542<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 >
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 >, Platform<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 >
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTrackerhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 > where you have the role: starred.
Unsubscribe from this issue.<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true >
Sent from Outlook Mobile<
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Wednesday, May 27, 2020 8:05:46 AM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
Changed
ab...@gmail.com added
F
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<
duplicate issue: 128513320<
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<
retention: Component default
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.<
ka...@gmail.com
I've discovered there's a clipboard feature with GBoard, the Google
keyboard.
On the top row are extra options, over of which is the 3 vertical buttons.
Tap that and one of the features is clipboard items. I've just discovered
it so don't know how extensive it's going to be. You can add items to the
clipboard. I see only my most recent cut item right now...
I hope this will become what the others were. Hopefully Google will
purchase one of the two I used to use, like they did with Waze...
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
Pardon brevity or typos. Sent from my phone.
---
On Wed, May 27, 2020, 9:01 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
keyboard.
On the top row are extra options, over of which is the 3 vertical buttons.
Tap that and one of the features is clipboard items. I've just discovered
it so don't know how extensive it's going to be. You can add items to the
clipboard. I see only my most recent cut item right now...
I hope this will become what the others were. Hopefully Google will
purchase one of the two I used to use, like they did with Waze...
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
Pardon brevity or typos. Sent from my phone.
---
On Wed, May 27, 2020, 9:01 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
al...@gmail.com
Such permission was a key functionality for Google Translate and probably some other apps. I think it was really bad idea to remove it. Separate additional permission seems like a good idea which will allow user to decide for their own and provide ability for such functionality as was in Google Translate before update to Android 10 (I mean tap to translate function which used to provide pop-up translation icon after copying text)
[Deleted User] <[Deleted User]>
I quit Apple everything due to lack of freedom to move and listen to my music that I owned. iTunes took control of my media. Now it seems you want to be iGoogle. While I do appreciate Google worrying about security, I feel you have overstepped here. I paid for my phone, I am over the age of 21, I know when I drink an alcoholic beverage, I should not drive. I know if I have unprotected sex there are consequences. I know if I leave my front for wide open or my car unlocked things may get stolen. Yet Google thinks I am too stupid to protect my phone? Did you get bought out by Apple, Zuckerberg or a politician? Because you sure are starting to act like them. Let adults be adults and pay the price for or own stupidity. You have no right to tell me what gas to put in my car, why do you feel you have the right to tell me what app I have to use on my phone? I use the clipboard managers in both my jobs regularly. I already have a double work load. I will go out of business if I have to work quadruple the amount to keep afloat. Give us back the ability to use our personal property as we wish. Please.
cb...@gmail.com
Please keep the feature alive. I use clipboard managers very often.
pa...@gmail.com
Hi… I just updated the device to Android 10. I regretfully miss my clipboard app. It used to make things so convenient. :-(
je...@gmail.com
I use the clipboard very! Often And would hate you see it gone through out
the other phones all the time as well as mine and Android apps department
of our phones needs to know that.
On Sun., Jun. 7, 2020, 2:22 p.m. , <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
the other phones all the time as well as mine and Android apps department
of our phones needs to know that.
On Sun., Jun. 7, 2020, 2:22 p.m. , <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
be...@gmail.com
I am a writer and all my work was on clip now I don't know what to do kindly allow us to use clip
be...@gmail.com
This is a wrong decision 😒
The only reason for me to use android is because of my Freedom to use my choice of apps and if I can't any more than it's better for me to go Beck to Apple iPhone
The only reason for me to use android is because of my Freedom to use my choice of apps and if I can't any more than it's better for me to go Beck to Apple iPhone
jo...@gmail.com
Why did you break my favorite clipboard apps. Have they been replaced with some native functionality that I am just not aware of? It's a step in the wrong direction and I have been missing their usefulness.
no...@gmail.com
Multiple clipboards are a necessity given the cumbersome user flow of sharing to an app (4 to 5 step process) and the limited screen area.
Smartphones and tablets can only thrive productivity-wise with workarounda like multiple keyboards, split screens, UX improvements while sharing, additional contextual menus to bind common actions etc.
Please don't cripple the process and just add this as a separate permission apps should request.
Smartphones and tablets can only thrive productivity-wise with workarounda like multiple keyboards, split screens, UX improvements while sharing, additional contextual menus to bind common actions etc.
Please don't cripple the process and just add this as a separate permission apps should request.
ha...@gmx.de
i need Clipboard manager because my Android phone only supports ONE entry
Means that when I want to copy multiple texts between apps I need to switch between apps for every single piece I want to copy!
Means that when I want to copy multiple texts between apps I need to switch between apps for every single piece I want to copy!
la...@latsoudislaw.com
Please reconsider! Give the user the power to give permission to specific apps.
2FA is no longer fun....
2FA is no longer fun....
hd...@gmail.com
Really?
Couldn't believe that this is now blocked by default! Why not using a separate permission for the clipboard access?
Please give us users back the choice to allow who can access our clipboard.
Couldn't believe that this is now blocked by default! Why not using a separate permission for the clipboard access?
Please give us users back the choice to allow who can access our clipboard.
cy...@gmail.com
Google has already explained their decision: they think there's too many permission requests and they think that users are too simple minded to understand what granting this permission means. So that's the future of Android: less choice for the sake of more protecting the poor, dumb user that doesn't know how to stay out of trouble.
th...@gmail.com
I strongly believe that clipboard function should be up to the user to determine. The same applies to the ability to paste text in password text boxes. All this creates quite an annoyance to user. In a single word: unacceptable!
hs...@gmail.com
Give us back our Clipboard..it is a VERY useful feature !
sh...@gmail.com
Please don't remove clipboard monitoring in background.
mu...@gmail.com
Please ,Give back our clip stack
in...@gmail.com
Please allow to run clipboard in background.
I'm facing many problems due to it.
I'm facing many problems due to it.
mo...@gmail.com
Dear Google I understand that your trying make Android more secure and private but this is not a good way to go about it.i also heard that your going to implement a feature in Android q that will let users know what apps are using what permissions at any given time that's good and I like the fact that Android informs users so they can take action but why cripple the functionality of the os when you already have plenty of security and privacy features put in place to protect users.alot of android user prefer android because of the freedom and choice it offers not only in terms of hardware but software as well.please think about this I don't think this would be beneficial to anyone I thought the reason for the permission in android was to strike the perfect balance between security and functionality by letting the user have the choice to disable and enable individual permissions,and now with android q users will definitely be informed about android's permission system since it's a privacy feature in android q.
ar...@gmail.com
Clipboard managers like ClipStack arose because core Android didn't offer the functionality. Security guidelines to make Clipboard Managers more secure work. Closing the interface w/o offering the obviously needed functionality is bad faith.
el...@gmail.com
desde España me uno
to...@gmail.com
Above all My great gratitude to The Development & Developers who dedicate
themselves to the buganizer-system@google.com
I would like to contribute further Details & Data relevant to the Issue I
reported. It's been an agonizing task. I would also would share logs and
discuss any relevant information not excluding my Google domain SECURITY,
Audits, investigations, and I assure these Databases are most relevant to
this and other similar bug reports.
Thank you,
Antonio Gonzalez Admin xtch.llc
tonyvg@xtvgtech.com
tonyvg2013@gmail.com
On Sun., Jul. 5, 2020, 4:32 a.m. , <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
themselves to the buganizer-system@google.com
I would like to contribute further Details & Data relevant to the Issue I
reported. It's been an agonizing task. I would also would share logs and
discuss any relevant information not excluding my Google domain SECURITY,
Audits, investigations, and I assure these Databases are most relevant to
this and other similar bug reports.
Thank you,
Antonio Gonzalez Admin xtch.llc
tonyvg@xtvgtech.com
tonyvg2013@gmail.com
On Sun., Jul. 5, 2020, 4:32 a.m. , <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ae...@gmail.com
When do you back clipboard access feature? As android user this disappointed me. Please ASAP back this feature.
bl...@gmail.com
I just bought the Samsung A20 and its missing the clipboard...WHY?!? Please put it back!!!
an...@gmail.com
I really 1000% hate this very much. Now it takes me a lot of hard work and time to create and edit text, html, mht files. I didn't expected this from you android team. Now I am forced to use gboard which I hate and never use. Please bring the clipboard feature back. There must a way to to keep the user's data safe while using a clipboard app. The gboard will never replace the effectiveness and user friendliness of clipboard apps. I regret of updating to android 10.
ba...@gmail.com
This is a very helpful Al for me. Gh
Please stop blocking it.
Please stop blocking it.
lj...@gmail.com
Great.
Get Outlook for Android<https://aka.ms/ghei36 >
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 14, 2020 8:21:27 AM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
ba...@gmail.com addedhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment390 >:
This is a very helpful Al for me. Gh
Please stop blocking it.
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 >
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 >
duplicate issue: 128513320<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 >, 128582282<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 >, 137878823<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 >, 151168542<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 >
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 >, Platform<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 >
retention: Component default
ReportedBy: Developer
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTrackerhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 > where you have the role: starred.
Unsubscribe from this issue.<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true >
Get Outlook for Android<
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 14, 2020 8:21:27 AM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
Changed
ba...@gmail.com added
This is a very helpful Al for me. Gh
Please stop blocking it.
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<
duplicate issue: 128513320<
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<
retention: Component default
ReportedBy: Developer
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.<
hw...@gmail.com
lj...@gmail.com
<html xmlns:o="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office" xmlns:w="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:word" xmlns:m="http://schemas.microsoft.com/office/2004/12/omml " xmlns="http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40 "><head><meta http-equiv=Content-Type content="text/html; charset=utf-8"><meta name=Generator content="Microsoft Word 15 (filtered medium)"><style><!--
/* Font Definitions */
@font-face
{font-family:"Cambria Math";
panose-1:2 4 5 3 5 4 6 3 2 4;}
@font-face
{font-family:Calibri;
panose-1:2 15 5 2 2 2 4 3 2 4;}
@font-face
{font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji";
panose-1:2 11 5 2 4 2 4 2 2 3;}
@font-face
{font-family:"Edwardian Script ITC";
panose-1:3 3 3 2 4 7 7 13 8 4;}
@font-face
{font-family:"Leelawadee UI";
panose-1:2 11 5 2 4 2 4 2 2 3;}
/* Style Definitions */
p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal
{margin:0in;
margin-bottom:.0001pt;
font-size:11.0pt;
font-family:"Calibri",sans-serif;}
a:link, span.MsoHyperlink
{mso-style-priority:99;
color:blue;
text-decoration:underline;}
.MsoChpDefault
{mso-style-type:export-only;}
@page WordSection1
{size:8.5in 11.0in;
margin:1.0in 1.0in 1.0in 1.0in;}
div.WordSection1
{page:WordSection1;}
--></style></head><body lang=EN-US link=blue vlink="#954F72"><div class=WordSection1><p class=MsoNormal>Great!</p><p class=MsoNormal><o:p> </o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal>Best regards,<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><o:p> </o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-size:18.0pt;font-family:"Edwardian Script ITC"'>Lawrence Johnson<o:p></o:p></span></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji",sans-serif'>📞</span>(863) 354-0329<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji",sans-serif'>📞</span>(863) 852-5601<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji",sans-serif'>📠</span>(973) 215-8605<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><o:p> </o:p></p><div style='mso-element:para-border-div;border:none;border-top:solid #E1E1E1 1.0pt;padding:3.0pt 0in 0in 0in'><p class=MsoNormal style='border:none;padding:0in'><b>From: </b><a href="mailto:buganizer-system@google.com">buganizer-system@google.com</a><br><b>Sent: </b>Wednesday, July 15, 2020 2:43 PM<br><b>To: </b><a href="mailto:b-system+663841872@google.com">b-system+663841872@google.com</a><br><b>Cc: </b><a href="mailto:ljohnson329@gmail.com">ljohnson329@gmail.com</a><br><b>Subject: </b>Re:https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 ">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 </a><br><br><strong><span style='font-family:"Calibri",sans-serif'>Changed</span></strong><br><br><strong><span style='font-family:"Calibri",sans-serif'>hw...@gmail.com added <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment392 ">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 </a><br>><br>> *Changed*<br>><br>> *<a href="mailto:lj...@gmail.com" target="_blank">lj...@gmail.com</a> <<a href="mailto:lj...@gmail.com" target="_blank">lj...@gmail.com</a>> added <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment391 ">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment391 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment391 </a>>:*<br>> Great.<br>><br>> Get Outlook for Android<<a href="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://aka.ms/ghei36&sa=D&usg=AFQjCNEmMpZx9uAlrAqpMG4Keo6Etk1VEw " target="_blank">https://aka.ms/ghei36 </a><br>> <<a href="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://aka.ms/ghei36&sa=D&usg=AFQjCNEmMpZx9uAlrAqpMG4Keo6Etk1VEw " target="_blank">https://www.google.com/url?q=https://aka.ms/ghei36&sa=D&usg=AFQjCNEmMpZx9uAlrAqpMG4Keo6Etk1VEw </a>><br>> ><br>><br>> ________________________________<br>> From: <a href="mailto:buganizer-system@google.com" target="_blank">buganizer-system@google.com</a> <<a href="mailto:buganizer-system@google.com" target="_blank">buganizer-system@google.com</a>><br>> Sent: Tuesday, July 14, 2020 8:21:27 AM<br>> To: <a href="mailto:b-system%2B663841872@google.com" target="_blank">b-system+663841872@google.com</a> <<a href="mailto:b-system%2B663841872@google.com" target="_blank">b-system+663841872@google.com</a>><br>> Cc: <a href="mailto:ljohnson329@gmail.com" target="_blank">ljohnson329@gmail.com</a> <<a href="mailto:ljohnson329@gmail.com" target="_blank">ljohnson329@gmail.com</a>><br>> Subject: Re: <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 </a>>: Request: Do not<br>> remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it<br>><br>> Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the<br>> team that works on this product.<br>><br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 </a><br>><br>> Changed<br>><br>> <a href="mailto:ba...@gmail.com" target="_blank">ba...@gmail.com</a> added <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment390 ">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment390 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment390 </a>><<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment390 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment390 </a>>:<br>> This is a very helpful Al for me. Gh<br>> Please stop blocking it.<br>><br>><br>> _______________________________<br>><br>> Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and<br>> do not let only system apps have it<br>> component: Android Public Tracker<<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 </a>><br>> status: Intended Behavior<br>> reporter: <a href="mailto:lb...@gmail.com" target="_blank">lb...@gmail.com</a><br>> assignee: <a href="mailto:cc...@google.com" target="_blank">cc...@google.com</a><br>> cc: <a href="mailto:da...@google.com" target="_blank">da...@google.com</a>, <a href="mailto:lb...@gmail.com" target="_blank">lb...@gmail.com</a><br>> type: Feature Request<br>> priority: P1<br>> severity: S3<br>> blocked by: 123500346<<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 </a>><br>> duplicate issue: 128513320<<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 </a>>, 128582282<<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 </a>>, 137878823<<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 </a>>, 151168542<<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 </a>><br>> hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 </a>>,<br>> Platform<<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 </a>><br>> retention: Component default<br>> ReportedBy: Developer<br>><br>><br>><br>> Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system<br>><br>> You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on<br>> Google IssueTracker <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 </a>><<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 </a>> where you have the<br>> role: starred.<br>> Unsubscribe from this issue.<<br>> <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true </a>><br>><br>><br>> _______________________________<br>><br>> *Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and<br>> do not let only system apps have it*<br>> component: Android Public Tracker<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 </a>><br>> status: Intended Behavior<br>> reporter: <a href="mailto:lb...@gmail.com" target="_blank">lb...@gmail.com</a><br>> assignee: <a href="mailto:cc...@google.com" target="_blank">cc...@google.com</a><br>> cc: <a href="mailto:da...@google.com" target="_blank">da...@google.com</a>, <a href="mailto:lb...@gmail.com" target="_blank">lb...@gmail.com</a><br>> type: Feature Request<br>> priority: P1<br>> severity: S3<br>> blocked by: 123500346 <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 </a>><br>> duplicate issue: 128513320<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 </a>>, 128582282<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 </a>>, 137878823<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 </a>>, 151168542<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 </a>><br>> hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 </a>>, Platform<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 </a>><br>> retention: Component default<br>> ReportedBy: Developer<br>><br>><br>><br>> Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system<br>><br>> You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on<br>> Google IssueTracker <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 </a>> where you have the<br>> role: starred.<br>> Unsubscribe from this issue.<br>> <<a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true " target="_blank">https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true </a>><br>><br><br><br>_______________________________</p><div><p class=MsoNormal><br><strong><span style='font-family:"Calibri",sans-serif'>Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it</span></strong></p></div></div><p class=MsoNormal><span style='color:gray'>component: </span><a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 " target="_blank">Android Public Tracker</a><br><span style='color:gray'>status: </span>Intended Behavior<br><span style='color:gray'>reporter: </span>lb...@gmail.com<br><span style='color:gray'>assignee: </span>cc...@google.com<br><span style='color:gray'>cc: </span>da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com<br><span style='color:gray'>type: </span>Feature Request<br><span style='color:gray'>priority: </span>P1<br><span style='color:gray'>severity: </span>S3<br><span style='color:gray'>blocked by: </span><a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 " target="_blank">123500346</a><br><span style='color:gray'>duplicate issue: </span><a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 " target="_blank">128513320</a>, <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 " target="_blank">128582282</a>, <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 " target="_blank">137878823</a>, <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 " target="_blank">151168542</a><br><span style='color:gray'>hotlist: </span><a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 " target="_blank">[AOSP] assigned</a>, <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 " target="_blank">Platform</a><br><span style='color:gray'>retention: </span>Component default<br><span style='color:gray'>ReportedBy: </span>Developer<br><br><br><br>Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system<br><br><span style='color:gray'>You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker issue <a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 ">123461156</a> where you have the role: starred. </span><br><a href="https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true ">Unsubscribe from this issue.</a></p><p class=MsoNormal><o:p> </o:p></p></div></body></html>
/* Font Definitions */
@font-face
{font-family:"Cambria Math";
panose-1:2 4 5 3 5 4 6 3 2 4;}
@font-face
{font-family:Calibri;
panose-1:2 15 5 2 2 2 4 3 2 4;}
@font-face
{font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji";
panose-1:2 11 5 2 4 2 4 2 2 3;}
@font-face
{font-family:"Edwardian Script ITC";
panose-1:3 3 3 2 4 7 7 13 8 4;}
@font-face
{font-family:"Leelawadee UI";
panose-1:2 11 5 2 4 2 4 2 2 3;}
/* Style Definitions */
p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal
{margin:0in;
margin-bottom:.0001pt;
font-size:11.0pt;
font-family:"Calibri",sans-serif;}
a:link, span.MsoHyperlink
{mso-style-priority:99;
color:blue;
text-decoration:underline;}
.MsoChpDefault
{mso-style-type:export-only;}
@page WordSection1
{size:8.5in 11.0in;
margin:1.0in 1.0in 1.0in 1.0in;}
div.WordSection1
{page:WordSection1;}
--></style></head><body lang=EN-US link=blue vlink="#954F72"><div class=WordSection1><p class=MsoNormal>Great!</p><p class=MsoNormal><o:p> </o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal>Best regards,<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><o:p> </o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-size:18.0pt;font-family:"Edwardian Script ITC"'>Lawrence Johnson<o:p></o:p></span></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji",sans-serif'>📞</span>(863) 354-0329<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji",sans-serif'>📞</span>(863) 852-5601<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-family:"Segoe UI Emoji",sans-serif'>📠</span>(973) 215-8605<o:p></o:p></p><p class=MsoNormal><o:p> </o:p></p><div style='mso-element:para-border-div;border:none;border-top:solid #E1E1E1 1.0pt;padding:3.0pt 0in 0in 0in'><p class=MsoNormal style='border:none;padding:0in'><b>From: </b><a href="mailto:buganizer-system@google.com">buganizer-system@google.com</a><br><b>Sent: </b>Wednesday, July 15, 2020 2:43 PM<br><b>To: </b><a href="mailto:b-system+663841872@google.com">b-system+663841872@google.com</a><br><b>Cc: </b><a href="mailto:ljohnson329@gmail.com">ljohnson329@gmail.com</a><br><b>Subject: </b>Re:
br...@gmail.com
Please implement this as as an explicit permission just like every other security feature in Android. Limiting functionality isn't a good way to retain users and developers. If I want to give an app access to my clipboard then that is my decision. I don't need the OS to make that decision for me.
wa...@gmail.com
I wouldn't have upgraded if I knew clipboard manager would be disabled - I use it because there is nothing comparable on offer that will allow me to choose from anything but the last clip board entry.
Don't take stuff away unless you are providing a replacement!
Don't take stuff away unless you are providing a replacement!
ja...@gmail.com
The consumers should have an informed choice regarding their privacy and app implications not google forcing it upon them
ma...@gmail.com
This application is simple and working
Do not remove it from the thursted app
I need it
Do not remove it from the thursted app
I need it
ia...@gmail.com
Alarmed at not being able to manage my clipboard with Android 10 as I have in the past. Please fix this.
br...@gmail.com
Clip board apps are essential to use android as a multitask platform
wa...@gmail.com
Great solution: Some people have used hammers to kill other people, so Google is now removing all hammers from hardware stores. You will have to build your houses and offices with something else. May we suggest a screwdriver?.
We are Google and we are brilliant!
We are Google and we are brilliant!
m4...@gmail.com
Agree with the sentiment of most comments here. There are no privacy or security issues provided the user gives informed consent. Removing clipboard access, on the other hand, is a significant impediment to the development of user experience improvements. Google's answer should be to provide solutions to any perceived issues, not functionality restrictions.
ca...@gmail.com
ONE LAST NAIL IN GOOGLES' COFFIN! I've really gotten fed up with this attitude you people at Google have. You are not supposed to act like Microsoft you know?! So just break it and let someone else fix it that's the norm for you? I want my Clip Board managers IT'S NOT UP TO YOU! How about a Class Action how would you like that?
jm...@gmail.com
I'll put this in the only terms Google will understand.
Google - you've lost a customer
If I'm going to live with these sorts of restrictions I'll go with Apple next time. Bye.
Google - you've lost a customer
If I'm going to live with these sorts of restrictions I'll go with Apple next time. Bye.
sc...@googlemail.com
Google, what are you playing at?
You are making this once great system unusable!
To remove clipboard managers is ridiculous, as a user with short term memory problems, I rely on the clipboard to fill out forms etc!
How much more will you cripple android, I've already uninstalled a regularly used app because YOU removed it's access!!
Also another thing you've crippled is music remote control via Android wear watch, what is the point if you pause the music with the screen off, to have to turn on the screen before you can play again! - the whole point of the watch is to leave the phone in your pocket!!
PLEASE STOP MAKING ANDROID UNUSABLE!!
You are making this once great system unusable!
To remove clipboard managers is ridiculous, as a user with short term memory problems, I rely on the clipboard to fill out forms etc!
How much more will you cripple android, I've already uninstalled a regularly used app because YOU removed it's access!!
Also another thing you've crippled is music remote control via Android wear watch, what is the point if you pause the music with the screen off, to have to turn on the screen before you can play again! - the whole point of the watch is to leave the phone in your pocket!!
PLEASE STOP MAKING ANDROID UNUSABLE!!
te...@hotmail.com
This was awesome for multilingual dictionaries. I'm an iPhone user who just bought an android to give it a go but this is a massive deal breaker for someone learning chinese. Split screen with content on one side and dictionary on the other is soooo awesome for language learners!
Please please please sort it out 🙏🙏🙏
Please please please sort it out 🙏🙏🙏
bl...@gmail.com
>400 comments posted over 1.5 years.
Lots of people have brought up plenty of valid use cases for clipboard managers, and many of them have heavily invested in the Android ecosystem to enhance their productivity.
We all fail to see the issue with treating clipboard access in the background as advanced on-request-only permission. If the OS is as transparent as possible to the user of what an app does, and the user accepts the risks, then the OS should get out of the way. Things are supposed to be as simple as this. The higher levels of freedom are one of the main reasons that drive people to buy Android instead of Apple devices, you know. Also, there are many ways apps can access a user's personal information in the background - does it mean that any permission that can be used to access PIIs in the background will slowly be removed?
When I read many of the comments above I see an amazing community of developers and power users who want to be more involved in these macroscopic decisions, propose possible solutions and are struggling to be heard.
When I read your (sole) answer (and many other answers, or lack of them, on other issues and tickets) I only see an arrogant company of self-entitled jerks who take all the decisions without listening to their users, and probably dismiss the real issues of thousands of users who spent their money for your products in a single product meeting, without even bothering to provide any context outside of a telegraphic "it's for security reasons".
And I know that your arrogance and carelessness comes from the belief that both developers and users, despite all the barking, won't leave Android anyway, because of the lack of comparable alternatives out there - and those who do and decide to buy a PinePhone or install Ubuntu Touch are a negligible minority.
Let me just tell you that such a company of jerks doesn't deserve such a wonderful community. If you piss off the developers that build software for your platform too many times then those developers will start building an alternative - and that's how all monopolies usually collapse.
Lots of people have brought up plenty of valid use cases for clipboard managers, and many of them have heavily invested in the Android ecosystem to enhance their productivity.
We all fail to see the issue with treating clipboard access in the background as advanced on-request-only permission. If the OS is as transparent as possible to the user of what an app does, and the user accepts the risks, then the OS should get out of the way. Things are supposed to be as simple as this. The higher levels of freedom are one of the main reasons that drive people to buy Android instead of Apple devices, you know. Also, there are many ways apps can access a user's personal information in the background - does it mean that any permission that can be used to access PIIs in the background will slowly be removed?
When I read many of the comments above I see an amazing community of developers and power users who want to be more involved in these macroscopic decisions, propose possible solutions and are struggling to be heard.
When I read your (sole) answer (and many other answers, or lack of them, on other issues and tickets) I only see an arrogant company of self-entitled jerks who take all the decisions without listening to their users, and probably dismiss the real issues of thousands of users who spent their money for your products in a single product meeting, without even bothering to provide any context outside of a telegraphic "it's for security reasons".
And I know that your arrogance and carelessness comes from the belief that both developers and users, despite all the barking, won't leave Android anyway, because of the lack of comparable alternatives out there - and those who do and decide to buy a PinePhone or install Ubuntu Touch are a negligible minority.
Let me just tell you that such a company of jerks doesn't deserve such a wonderful community. If you piss off the developers that build software for your platform too many times then those developers will start building an alternative - and that's how all monopolies usually collapse.
mo...@gmail.com
I'm an ordinary(non-pro) user. Living without clipboard is a nightmare. Even Windows added it and Google has removed it! And what is an alternative solution recommended by Google? None.
ny...@gmail.com
STOP BEING DOUCHEBAGS! WTF is your problem? You've gotten too big for your own good, now you think you can treat us like CrApple treats their iPhone (iJunk) customers? Give us back our clipboard permissions!
im...@gmail.com
مجھے سمجھ نہیں آتی کہ کون لوگ ان کے کوالٹی کو چیک کرنے والے ہیں. جو ہمیشہ اچھی پالیسیز کا قلع قمع کرنے پر تلے ہوئے ہیں. جنہوں نے اورکٹ اور
گوگل پلس کا کباڑا کیا وہ اب اس اینڈرائیڈ کے درپے ہوئے ہوئے ہیں
ٹیکسٹ کوکاپی کرنے سے تعلیمی میدان میں بہت فائدہ اٹھایا گیا. مختلف ویب سائٹس اے ڈیٹا کاپی کرنا اور نوٹس بنانا یہ کلپ بورڈ مینجر جیسے فوائدبہت متاثر کن تھے .
گوگل پلس کا کباڑا کیا وہ اب اس اینڈرائیڈ کے درپے ہوئے ہوئے ہیں
ٹیکسٹ کوکاپی کرنے سے تعلیمی میدان میں بہت فائدہ اٹھایا گیا. مختلف ویب سائٹس اے ڈیٹا کاپی کرنا اور نوٹس بنانا یہ کلپ بورڈ مینجر جیسے فوائدبہت متاثر کن تھے .
gr...@gmail.com
Google naman tangina! Ano ba mali sa clipboard app. E sa ayoko gamitin yung clipboard nyo sa keyboard e. Ayusin nyo trabaho nyo!
l3...@gmail.com
And that's why I'll migrate to pinephone or Librem 5 as soon as possible
And stop using google services, google has become the evil that they always told them selves to not be
And stop using google services, google has become the evil that they always told them selves to not be
re...@gmail.com
Living without clipboard is a nightmare!
ca...@googlemail.com
Please fix this clipboard issue. I use my phone to fill in sign offs and copy and pasting lots of serial numbers etc is infinitely more difficult without clipboard apps working.
mo...@gmail.com
To my astonishment, even a functionality of Google Translate app has
stopped working. Because their own app cannot read the clipboard as
well! This is crazy!
stopped working. Because their own app cannot read the clipboard as
well! This is crazy!
lb...@gmail.com
Guys please consider starring this instead of writing to a "won't fix" issue:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/131947383
Or make new ideas. For now it doesn't seem like Google read here anymore, for a long time.
Or make new ideas. For now it doesn't seem like Google read here anymore, for a long time.
sa...@gmail.com
I would like all the beta stuff removed. Bring back the older Android 10 settings. I'm not tech savvy enough to say why, I don't care for the remembering previous texts notifications. I am unable to turn it off. Does anyone know the settings path for this request?
at...@gmail.com
Please fix the clipboard issue.
le...@gmail.com
I will work on filing an ADA complaint. Is there anyone else here with traumatic brain injury,physical impairment or cognitive disabilities would like to file a class action lawsuit against Google? By prohibiting this app it makes it almost impossible for some people like myself to have motion flexibily and to have access to something that will give them memory that they otherwise would not be able to have to reduced motions that allow communication and usage of other internet applications efficiently. This inability to save our work fluidly may be violating ADA. I use this app because it really helps me keep track of my information online. Without it I would be a mess. Are there those who are disabled physically or cognitively impaired doing the same thing? Lets now tell Google that apps that help the disabled and others and have a very big impact on the disabled in their access to information and their work that they produce must not be disabled arbitrarily and they must ensure they remain open and available to the users. We should figure out how the law and what they're doing Collides and sue the living mess out of them.
li...@gmail.com
This is absurd. I don't know why Google always chooses to implement new 'features' in the most destructive ways possible, but I'm SICK of it. I'm seriously considering abandoning android/google entirely due to the increasingly ham-fisted way google manages its products. I long ago lost count of the number of times I've asked myself "WTF are you doing Google??" when an app or feature I use it broken or removed entirely, often without warning and in spite of far less disruptive options they could have taken.
You guys need to focus on getting the baseline functionality of your products down, and stop sprinting towards every half-formed idea. This company is turning to shit, and has been for a long time.
You guys need to focus on getting the baseline functionality of your products down, and stop sprinting towards every half-formed idea. This company is turning to shit, and has been for a long time.
to...@gmail.com
Please allow clipstack, clipmate etc.
st...@gmail.com
after all this time it's become more than obvious that the monopoly known as Google needs to be broken apart..
Google has no intention of fixing this issue for the users.
Google has no intention of fixing this issue for the users.
ru...@gmail.com
Please don't remove clipstack
jo...@gmail.com
Really?! What ever happened to "don't be evil"? That's clearly long gone!
Even so that doesn't have to mean that you must render the most basic & fundamental functions of the OS! Security is good, but there's got to be a way to maintain security without disabling the clipboard- this is a crucial feature of an OS going back decades that has always been available to all the apps & processes running. Don't break that legacy for smart devices, that will really make them DUMB!
This is really such an obvious, blatant move by Google to limit & control what a user can do on a device he or she has already purchased. It's pathetic, shameful & disgusting!
Even so that doesn't have to mean that you must render the most basic & fundamental functions of the OS! Security is good, but there's got to be a way to maintain security without disabling the clipboard- this is a crucial feature of an OS going back decades that has always been available to all the apps & processes running. Don't break that legacy for smart devices, that will really make them DUMB!
This is really such an obvious, blatant move by Google to limit & control what a user can do on a device he or she has already purchased. It's pathetic, shameful & disgusting!
tl...@fernandomiguel.net
Although not ideal, since I'm a former clip stack user too,
Keep in mind keyboards can do this function very easily.
Both gboard and SwiftKey have clipboard functionality
Give it a try
Keep in mind keyboards can do this function very easily.
Both gboard and SwiftKey have clipboard functionality
Give it a try
dr...@gmail.com
Please, make our clipboard function again, which is one of the best clipboard manager I ever seen
Thanking you
Thanking you
ra...@gracelifechapel.co
Adding my voice to wanting this functionality back. Make it an advanced option if necessary.
s7...@gmail.com
I regularly and daily use clipboard to store text messages that I routinely sent to customers. I'm a business owner and not having access is hampering my business. In fact, there is information on my clipboard app right now that I need and can't access!!! Why was clipboard blocked???? What purpose did it serve??? smh...
br...@gmail.com
Multiple clips in the clipboard please - I use this function all the time during sales
lj...@gmail.com
Thanks
Best regards,
Lawrence Johnson
📞(863) 354-0329
📞(863) 852-5601
📠(973) 215-8605
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Monday, September 7, 2020 11:53:01 PM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
br...@gmail.com addedhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment428 >:
Multiple clips in the clipboard please - I use this function all the time during sales
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<https://issuetracker.google.com/components/190923 >
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123500346 >
duplicate issue: 128513320<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128513320 >, 128582282<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/128582282 >, 137878823<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137878823 >, 151168542<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151168542 >, 162347586<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/162347586 >
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/468531 >, Platform<https://issuetracker.google.com/hotlists/461195 >
retention: Component default
ReportedBy: Developer
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTrackerhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156 > where you have the role: starred.
Unsubscribe from this issue.<https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156?unsubscribe=true >
Best regards,
Lawrence Johnson
📞(863) 354-0329
📞(863) 852-5601
📠(973) 215-8605
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Monday, September 7, 2020 11:53:01 PM
To: b-system+663841872@google.com <b-system+663841872@google.com>
Cc: ljohnson329@gmail.com <ljohnson329@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
Changed
br...@gmail.com added
Multiple clips in the clipboard please - I use this function all the time during sales
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<
duplicate issue: 128513320<
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<
retention: Component default
ReportedBy: Developer
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.<
ge...@gmail.com
Multiple clips in the clipboard please - I use this function all the time
during sales
On Thu, Sep 3, 2020, 10:23 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
during sales
On Thu, Sep 3, 2020, 10:23 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
i....@gmail.com
Since 4.4 Android is heading in the wrong direction. It has not been upgrading but has been degrading.
That is the another proof.
That is the another proof.
cl...@gmail.com
Goodbye Android multitasking..Google buried the freedom of moves you gave us..
st...@gmail.com
It appears Google developers are not users.
They do not understand the consequences of their actions on the actual users.
They've decided that we are useless sheep who cannot make our own decision on this aspect of our security.
They do not understand the consequences of their actions on the actual users.
They've decided that we are useless sheep who cannot make our own decision on this aspect of our security.
na...@gmail.com
Agree with other users. Being back the usability of clipboard manager, yesterday. This has been a complaint for a year and a half. Listen to you user base. Gramma non-poweruser may not care, but it is clear from this thread that a large part of your username does. +1 for me!
n....@gmail.com
This is crazy to remove without giving alternative. Add security setting but dont just remove.
cl...@gmail.com
Please do not remove this app. I use it for everything I have to hold information that is important and I might need to look back on something from a month ago. It helps me on a legal situation when I had to copy something that would incriminate the person I was suing. And if I forget something I can look back through it because I know I copied it. I've literally looked at it like five times since you shut it down forgetting that you shut it down hoping that I would get my information that I have copied.
em...@gmail.com
Google ist ausserirdisch und seelenlos.. Ich habe begonnen Google zu verabscheuen..
G.P.Esposito 70j
G.P.Esposito 70j
no...@gmail.com
This is ridiculous to ban clip board managers. I have used one for many years and rely on it nearly every day. The is just arbitrary and capricious and punishes your customers and developers. Just another reason to avoid Google all together!
no...@gmail.com
Please put it back to how it was Google. There must be another way to make Android just as secure. Thankyou.
jr...@gmail.com
Please return functionality for clipboard access. I desperately miss my clipboard program and want it to function again.
ag...@gmail.com
PLEASE GIVE BACK OUR CLIPBOARD MANAGERS ! ! !
av...@gmail.com
Please give users the option to allow clipboard access for specific trusted apps, e.g. kdeconnect.That will help to make two factor authentication more widespread, i.e. it will improve overall security.
ma...@gmail.com
I also want access returned to clipboard managers! This is a terrible move on Google's part!
re...@gmail.com
I NEED MY CLIPBOARD
cr...@gmail.com
How could you do this to us Google without supplying a really great alternative
bo...@gmail.com
BRING BACK CLIPBOARD... GBOARD DOESN'T CUT IT
yr...@gmail.com
Please allow ClipStack to return to work on Android 10
jm...@gmail.com
BRING BACK CLIPBOARD... GBOARD DOESN'T CUT IT
re...@gmail.com
i need to share the clipboard. pls give back this feature!
al...@gmail.com
Please let the consumer set the permissions and allow the clipboard work as it used.
ma...@googlemail.com
This restriction is not in the interest of the users.
te...@gmail.com
I agree this current restriction of how I use my own personal clipboard has detrimentally affected my workflow and use of my Android devices. The ability to use my own clipboard information how I choose is one of the many reasons I prefer to use Android over ios devices. I use clipboard monitoring for defining Chinese text everyday, many times a day. Now that my phone is Android 10 I cannot use this feature in my Chinese Dictionary app Pleco. Please consider giving us per app access to clipboard monitoring, similar to the permissions we are able to choose for our other apps. This should be a fundamental core feature of Android over ios, the ability to use our own judgement on how our personal information is used and not be forced into a standard that drastically affects our workflow.
to...@gmail.com
𝙂𝙤𝙤𝙜𝙡𝙚, 𝙖𝙨 𝙖 𝙡𝙤𝙣𝙜 𝙩𝙞𝙢𝙚 𝙘𝙪𝙨𝙩𝙤𝙢𝙚𝙧 𝙤𝙛 𝙮𝙤𝙪𝙧𝙨, 𝙄 𝙖𝙢 𝙪𝙥𝙨𝙚𝙩 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙖𝙡𝙡𝙚𝙙 𝙗𝙮 𝙮𝙤𝙪𝙧 𝙘𝙝𝙤𝙞𝙘𝙚 𝙩𝙤 𝙗𝙖𝙣 𝙘𝙡𝙞𝙥𝙗𝙤𝙖𝙧𝙙 𝙢𝙖𝙣𝙖𝙜𝙚𝙧𝙨. 𝙄 𝙧𝙚𝙡𝙮 𝙤𝙣 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙆𝙞𝙣𝙜𝙨𝙤𝙛𝙩 𝙘𝙡𝙞𝙥𝙗𝙤𝙖𝙧𝙙 𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙡𝙞𝙘𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙨𝙘𝙝𝙤𝙤𝙡 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙗𝙪𝙨𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙨𝙨. 𝙔𝙤𝙪𝙧 𝙢𝙖𝙠𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙩𝙝𝙚𝙨𝙚 𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙡𝙞𝙘𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣𝙨 𝙤𝙗𝙨𝙤𝙡𝙚𝙩𝙚 𝙞𝙨 𝙣𝙚𝙖𝙧𝙡𝙮 𝙞𝙡𝙡𝙚𝙜𝙖𝙡. 𝙄𝙛 𝙨𝙤𝙢𝙚𝙤𝙣𝙚 𝙞𝙨 𝙣𝙤𝙩 𝙙𝙤𝙣𝙚, 𝙄 𝙬𝙞𝙡𝙡 𝙛𝙞𝙡𝙚 𝙖𝙣 𝙞𝙣𝙟𝙪𝙣𝙘𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣.
pj...@gmail.com
Hey Google,
If you do not intend to put a native clipboard manager in your OS do not remove the option for those of us who want/ need one. We know the risks and if we decide to take them then it's on us. This kind of "upgrade" sure doesn't feel like one.
If you do not intend to put a native clipboard manager in your OS do not remove the option for those of us who want/ need one. We know the risks and if we decide to take them then it's on us. This kind of "upgrade" sure doesn't feel like one.
ba...@gmail.com
Please do not remove clipboard app!
Maybe it's time to join the Apple family????
Maybe it's time to join the Apple family????
wo...@gmail.com
I see it as a criminal act what you've been doing.
ENOUGH OF YOUR SPY & TRACKING CRIMES.
I DO WISH GOOGLE WOULD BE DISMANTLED MORE THEN MICROSOFT WAS.
It's criminal monopoly imposing the users being controled and spied on them for making money on their meta data passed to those who pay for it.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app.
Do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps, google criminals!
ENOUGH OF YOUR SPY & TRACKING CRIMES.
I DO WISH GOOGLE WOULD BE DISMANTLED MORE THEN MICROSOFT WAS.
It's criminal monopoly imposing the users being controled and spied on them for making money on their meta data passed to those who pay for it.
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app.
Do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps, google criminals!
wo...@gmail.com
it's easy to access clipboard in windows 'cause google criminal behavior hasn't been able to subjugate it to that extent as they seem to do with android.
google must be dismantled into damn pieces.. much more than microsoft was when bill gates tried his monopoly system implement..
too much power to the corporate criminals, so that is to google..
i'm happy to see that the US government finally began its investigation on google's monopoly..
i hope google will be done, and other smaller companies will cooperate n give us better with more freedom service..
it's outrageous to see criminal monopoly behavior of googl gangster corporation
google must be dismantled into damn pieces.. much more than microsoft was when bill gates tried his monopoly system implement..
too much power to the corporate criminals, so that is to google..
i'm happy to see that the US government finally began its investigation on google's monopoly..
i hope google will be done, and other smaller companies will cooperate n give us better with more freedom service..
it's outrageous to see criminal monopoly behavior of googl gangster corporation
va...@gmail.com
This is so frustrating, moving to iOS
al...@gmail.com
As a user said before:
As a user of various clipboard manager apps, I really hope Google will find a way to allow apps to continue to have clipboard access.
As a user of various clipboard manager apps, I really hope Google will find a way to allow apps to continue to have clipboard access.
st...@gmail.com
I'm not sure how long the customers have to beg for something that should
be obvious. Give us our clipboards back.
On Fri, Nov 6, 2020, 2:16 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
be obvious. Give us our clipboards back.
On Fri, Nov 6, 2020, 2:16 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
jn...@gmail.com
I've long used an earlier tablet that had an enhanced clipboard manager as one of the pre-installed apps. I came to rely on the features of this app as essential. Now I find with the new tablet I have purchased, running Android 10, does not allow any kind of enhanced clipboard manager.
Please bring back clipboard management permissions ASAP.
Please bring back clipboard management permissions ASAP.
jm...@gmail.com
Again, give us back our clip board.
-------- Original message --------From: buganizer-system@google.com Date: 2020-11-08 10:23 p.m. (GMT-05:00) To: b-system+1742600667@google.com Cc: jmacknmo@gmail.com Subject: Re:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
jn...@gmail.com added
I've long used an earlier tablet that had an enhanced clipboard manager as one of the pre-installed apps. I came to rely on the features of this app as essential. Now I find with the new tablet I have purchased, running Android 10, does not allow any kind of enhanced clipboard manager.Please bring back clipboard management permissions ASAP.
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346
duplicate issue: 128513320, 128582282, 137878823, 151168542, 162347586
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned, Platform
retention: Component default
ReportedBy: Developer
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.
-------- Original message --------From: buganizer-system@google.com Date: 2020-11-08 10:23 p.m. (GMT-05:00) To: b-system+1742600667@google.com Cc: jmacknmo@gmail.com Subject: Re:
Changed
jn...@gmail.com added
I've long used an earlier tablet that had an enhanced clipboard manager as one of the pre-installed apps. I came to rely on the features of this app as essential. Now I find with the new tablet I have purchased, running Android 10, does not allow any kind of enhanced clipboard manager.Please bring back clipboard management permissions ASAP.
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346
duplicate issue: 128513320, 128582282, 137878823, 151168542, 162347586
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned, Platform
retention: Component default
ReportedBy: Developer
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.
cb...@gmail.com
This was a basic for me I organized my inventory by tracking numbers and it was so much simpler to unite them with clip stack
st...@gmail.com
Why is Google ignoring the customer base as usual? This is beyond
ridiculous.
On Sun, Nov 8, 2020, 8:07 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ridiculous.
On Sun, Nov 8, 2020, 8:07 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
sv...@gmail.com
Why these new security requirements weren't implemented as OPTIONS is beyond me. I can understand a roll for advanced security. Many users would prefer the CHOICE of trading security for functionality.
te...@gmail.com
Yesterday I updated my phone to Android 10.I was very disappointed that I found Google does not allow clipboard apps to have access to native clipboard.This is very frustrating. I was keeping not sensitive data like passwords and usernames from different websites for everyday use for the last four years in a clipboard app and now I have to spend hours to change most of the passwords and also lost access in some accounts because I don't have my username.Many people have NOT SENSITIVE DATA.Google had to deal with that.Too much security for no reason.I think it is time to degoogle my phone.
go...@gmail.com
Allow clipboard permissions for all apps.
la...@gmail.com
This is an outage. First of all, Android runs on the Linux kernel. If you can't play nice with open source software you shouldn't be allowed to continue using it as the engine for Android. It doesn't belong to YOU. It belongs to EVERYONE who uses it. Part of the copyleft license is that you DON'T RESTRICT OR LIMIT IT'S USE. In addition people PAY FOR THEIR PHONES FOR THEIR OWN USE. You don't get to decide how people use their phones. People use clipboard editors for multiple tasks, some of which are necessary for their work. This is not OK. I just personally lost the ability to copy and paste a user ID code to send to a developer from an archived email because I didn't know I wouldn't be able to go back to the clipboard history and paste the text from there. I need to be able to do that. MANY PEOPLE NEED TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT. This is absolutely unacceptable.
st...@gmail.com
I love how Google doesn't have time for users. They have proven themselves
to only care about control, power and the dollar. They know that their
decision on this issue is wrongheaded. And they choose to ignore the users.
Confidence is low that they will ever admit they were wrong and do
something about it.
On Sun, Nov 15, 2020, 3:24 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
to only care about control, power and the dollar. They know that their
decision on this issue is wrongheaded. And they choose to ignore the users.
Confidence is low that they will ever admit they were wrong and do
something about it.
On Sun, Nov 15, 2020, 3:24 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ag...@gmail.com
Give function back, please!
jo...@gmail.com
I understand that security plays a large factor in this decision but I rely on clipboard managers a GREAT DEAL! Lots of time I copy things to the clipboard and need to go back to them later and to use a note app to do this becomes a tedious and time consuming process. Ease bring back support for clipboard managers or a workaround!
si...@gmail.com
I understand that security plays a large factor in this decision but I rely on clipboard for my new vocabulary list
st...@gmail.com
It's so exciting to see how much Google cares about the end-user that isn't
in the corporate or billionaire class.
That was sarcasm.
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020, 12:07 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
in the corporate or billionaire class.
That was sarcasm.
On Mon, Nov 30, 2020, 12:07 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
co...@gmail.com
Just bought a new device running Android 10, only to find one of my most used apps Clip Stack no longer works due to what seems to me a draconian decision. Please make these apps usable again!
ob...@gmail.com
Please return the clipboard app permissions
tn...@gmail.com
Please allow clipboard access permissions to 3rd party apps. You are about to ruin your reputation.
ni...@gmail.com
my whole phone depend on this clipboard app please don't remove this apps I really really really really need this apps please give this kind of app permission from u
ni...@gmail.com
Please let us have our freedom let us install any apps we want in our phone we are not doing any bad thing with this apps its just a clipboard apps it’s help me copy multiple word and sentence that we need afterwards if u are a good company if u guys think about our Welfare then give us our freedom to use any apps we want.
ni...@gmail.com
I Know u guys Won't listen to me or any of us cuz u guys all are g a y and i also know that ur not gonna read my comment but we wont stop trying to and one day we will make u realise u guys were wrong and fix ur mistakes and give us our freedom to use any apps we want that's it for now
lo...@gmail.com
Please Google give us back clipboard access. Just let an app that wants to capture copy actions ask for the user's permission once.
dr...@gmail.com
On my last few phones I have found the ability to take screenshots and have them go to my clipboard for easy insertion into notes, emails, messages, etc. INVALUABLE. I used that fiction almost daily if not several times a day. It is extremely frustrating to have lost it!
pg...@gmail.com
Please restore clipboard acceds functionality to Andoid OS. This is essential to how i live my life. This is enoughbto force me seek out different type phones.
jf...@gmail.com
I've always respected Google but stopping clipboard aps is censorship pure and simple please alow us to express ourselves.
4s...@gmail.com
Google please undo this! This is a nightmare for users.
bz...@gmail.com
Why does Google do this? I use clip stack all the time!
jm...@gmail.com
Give us back our clipboards.
On Tue., Dec. 22, 2020, 8:35 a.m. , <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
On Tue., Dec. 22, 2020, 8:35 a.m. , <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ws...@gmail.com
Google doesn't give a f*** about this:
> Status: Won't Fix (Intended behavior)
> Status: Won't Fix (Intended behavior)
r....@gmail.com
Please accept clip stack
bu...@gmail.com
Oh man, why did this happen?
ch...@gmail.com
Please do not remove clipboard access permission to third party applications other than ime ones Expect Android to be the liberal ones
ch...@gmail.com
Android should not be iOS. It should all be about liberty and choice to the end user
vi...@gmail.com
Humble Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
ma...@gmail.com
Please allow us the users to designate specific apps to have background clipboard control. The clipboard in the keyboard apps I've tried don't have the features I want while dedicated clipboard managers do.
ro...@gmail.com
Fix this
dj...@gmail.com
I have an idea for an app concerned with privacy. Letting my app access clipboard data isn't necessary for my app to function as intended. However granting my app Clipboard access will yield much better user experience. I also plan to make my app open source so people can see for themselves that I don't collect data. I appreciate the security concern but there is a way to mitigate the security problem in and issue. Make accessing the clipboard a permission just like storage and location. Unless Google doesn't want competetors collecting data.
jo...@gmail.com
I realized that in Android 11, when you receive a text code for a login,
when you go to the box where you enter the code, it automatically shows it
above the keyboard like the word suggestions. I'm curious if you would be
able to access those codes using the clipboard permission and thus why
Google removed the permission from non-standard apps?
On Fri, Jan 8, 2021, 9:29 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
when you go to the box where you enter the code, it automatically shows it
above the keyboard like the word suggestions. I'm curious if you would be
able to access those codes using the clipboard permission and thus why
Google removed the permission from non-standard apps?
On Fri, Jan 8, 2021, 9:29 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
vk...@gmail.com
I regret updating my phone to android 10 now. I used this feature 1000x more than google assistant. KDEConnect's clipboard share just made life easier.
st...@gmail.com
For what it's worth, KDEConnect can still send the clipboard from Android to desktop/laptop by enabling the persistent notification setting and then hitting the "Send Clipboard" action in the notification.
But it sure would be easier if the clipboard was automatically synchronized.
But it sure would be easier if the clipboard was automatically synchronized.
an...@gmail.com
Please fix this.
jn...@gmail.com
Removing support from clipboard managers was a huge backward step for Android.
If there are subtle security issues you are still working to resolve, at least please provide a more feature rich standard clipboard system that includes a clip tray while you are working on security concerns.
If there are subtle security issues you are still working to resolve, at least please provide a more feature rich standard clipboard system that includes a clip tray while you are working on security concerns.
wa...@gmail.com
Removing support from clipboard managers was a huge backward step for
Android.
If there are subtle security issues you are still working to resolve, at
least please provide a more feature rich standard clipboard system that
includes a clip tray while you are working on security concerns.
On Sun, Jan 17, 2021, 8:52 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
Android.
If there are subtle security issues you are still working to resolve, at
least please provide a more feature rich standard clipboard system that
includes a clip tray while you are working on security concerns.
On Sun, Jan 17, 2021, 8:52 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
wa...@gmail.com
br...@gmail.com
I really don't like the backwards direction Android has been going with the clipboard options. At first we had the integrated option within the text highlight with the tap and hold, and that was working nicely, no app required. But that was removed, so now we had to use an app, which was less convenient but still functional. And now removing apps as a clipboard manager? I'm sorry but that is a stupid move. That's going to affect so many people who use that function for content creating and work and so many other functionalities. Please bring it back.
ch...@gmail.com
Clipboard access should of course be permission protected, by preventing it altogether is ridiculous when the Accessibility/Autofill API has access to the UI fields where the clipboard content in paste.
se...@gmail.com
Hey dev! add extra permission to copying text to third party apps but dont restrict it
Its so annoying
Its so annoying
ca...@gmail.com
I am handicapped with only one Hand. Pleased Bring this Feature back.
ma...@gmail.com
Hello Devs, I have to add my voice here! I've come to rely heavily on multiple clipboards & histories. Suffering from Multiple Sclerosis I don't require most of the built-in assistance features which can be restricting. I do however I do make use of what elements I can find including many 3rd party apps. Removing clipboard access unilaterally without even the option to personally accept any "risk" is another example of what feels like totalitarian decision making. Please consider at least offering individuals options to take responsibility and exempt themselves from such "security improvements" (without forcing the extremes of rooting or similar bypassing)
Thanks for any consideration.
Thanks for any consideration.
ws...@gmail.com
This deficient antifeature hurts me everyday since it was implemented! Receiving notification mail after mail from other people affected by this crap and seeing Google not giving a damn about it hurts as well, so I'm now unsubscribing from this issue. Good luck everyone, I feel you!
ch...@gmail.com
Bring it back!
ne...@gmail.com
Please bring it back. I need the clip stack, it helps me alot.
jo...@gmail.com
I have been using clip stack for years and have found it to be a great help. Please don't stop I from being able to use it
st...@gmail.com
Obviously they don't care about the users.
On Sun, Jan 31, 2021, 1:06 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
On Sun, Jan 31, 2021, 1:06 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ed...@gmail.com
I guess Google keeps it simple. Turn a deaf ear to all of us. Autocratic
rule is the new fashion. Vote for Trump ❓
On Monday, January 18, 2021, <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
rule is the new fashion. Vote for Trump ❓
On Monday, January 18, 2021, <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
sa...@gmail.com
Google I understand that your trying make Android more secure and private but this is not a good way to go about it.i also heard that your going to implement a feature in Android q that will let users know what apps are using what permissions at any given time that's good and I like the fact that Android informs users so they can take action but why cripple the functionality of the os when you already have plenty of security and privacy features put in place to protect users.alot of android user prefer android because of the freedom and choice it offers not only in terms of hardware but software as well.please think about this I don't think this would be beneficial to anyone I thought the reason for the permission in android was to strike the perfect balance between security and functionality by letting the user have the choice to disable and enable individual permissions,and now with android q users will definitely be informed about android's permission system since it's a privacy feature in android q.
bu...@gmail.com
Give control of MY clipboard data back to ME, damn you.
dj...@gmail.com
Google should be investing into others. I understand Google is trying to make it safer for Android Users. But controlling is turning into a problem and a goal to achieve for hackers to crack into it to feel powerful. Opening it up will discourage hackers and invest and partnership with other developers. As these developers who build apps for clip boards will be trusted. Doing this will create more jobs. Also, it protects and respects the frist amendment of the United States of America by keeping it open source.
ro...@gmail.com
yep, you hit the nail on the head!
On Tue, Feb 23, 2021, 1:06 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
On Tue, Feb 23, 2021, 1:06 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
al...@gmail.com
I agree, dont take away the copy history.
Because it is a very usefull function to have on a smartphone.
If Google restricts more and more functions in the Android UI,
people will go over to other alternatives.
Because it is a very usefull function to have on a smartphone.
If Google restricts more and more functions in the Android UI,
people will go over to other alternatives.
su...@gmail.com
Hey, I want my multi clipboard!
ks...@gmail.com
This is terrible. I finally bought a new phone, now I can't use Clip Stack thanks to google. I am a professional writer, I depend on Clip Stack and have for years. If you are going to do something like this, at least have your own alternatives! What am I supposed to do? I won't be able to work on my new phone now. I'll have to use my old phone which is utterly ridiculous. This was a terrible decision Google, I'm not happy at all.
ai...@gmail.com
Hey google please let clipstack work again as before..... please please please
on...@gmail.com
Bring it back already. There was no flipping warning the phone was going to the next level and you guys never tell people because of TOS what's going to be removed or not work afterwards. A heads up would have been nice so that stuff that I have locked in two different clipboard background accounts I could have copied or exported. Now there's important stuff to mean it's been lost. I don't know how the hell this has to do with security. Like everybody else I think you're full of shit. And worse you promised way back then that you were going to come up with your own that would be secure. That was a lie too because it's been something like a year and I'm on already the next level updated, and you still have not released it as far as I can tell. I can't read every single one of the thousands of messages here to see if there's a viable workaround, but I've also been using gboard for years, and there doesn't seem to be anything in there there. This is absolutely mean and pathetic. It's getting to the point now where after 20 years of cell phones I'm considering wanting to root a phone. I'm certainly not going to go Apple, and the reason why I got a flipping Android to be a part of the vaunted open source environment, and I constantly feel like there's a lack of parameters to customize the phone. Like my back is up against the wall constantly. You also took away message tones out of contacts for assigning individual custom tones to individual contacts so you could know without looking who was texting you by the tone. You falsely claimed that that was also in the name of security and that it was only going to be temporary. And what's it been? Flipping 3 years? This might end up being my last Android/Google phone if I don't root it. I've been doing research for a couple weeks now about buying Android phones that are stripped of Google, or getting more pure Linux phones. And then of course, we all feel like we're pissing in the ocean if we try to suggest or complain to you guys cuz so many people have Google stuff, so you guys don't care. Heck I even thought about suing you because I had important information locked in clipboard accounts that I never had the ability to get out because of no heads up from you. It's flipping 2021, 21 years into the New millennium and there's are certain basic things that there is absolutely no excuse to not be warning people or helping people. There should be a detailed list of what's going to change before you upgrade. A link that you can go to that is prepared by your freaking developers to tell people everything whether good or bad to the user that is going to change so that they can be prepared. With all the stuff that the developers know, and has to get approved before happening, there is just simply no excuse to not give a list prepared for regular end users to see! This is complete unprofessional laziness and inefficiency. Absolutely no excuse. Maybe most people don't care, but for the people that do there is no reason why we can't click on a link not only after, but especially before an update even if it's just a security update, and see exactly what's going to change, what bugs fixed, what features are being added or taken away.... So that we can act accordingly. Again I don't think I'm buying another regular Android phone after this. I just can't handle it anymore. You don't respond to individuals through developer emails, you've shut off all access to Google support even for people who pay highway robbery prices for things like YouTube Red premium, which also sucks that we are forced to pay such a high price for access to things we don't want like YouTube music. All We freaking wanted was the ability to do screen timeout and avoid the ad apocalypse, and I have to freaking pay $150 a year with no support???? You're already raping us for all of our personal information through your surveillance Tech, the least you can do is give us some freaking Vaseline so that we can have a product that we are happy with. Don't pretend like you don't know what people want people are very vocal about things that they want and need special would you steal them from us for no reason. With the programmability of their phones there's no reason why we can't get more and more options, instead of taking away features and adding new features. Come on be honest the last two or three updates have been basically irrelevant anyway. Cell phone platforms are basically static. Nothing changes except for hardware getting 5% bigger on new devices. It's time if you can't come up with anything new in cell phone technology, that you start making these devices the way they're supposed to be ....with customizable programmability parameters. It's fine if it's set up to default for simple users, but with medium or higher level users that don't want to root their phone, allow there to be parameters so we can set it up to be how we want. Again, there's no excuse but unprofessional laziness. It seems like all you guys do is move things around with each update anyway. Like the developers move stuff to make it seem like it's different, when nothing is really truly new. But you fake out the customers to make it think it's been a serious upgrade because they have a learning curve now to find out where everything was that they used to know exactly where it was. Stupid. With all the frustration out there, it's only a matter of time before somebody else comes around and it becomes the next hottest thing, because you just don't give a crap about users. Greedy greedy greedy. Selfish selfish selfish. I will continue my search to find out what my next non-google phone will be. Then I will be migrating because you are not looking to please customers. Not looking to offer good support. Not aiming to please whatsoever.
ro...@gmail.com
I don't spend a lot of time engaging with/about godgle but this post
deserves an ACK.
It's here, in case the citation gets stripped:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment522
20-odd years ago, I viewed google as a valuable, educational search
resource. Gradually, steadily, increasingly, that objective usefulness
has been diluted, eroded, and corrupted by greed for wealth, greed for
power, IMO. Top search results are bought. "Help" is comprised of
cheap, "community" billboards such as this one. There is no interaction
with functionaries, save the occasional condescending snark that,
probably, serves the compensation calculus for devs having a bad day.
If you were on fire, Sergey wouldn't piss on you unless there was a
nickel in it for him.
Worse, unmitigated success and greed has brought us election meddling,
censorship, erasure of any thought, person, or (historical) fact that
does not serve the NARRATIVE. All of Big Tech seem to be of the same
mind. Critical thinking, productive discourse, individuality, the
rights and freedoms enumerated and protected by the Constitution, the
Rule of Law, itself, all are rapidly being destroyed by a malicious
megalomania.
Wake up.
Rolf Pedersen
On 3/4/21 5:35 AM, buganizer-system@google.com wrote:
deserves an ACK.
It's here, in case the citation gets stripped:
20-odd years ago, I viewed google as a valuable, educational search
resource. Gradually, steadily, increasingly, that objective usefulness
has been diluted, eroded, and corrupted by greed for wealth, greed for
power, IMO. Top search results are bought. "Help" is comprised of
cheap, "community" billboards such as this one. There is no interaction
with functionaries, save the occasional condescending snark that,
probably, serves the compensation calculus for devs having a bad day.
If you were on fire, Sergey wouldn't piss on you unless there was a
nickel in it for him.
Worse, unmitigated success and greed has brought us election meddling,
censorship, erasure of any thought, person, or (historical) fact that
does not serve the NARRATIVE. All of Big Tech seem to be of the same
mind. Critical thinking, productive discourse, individuality, the
rights and freedoms enumerated and protected by the Constitution, the
Rule of Law, itself, all are rapidly being destroyed by a malicious
megalomania.
Wake up.
Rolf Pedersen
On 3/4/21 5:35 AM, buganizer-system@google.com wrote:
ra...@gmail.com
I used my clipboard for saving interesting news articles to discuss with peers and friends.
Why is it too hard for us to have articles of discussion in a clipboard?
Why is it too hard for us to have articles of discussion in a clipboard?
re...@gmail.com
Frustrating...
Don't be EVIL google ... And do NOT become APPLE...if we wanted these kind of futures removed we could get stupid toys like iphone... For the illusion of privacy u killed many useful apps...shame! Shame!
Don't be EVIL google ... And do NOT become APPLE...if we wanted these kind of futures removed we could get stupid toys like iphone... For the illusion of privacy u killed many useful apps...shame! Shame!
ol...@gmail.com
Should be a separate permission that can be allowed for apps. I can understand the security concern if it's allowed without explicit confirmation by the user but just removing it is (as you may probably see from the many frustrated users here) a really bad idea and breaks many widely used apps (ClipStack, KDE Connect, ...).
[Deleted User] <[Deleted User]>
I would just add, Google, that if Android had native necessary features like UNDO, REDO, plus you've got this perfect place to easily access cut/copy snippets in gboard. But why in the world don't you allow that section to vertically scroll and if I want to keep 100 items let me keep 100 items.
So many play store apps exist because you guys never really seem to understand how people use their phones... There's a difference between "nice to have" task specific apps and critical functionality. We get why you do things like kill call recording, and now this, all premised on security, a good thing when it does its job in prevents rogue apps from stealing data.. but you punish us by breaking these critical functionality apps that you won't build yourself.
So many play store apps exist because you guys never really seem to understand how people use their phones... There's a difference between "nice to have" task specific apps and critical functionality. We get why you do things like kill call recording, and now this, all premised on security, a good thing when it does its job in prevents rogue apps from stealing data.. but you punish us by breaking these critical functionality apps that you won't build yourself.
AJ...@hotmail.co.uk
How do I star this? The app I came from said I should
ma...@gmail.com
I hate it you messed up my keyboard, moved things around changed my color and apps now my freaking clipboard this is messed up change it back I hate these freaking forced updates.
su...@gmail.com
Give back my clipboard!
cl...@gmail.com
bo...@gmail.com
Adding my voice! Please Google REINSTATE THE CLIPBOARD CAPTURE FACILITY FOR APPS. What you've done has disabled an app I've been using every day for years. WHY CUT DOWN ON ANDROID FEATURES FOR USERS?!
al...@gmail.com
Please get the clipboard permission back
ro...@gmail.com
😭😭😭
st...@gmail.com
From the very beginning of this thread I have been cynical about the
chances that Google gave a crap about how we feel about clipboards. And
nothing has changed my opinion.
On Thu, Apr 8, 2021, 1:58 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
chances that Google gave a crap about how we feel about clipboards. And
nothing has changed my opinion.
On Thu, Apr 8, 2021, 1:58 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ko...@gmail.com
YESS, please do not remove it! it's absolutely essential for us.
st...@gmail.com
Please get the clipboard permission back
se...@gmail.com
Please, get the clipboard permission back.
su...@gmail.com
I want my clipboard back!
1l...@gmail.com
adb -d shell appops set com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW allow; adb -d shell pm grant com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager android.permission.READ_LOGS; adb shell am force-stop com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager;
How am i supposed to do this on a computer if thr app is on a mobile. You haven't provided instructions on how to do 5his to get your app to work again?
lb...@gmail.com
@540 Say, is it possible to do it using another smartphone that will call it?
I wonder
I wonder
wo...@gmail.com
It's taking ages and despicable google keeps robbing us from the freedom of
our choices.
Quite the same as it's been attacking our civil liberties and free speech.
It's high time to begin eliminating the traitors of our freedoms!
On Wed, Apr 14, 2021, 16:14 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
our choices.
Quite the same as it's been attacking our civil liberties and free speech.
It's high time to begin eliminating the traitors of our freedoms!
On Wed, Apr 14, 2021, 16:14 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
zw...@email.de
I don't think Google ist still looking into this discussion, as its staus is set to "won't fix".
The only thing we can do to point google to this issue is to open new issues with the request to fix this.
All of them have to be reviewed by a google worker. They will be marked as duplicate to this issue, but at least they are forced to look at this issue.
The more of these duplicates have to be marked, the more google will have to have a look at this issue.
So everyone: Write new issues with this request, not only once, but regularly. I don't know if this can change anything, but it's worth a try.
Sorry google, but simply setting this to "won't fix" despite all the remaining problems and all the good comments of an alternate behaviour is a bad thing. You have to reconsider your opinion.
The only thing we can do to point google to this issue is to open new issues with the request to fix this.
All of them have to be reviewed by a google worker. They will be marked as duplicate to this issue, but at least they are forced to look at this issue.
The more of these duplicates have to be marked, the more google will have to have a look at this issue.
So everyone: Write new issues with this request, not only once, but regularly. I don't know if this can change anything, but it's worth a try.
Sorry google, but simply setting this to "won't fix" despite all the remaining problems and all the good comments of an alternate behaviour is a bad thing. You have to reconsider your opinion.
ka...@gmail.com
I wish to give some input on this. As the user of a pixel phone with the
most recent update of the Android OS, I have to say that Google has handled
this fairly decently in the native Pixel clipboard.
If you click on the paste clipboard in the line of characters above the
keyboard, you'll notice that your recent history of copies are there. If
you long-press one of those items, you have the option to pin that item and
it will stay in your clipboard indefinitely. Anything you don't pin will
expire within a few days keeping the clipboard clean.
Frankly, I like that option more than either of the two clipboard managers
I've used in the past because it takes no extra space on my phone and also
works very well.
I hope this doesn't make me horribly unpopular, but I applaud Google for
how they have filled a gap for me, at least, and encourage you to get to
know how they have done it. If you have a non-google phone, you need to
talk to them about using the native clipboard functionality as provided by
Google. It really is quite nice.
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
Pardon brevity or typos. Sent from my phone.
---
On Wed, Apr 14, 2021, 10:37 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
most recent update of the Android OS, I have to say that Google has handled
this fairly decently in the native Pixel clipboard.
If you click on the paste clipboard in the line of characters above the
keyboard, you'll notice that your recent history of copies are there. If
you long-press one of those items, you have the option to pin that item and
it will stay in your clipboard indefinitely. Anything you don't pin will
expire within a few days keeping the clipboard clean.
Frankly, I like that option more than either of the two clipboard managers
I've used in the past because it takes no extra space on my phone and also
works very well.
I hope this doesn't make me horribly unpopular, but I applaud Google for
how they have filled a gap for me, at least, and encourage you to get to
know how they have done it. If you have a non-google phone, you need to
talk to them about using the native clipboard functionality as provided by
Google. It really is quite nice.
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com
Pardon brevity or typos. Sent from my phone.
---
On Wed, Apr 14, 2021, 10:37 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ar...@gmail.com
Give us back the apps we paid for. This is theft!
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Wednesday, April 14, 2021 5:46:23 PM
To: b-system+-1204855705@google.com <b-system+-1204855705@google.com>
Cc: arro1834@gmail.com <arro1834@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156
Changed
ka...@gmail.com addedhttps://issuetracker.google.com/issues/123461156#comment544 >:
I wish to give some input on this. As the user of a pixel phone with the
most recent update of the Android OS, I have to say that Google has handled
this fairly decently in the native Pixel clipboard.
If you click on the paste clipboard in the line of characters above the
keyboard, you'll notice that your recent history of copies are there. If
you long-press one of those items, you have the option to pin that item and
it will stay in your clipboard indefinitely. Anything you don't pin will
expire within a few days keeping the clipboard clean.
Frankly, I like that option more than either of the two clipboard managers
I've used in the past because it takes no extra space on my phone and also
works very well.
I hope this doesn't make me horribly unpopular, but I applaud Google for
how they have filled a gap for me, at least, and encourage you to get to
know how they have done it. If you have a non-google phone, you need to
talk to them about using the native clipboard functionality as provided by
Google. It really is quite nice.
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com<mailto:karlplds@gmail.com>
Pardon brevity or typos. Sent from my phone.
---
On Wed, Apr 14, 2021, 10:37 AM <buganizer-system@google.com<mailto:buganizer-system@google.com>> wrote:
________________________________
From: buganizer-system@google.com <buganizer-system@google.com>
Sent: Wednesday, April 14, 2021 5:46:23 PM
To: b-system+-1204855705@google.com <b-system+-1204855705@google.com>
Cc: arro1834@gmail.com <arro1834@gmail.com>
Subject: Re:
Replying to this email means your email address will be shared with the team that works on this product.
Changed
ka...@gmail.com added
I wish to give some input on this. As the user of a pixel phone with the
most recent update of the Android OS, I have to say that Google has handled
this fairly decently in the native Pixel clipboard.
If you click on the paste clipboard in the line of characters above the
keyboard, you'll notice that your recent history of copies are there. If
you long-press one of those items, you have the option to pin that item and
it will stay in your clipboard indefinitely. Anything you don't pin will
expire within a few days keeping the clipboard clean.
Frankly, I like that option more than either of the two clipboard managers
I've used in the past because it takes no extra space on my phone and also
works very well.
I hope this doesn't make me horribly unpopular, but I applaud Google for
how they have filled a gap for me, at least, and encourage you to get to
know how they have done it. If you have a non-google phone, you need to
talk to them about using the native clipboard functionality as provided by
Google. It really is quite nice.
---
Karl L. Pearson | karlplds@gmail.com<mailto:karlplds@gmail.com>
Pardon brevity or typos. Sent from my phone.
---
On Wed, Apr 14, 2021, 10:37 AM <buganizer-system@google.com<mailto:buganizer-system@google.com>> wrote:
_______________________________
Reference Info: 123461156 Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
component: Android Public Tracker<
status: Intended Behavior
reporter: lb...@gmail.com
assignee: cc...@google.com
cc: da...@google.com, lb...@gmail.com
type: Feature Request
priority: P1
severity: S3
blocked by: 123500346<
duplicate issue: 128513320<
hotlist: [AOSP] assigned<
retention: Component default
ReportedBy: Developer
Generated by Google IssueTracker notification system
You're receiving this email because you are subscribed to updates on Google IssueTracker
Unsubscribe from this issue.<
lb...@gmail.com
For now, you can star and comment on requests that might soften this or provide alternatives for users and developers, such as:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/135471818
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/149413822
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/151294241
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/158644887
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/185304449
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/158646295
ag...@gmail.com
Please address this.
mu...@gmail.com
Yes, I 2support the re-introduction
sh...@gmail.com
Google,
Is this America and we are capable of making our own decisions or is this a fucking dictatorship and you decide what we can and cannot use on devices WE pay for???? Seriously, you need to let go of the all powerful is complex and allow people to CHOOSE wtf they want to use and not use. Or better yet since you feel the need to have your hand in EVERYTHING provide the damn services yourselves that you keep fckin taking away from consumers as well as from developers. Has it occured to you if you offered an equivalent clipboard option people wouldn't feel the need to seek it elsewhere??? This is the shit that makes me people go elsewhere or start seeking and using illegal softwares and shit, hence defeating the purpose of your bullshit ass so called "safety precautions". God damn, let it go. You don't run the fckin world.
Is this America and we are capable of making our own decisions or is this a fucking dictatorship and you decide what we can and cannot use on devices WE pay for???? Seriously, you need to let go of the all powerful is complex and allow people to CHOOSE wtf they want to use and not use. Or better yet since you feel the need to have your hand in EVERYTHING provide the damn services yourselves that you keep fckin taking away from consumers as well as from developers. Has it occured to you if you offered an equivalent clipboard option people wouldn't feel the need to seek it elsewhere??? This is the shit that makes me people go elsewhere or start seeking and using illegal softwares and shit, hence defeating the purpose of your bullshit ass so called "safety precautions". God damn, let it go. You don't run the fckin world.
ro...@gmail.com
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Godgle, CCP, et al are working on it. Give em time. Or, stand in defiance.
Godgle, CCP, et al are working on it. Give em time. Or, stand in defiance.
dr...@gmail.com
What a shame
Gboard sucks
Gboard sucks
jo...@gmail.com
The prpgressive restrictions of android in every new version shows a trend. With each new version I cannot use several
It s tune to leave the dining ski
It s tune to leave the dining ski
ba...@gmail.com
Please do not remove clipboard access permission. I haave a samsung m31s which does not support clipboard in samsung keyboard and i have no idea why considering many other samsung phones have this ability. So my only way out is to use none system apps.
ma...@gmail.com
adb -d shell appops set com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW allow;
adb -d shell pm grant com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager android.permission.READ_LOGS;
adb shell am force-stop com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager;
adb -d shell pm grant com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager android.permission.READ_LOGS;
adb shell am force-stop com.catchingnow.tinyclipboardmanager;
ne...@fartbeans.com
Please unban clipboard managers! Without clipboard managers, it becomes very difficult to make workflow even somewhat seamless.
oa...@gmail.com
Please allow clipboard managers in all future versions.
Clipboard history is a valuable resource for every user.
Appart for many uses, it can also work as rescue information at sometimes.
I cannot imagine working without clipboard manager.
Clipboard history is a valuable resource for every user.
Appart for many uses, it can also work as rescue information at sometimes.
I cannot imagine working without clipboard manager.
bl...@gmail.com
We need some way to manage clips on a cell phone. I'm aware of privacy issues but without a clipboard manager there's just too much typing and too many things that we need to Pace back into our text. Please, please give us away to have a good clipboard manager.
mo...@gmail.com
The best thing to do is to change the phone
sa...@gmail.com
Please give users the permission to choose if certain apps can read the clipboard or not. This is functionality that a lot of users use and is beneficial to their day to day activities
na...@gmail.com
Re-enable clipboard access and stop banning 3rd party app functionality! This is anti-trust!
The whole point of an open source OS like Android, is for 3rd party dev's to fill in the gaps missed by the OS itself. Hell, you already scrape 15-30% of the revenue off the backs of devs, let them operate.
I get there are bad actors, however "blanket banning" is not the answer. Permissions are permissions. Find a better way. Stop killing 3rd party dev, UX, and ultimately yourselves in the process.
The whole point of an open source OS like Android, is for 3rd party dev's to fill in the gaps missed by the OS itself. Hell, you already scrape 15-30% of the revenue off the backs of devs, let them operate.
I get there are bad actors, however "blanket banning" is not the answer. Permissions are permissions. Find a better way. Stop killing 3rd party dev, UX, and ultimately yourselves in the process.
lo...@gmail.com
Comment has been deleted.
ro...@gmail.com
na...@gmail.com na...@gmail.com #560Jun 27, 2021 04:07PM Re-enable clipboard access and stop banning 3rd party app functionality! This is anti-trust! The whole point of an open source OS like Android, is for 3rd party dev's to fill in the gaps missed by the OS itself. Hell, you already scrape 15-30% of the revenue off the backs of devs, let them operate. I get there are bad actors, however "blanket banning" is not the answer. Permissions are permissions. Find a better way. Stop killing 3rd party dev, UX, and ultimately yourselves in the process.
This hit the nail on the head! Same concern with Phone Call Recording and the accessibility blitz that about got Tasker removed (with little to no communication with devs, I might add).
po...@gmx.de
As a user of clipboard manager I find it very annoying that it doesn't work anymore since Android 10
st...@gmail.com
Google does not care about its users.
On Thu, Jul 8, 2021, 12:38 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
On Thu, Jul 8, 2021, 12:38 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
jb...@gmail.com
Not having a clipboard is crippling. Please restore it or provide another similar way of copying and pasting information including images between applications.
zo...@gmail.com
Yes plz
aj...@gmail.com
Plz unblock
eg...@gmail.com
re...@gmail.com
Hi. Yes, the clipboard manager is very useful. Please restore this possibility. Thanks.
ny...@gmail.com
When I read about this two years ago, I knew in an instant what I would need to do, if Google moved ahead with this issue.
Have always had the Clipstack widget on my screen.
I do not copy to it.
I SHARE to clipstack.
Works perfect.I can open the actual app and export everything, delete entries,edit my list or indiv.entry......etc.
Works wonderful.
Kind of a bandaid instead of a tourniquet.
But life is like that.
If you need any other help on this, just post, happy to help fine tune.
Have always had the Clipstack widget on my screen.
I do not copy to it.
I SHARE to clipstack.
Works perfect.I can open the actual app and export everything, delete entries,edit my list or indiv.entry......etc.
Works wonderful.
Kind of a bandaid instead of a tourniquet.
But life is like that.
If you need any other help on this, just post, happy to help fine tune.
fr...@gmail.com
I support the resolution of the issue.
Fr. Tom Frink, SJ
P.O. Box 10000, PMB 538
Saipan, MP 96950-8900
---------------------
Google Voice: (978) 361-2715
Skype: Frinkt1
WhatsApp: Fr. Tom Frink, SJ
Facebook: Tom Frink, SJ
Be a Jesuit! <https://www.beajesuit.org/ >
On Sun, Jul 25, 2021 at 11:39 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
Fr. Tom Frink, SJ
P.O. Box 10000, PMB 538
Saipan, MP 96950-8900
---------------------
Google Voice: (978) 361-2715
Skype: Frinkt1
WhatsApp: Fr. Tom Frink, SJ
Facebook: Tom Frink, SJ
Be a Jesuit! <
On Sun, Jul 25, 2021 at 11:39 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ba...@gmail.com
Not having a clipboard is crippling. Please restore it or provide another similar way of copying and pasting information including images between applications.
ne...@gmail.com
Please can you add permission for access to the clipboard. I really want a different tools to access and work with the clipboard
sw...@outlook.com
Using a clipboard manager was part of my life, without access makes my daily routine alot harder. Please consider to enable the access once again as I think this will be useful for a lot of people.
li...@gmail.com
I just want to add, that all of you android nerds are so hot. Look at you all passionate and for the balance! So hot, so very very hot.
( . Y . )
8===D.
( . Y . )
8===D.
de...@gmail.com
To anyone who wants clipboard monitoring functionality back can install this app from
fa...@hotmail.com
fe...@gmail.com
.
ma...@gmail.com
Seconded
wa...@gmail.com
wa...@gmail.com
wa...@gmail.com
ki...@gmail.com
lj...@gmail.com
ms...@gmail.com
Add my name to the list of dissatisfied Google users at having this feature affected.
st...@googlemail.com
me too:
Add my name to the list of dissatisfied Google users at having this feature affected.
thank you
Add my name to the list of dissatisfied Google users at having this feature affected.
thank you
lj...@gmail.com
ze...@gmail.com
me too:
Add my name to the list of dissatisfied Google users at having this feature affected.
thank you
Add my name to the list of dissatisfied Google users at having this feature affected.
thank you
co...@gmail.com
Yes add my name. I hate the clipboard restrictions. It's not protecting
ANYBODY
On Sat, Aug 28, 2021, 7:54 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ANYBODY
On Sat, Aug 28, 2021, 7:54 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
yi...@gmail.com
if i feel restricted when i use Android, why not just go for Iphone.
Clipboard restriction sucks.
Clipboard restriction sucks.
ma...@gmail.com
Hey google, what about the clipboard restrictions?
I need to copy paste my answers everytime i gave feedback on my email, my bussines account or anything else.
I use Clip Stack app to reuse common answers and mow its impossible. What a heck!
I need to copy paste my answers everytime i gave feedback on my email, my bussines account or anything else.
I use Clip Stack app to reuse common answers and mow its impossible. What a heck!
wo...@gmail.com
Google is nothing but a criminal antihuman leftist mafia.
I just keep my best not to have anything to do with that corporate
prostitute of traitors to us the people.
Millions of others like me will be there when Google faces criminal
charges, and we'll all vote for the death of Google gangster corporation
and those who rule that crime family.
No begging for anything!
Just move away from that stinky garbage google.
Move to other OSs, platforms, search engines, free speech space, etc., and
wait for the time to pay back to those technowhore Luciferian corporate
bitches.
On Sat, Sep 18, 2021, 19:29 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
I just keep my best not to have anything to do with that corporate
prostitute of traitors to us the people.
Millions of others like me will be there when Google faces criminal
charges, and we'll all vote for the death of Google gangster corporation
and those who rule that crime family.
No begging for anything!
Just move away from that stinky garbage google.
Move to other OSs, platforms, search engines, free speech space, etc., and
wait for the time to pay back to those technowhore Luciferian corporate
bitches.
On Sat, Sep 18, 2021, 19:29 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
va...@yagati.com
Request: Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it
as...@gmail.com
Please Do not remove clipboard permission and do not let only system apps have it. I absolutely need the app I used for a long time for managing my clipboard.
lo...@gmail.com
More of what I despise about Google.
ja...@gmail.com
Ok, I'm very late for this seems like; but I guess I noticed when changed to a newer decide and noticing that some of my workflows are broken and that my experience is worse, so I'll rant a bit.
I'm going to call this move regarding the clipboard (and can also be applied to other things that others have shared) 'secupidity', or security by stupidity. When removing a feature to make things more secure, what really happens is that the device becomes less useful since now in order to complete tasks more steps are needed if at all possible. I'm totally in favor of increasing security, hell who wants calculators that need the location to work?, and that if you not grant the permission they don't work at all?. So yes, perfectly in favor of increasing security, but that is done through permissions, maybe permissions that the app can not automatically request or even now the status of it (so they can not stop working if the user doesn't grant it); but in the end the user has to have the control over it.
I have read several people complaining in this thread about the apps they use no longer working and some of them even stating that they will move to iOS. I try to avoid Apple because of the closed ecosystem, but I agree with the views in this post Google Android is looking more and more like a closed system; so totally understand their point.
As of me, just starting with a new phone, and when I started to use one of my core apps, KDEConnect; I see that the most basic thing, copying from the cellphone to the PC does not work, just great. I already considered a problem the high customizable UIs from different manufacturers on top of Android to be an issue (I was for 5+ with the same phone in plain Android just because I didn't want to have customizations on top of Adnroid), but seems like even plain Android itself is going backwards. At this rate, I suspect my next phone will be in the cheaper segment and one that has good support for LinageOS or any other variation that doesn't impose a gated system.
Final thoughts, I would like to encourage to take this kind of changes very seriously and proceed with extreme caution when removing features; even if this clipboard support gets restored in a next version (fingers crossed), due to the short support from manufacturers (from 1 to maybe 3 yeras?) that means that many devices won't receive the fix and thus will remain providing subpar experiences to their owners (in this front seems more likely that an iOS user might have more lack since Apple at least supports their devices for a somewhat reasonable time). So yeah secupidity in its fullest.
I'm going to call this move regarding the clipboard (and can also be applied to other things that others have shared) 'secupidity', or security by stupidity. When removing a feature to make things more secure, what really happens is that the device becomes less useful since now in order to complete tasks more steps are needed if at all possible. I'm totally in favor of increasing security, hell who wants calculators that need the location to work?, and that if you not grant the permission they don't work at all?. So yes, perfectly in favor of increasing security, but that is done through permissions, maybe permissions that the app can not automatically request or even now the status of it (so they can not stop working if the user doesn't grant it); but in the end the user has to have the control over it.
I have read several people complaining in this thread about the apps they use no longer working and some of them even stating that they will move to iOS. I try to avoid Apple because of the closed ecosystem, but I agree with the views in this post Google Android is looking more and more like a closed system; so totally understand their point.
As of me, just starting with a new phone, and when I started to use one of my core apps, KDEConnect; I see that the most basic thing, copying from the cellphone to the PC does not work, just great. I already considered a problem the high customizable UIs from different manufacturers on top of Android to be an issue (I was for 5+ with the same phone in plain Android just because I didn't want to have customizations on top of Adnroid), but seems like even plain Android itself is going backwards. At this rate, I suspect my next phone will be in the cheaper segment and one that has good support for LinageOS or any other variation that doesn't impose a gated system.
Final thoughts, I would like to encourage to take this kind of changes very seriously and proceed with extreme caution when removing features; even if this clipboard support gets restored in a next version (fingers crossed), due to the short support from manufacturers (from 1 to maybe 3 yeras?) that means that many devices won't receive the fix and thus will remain providing subpar experiences to their owners (in this front seems more likely that an iOS user might have more lack since Apple at least supports their devices for a somewhat reasonable time). So yeah secupidity in its fullest.
pa...@gmail.com
Clipboard managers are life savers, breaking them and blaming user security is nonsense, will you deny all the apps accessing my drive, GPS, contacts? No cause I have the choice to set access rights per app and because those features are pretty damn useful. So is the clipboard
kh...@gmail.com
ze...@gmail.com
Disallowing clipboard managers is the wrong way to go. Users want freedom. I prefer Android over any other OS because of it being open source so us users can get the most out of it. But it started to go on the road of other systems. The number of regulations are growing. We do not want it to become a locked/closed OS.
wl...@gmail.com
Limiting users freedom because owners want more money is a way to make best developers go to some other truly open source platform
mf...@att.net
Limiting app access to the clipboard function makes no sense, even from a security standpoint, relative to the inconvenience and difficulty in use stemming from the removal of a very handy tool. Like with almost every other app, let users decide whether to grant access or not.
ea...@gmail.com
I understand that you do not give a damn about the needs of the users and to maintain some part of their interests they are going to leave without functional software that I use and that I paid for. The truth is I will do with you the same as I did with Microsoft, I changed it for Linux. Follow where you go and enjoy the results.
ms...@gmail.com
Why clipboard is not working for android 10!! 😔
re...@gmail.com
Still broken in Android 12.
he...@gmail.com
I use LineageOS which has Android 10 as a foundation and Clipstack has access to the clipboard. I guess LineageOS doesn't block access. So one solution is to use an alternative operating system(or at least LineageOS).
I also have my phone rooted. I don't know if that has anything to do with it.
I also have my phone rooted. I don't know if that has anything to do with it.
ba...@gmail.com
my...@gmail.com
Totally agree. Stop destroying the API.
[Deleted User] <[Deleted User]>
One more reason to stay on older android.
Android 9 - blocked recording
Android 10 - blocked clipboard
looks like AOSP with root will be on my device from now on ...
Android 9 - blocked recording
Android 10 - blocked clipboard
looks like AOSP with root will be on my device from now on ...
gm...@gmail.com
🛑 stop taking away the functionalities we are use too! You are creating a horrible experience and inconveniencing us! I relied on this function for the app smart Actions! Now you've destroyed a good app and imagine will negatively have affected that developers business. I will probably have to uninstall his app now. You ruined my experience and my view of Google Android is shifting. Thank you.
di...@gmail.com
Yes, Google Please allow this app to proceed as intended.
de...@gmail.com
This may look like a promotion but is intended as a help to those who are looking to gain this functionality back.
You can use XClipper -
It is a clipboard manager app with lots of features & works for Android 10+ devices that require no root or any kind of adb commands to enable clipboard monitoring again. It works by you to first enable an Accessibility service where it recognizes some touch events that might consider as a copy event & saves the required text data into the local database.
It also has a Windows companion app you can
Also, the app is open source and hosted on Github -
no...@gmail.com
I would like to complain about this change as well, I have used it since Android 4.2 in apps like Pleco or Pinyiner and it made a whole world of difference. Actually, that's why I bought a new Android tablet instead of iPad. And guess what - it stopped working in Android 10. It is a change that inflicts a hugeblow on functionality of these apps and it's impossible to check up a word in a floating notification quickly without it. Before I could just copy a word from PDF and immediately see the definition. What can I do now? No options for that. It's such a pity. Maybe I should've bought an iPad after all...
no...@gmail.com
The more I think about it the more stupid this idea is - the decision has just mae 3 of the apps I use daily practically USELESS. Is that the way the devs should care about customers' privacy - we'll just take that functionality so that you can't use your apps any longer because of privacy concerns. Because some people somewhere could use it to steal your text. Like - come on - I don't care! Let me use my apps! I am an adult person, let me know about the consequences and let me decide!
rb...@gmail.com
Comment has been deleted.
zu...@gmail.com
google stop over ruling people's wishes what to use what not other as android swalowed windows tere shal be some other software which will swallow that Android.
lu...@gmail.com
Any ETA on this?
cl...@gmail.com
Android is made for Google and their commercials partner! Security is a pretext I Will install an open source and free version of android!
ol...@reply.io
Let it back
av...@gmail.com
This app was so good and handy to use.
lu...@gmail.com
Meh!
tr...@gmail.com
What on earth is the point in having a clipboard if we can't paste anything from it except the last thing we copied? How stupid is that? Seriously, who was the bright spark who thought that removing access to the clipboard was a good idea? Then who was the even smarter person (this comment is dripping in an ocean of sarcasm) who approved the idea and made it part of your last OS update?
I can't use the clipboard now to create new contacts in my phone from data I've copied, such as, email address, first & last name, etc, simple stuff that use to work. I'd rather roll back my device's OS to the previous version than not have what should be simple access to my clipboard. What the Hell!
Fix it, PLEASE!
I can't use the clipboard now to create new contacts in my phone from data I've copied, such as, email address, first & last name, etc, simple stuff that use to work. I'd rather roll back my device's OS to the previous version than not have what should be simple access to my clipboard. What the Hell!
Fix it, PLEASE!
[Deleted User] <[Deleted User]>
I cannotive without a clipboard manager
ar...@gmail.com
Please, PLEASE do not remove the ability to use clipboard managers!!! Many users, including myself, rely daily on such apps! If this is a security measure, there MUST be a way to allow users to opt in/out of clipboard access on a per app basis. Please fix this!
pe...@gmail.com
By upgrading my device, I'm now forced to use a notes app just to keep the clips I used constantly... Why does something so simple have to be made so much more difficult. Please find a way to allow the users to continue to use the functionality of the clipboards that we've come to rely on.
wa...@gmail.com
I want and need a full-access clipboard manager on my phone. Google's perverse choice to negate access for such apps (I want to use Clip Stack, as I can on my Tracfone with an older version of Andtoif) is nonsense. Pleasr fix this foolish restriction immediately.
ri...@gmail.com
To everyone commenting, don't bother Google doesn't care what you want.
de...@gmail.com
Ffs this is a major feature that keeps me using my android instead of desktop, all day, for social media and work and email and and and.
I need my Clipstack app working again!
I need my Clipstack app working again!
ki...@gmail.com
This sucks
Clipboard managers area important !!
Clipboard managers area important !!
as...@gmail.com
There should be an permission like file access and so on to access clipboard so we can simply ask users to grant / deny according to their needs
mz...@gmail.com
You are significantly reducing usability of android devices. I am as programmer must hack your device or throw it away to the trash.
fa...@gmail.com
Is it a power for you to control app developers? Don't forget google is dealing with iOS. Please unlock it.
[Deleted User] <[Deleted User]>
Please unlock it, without it impossible to use favourite tasks!!!
sa...@gmail.com
I know it's not the same, but I found a 3rd party clipboard app on the Play store. It has a free and paid version: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=jp.snowlife01.android.clipboard_trial
Link says "trial" so I dunno if it'll stay free. And to use clipboard you have to drag down and click the persistent notification or click the floating dot that at 50% opacity level, which kinda defeats the purpose depending on how you look at it (imo I don't think so but everyone's different).
Link says "trial" so I dunno if it'll stay free. And to use clipboard you have to drag down and click the persistent notification or click the floating dot that at 50% opacity level, which kinda defeats the purpose depending on how you look at it (imo I don't think so but everyone's different).
ab...@gmail.com
Solve it Google
ja...@gmail.com
I just upgraded my phone, only to find out my clipboard app has been blocked for "security" reasons. I use my clipboard DAILY, and need one that will store multiple clips. This is a bad decision and clearly NOT user friendly. Please give us back OUR right to choose!
go...@gmail.com
I don't think if Google is even reviewing this issue tracker.
We paid hafthy amount to purchase high end Android device just to see that Android at it's own wish removes application permission without even informing or consulting their users.
It's really shameful on Google part.
I request Google to restore the clipboard app's background subc capabilities a soon as possible.
We paid hafthy amount to purchase high end Android device just to see that Android at it's own wish removes application permission without even informing or consulting their users.
It's really shameful on Google part.
I request Google to restore the clipboard app's background subc capabilities a soon as possible.
fr...@gmail.com
On the off chance anyone with any actual power to change reads this, we should be allowed to have clipboard history managers. I frequently copy several things and want the ability to go back and recopy certain things for ease of pasting. But apparently Google doesn't want us to have control over our own devices to even that extent? Please give us back that ability
hi...@gmail.com
I FOUND SOMETHING THAT LETS ME USE CUSTOM KEYBOARD WITH CLIPBOARD: Hey, so I'm new to my Galaxy S22 (on Android 12) so forgive me if this is already known but, just last night I found a stock working way to use the stock clipboard with 3rd party keyboards again! I dunno if this is the case with other phones or Android versions yet.
I added a video from last night and today of me testing it out, below and a third video on how to go to the settings to set it, but a trdl: On the sidebar on the S22, open it, then at the bottom click the gear button which opens up the sidebar settings, and from there you click "Clipboard". Then, if you're fine with seeing the clipboard thingie there, whenever you copy, cut or screeshot, the clipboard contents will be THERE ready for you to copy again if needed.
NOTE: In the first video I briefly speak and added English subs: I have a slight accent and speak more articulately in my other language so...
How to enable the clipboard sidebar on S22.mp4 -https://drive.google.com/file/d/1drb964j_oHyr7qNgNigBpZjujTA3ODY2/view?usp=sharing
Works with 3rd party keyboards 1.mp4 -https://drive.google.com/file/d/1e2F95VqFRcv-KBvQVQIdQClT_3b57Wzi/view?usp=sharing
Works with 3rd party keyboards 2.mp4 -https://drive.google.com/file/d/1dnTUjlMrTJP6GDCWCrlnh4infodQYGlK/view?usp=sharing
I added a video from last night and today of me testing it out, below and a third video on how to go to the settings to set it, but a trdl: On the sidebar on the S22, open it, then at the bottom click the gear button which opens up the sidebar settings, and from there you click "Clipboard". Then, if you're fine with seeing the clipboard thingie there, whenever you copy, cut or screeshot, the clipboard contents will be THERE ready for you to copy again if needed.
NOTE: In the first video I briefly speak and added English subs: I have a slight accent and speak more articulately in my other language so...
How to enable the clipboard sidebar on S22.mp4 -
Works with 3rd party keyboards 1.mp4 -
Works with 3rd party keyboards 2.mp4 -
ki...@gmail.com
Please restore the ability to use third-party clipboard managers.
af...@gmail.com
Why google do this stupid thing about clipboard is not working in background
sl...@gmail.com
First things first.
I wanna thank you Clipstack for bringing me right here where feedback is taken for granted.
Next i want to remind google people that we need a mobile version of the issue tracker. That'll speed up the process for free as far as i'm concerned.
Next is the fact we need to collect the same data google collect about us and have access to it and mess around with it because it is ours. This is gune cost some heavy duty nightwork. But we need that too
You see the thing is ... you people are not synchronized with the process tree for the AI to learn from and trust based on where it will land in the future 😉
Be Quick. Be Nice
Bbye
I wanna thank you Clipstack for bringing me right here where feedback is taken for granted.
Next i want to remind google people that we need a mobile version of the issue tracker. That'll speed up the process for free as far as i'm concerned.
Next is the fact we need to collect the same data google collect about us and have access to it and mess around with it because it is ours. This is gune cost some heavy duty nightwork. But we need that too
You see the thing is ... you people are not synchronized with the process tree for the AI to learn from and trust based on where it will land in the future 😉
Be Quick. Be Nice
Bbye
ma...@tobischaefer.com
please allow third-party clipboard manager apps to work again in android. i am positive google engineers can find a way to make this happen without compromising security or privacy of the device. all the best.
kr...@gmail.com
Not being able to use my Favorite Clipboard manager is annoying. Please give the USER the ability to control what apps can have background clipboard access. I want to use Clipper+ again.
99...@gmail.com
Seriously google? This has been an issue since android 10????? On 12 now and STILL no workarounds or options to allow specific apps to read the clipboard?
What a joke
What a joke
no...@gmail.com
And Google says it's "Intended behavior". No, we do not agree to that. It's why people go to Google instead of Apple - to have freedom to set their phones as they want to use it.
ph...@gmail.com
Why has clipstack not supported
[Deleted User] <[Deleted User]>
Every Android upgrade you break things. Rooting is now a necessity.
I can understand closing loopholes, but not giving *US* the choice on what to do with *OUR* devices is arrogant and offensive.
Android had a great development community because of it's openness. It's no coincidence the Unix hackers are giving up. "Send patches?" your chromeos team says... Why should we?
My CPU monitoring widget was really handy. You killed that (the required access to /proc could easily have been made into a permission). Now clipboard actions? Obviously your roadmap is to completely turn android into a dumb OS for dumb users, but you can do that without impeding things for those who want more than dumb.
What next? 'developers menu', adb? (of course adb has gotten more restrictive since the early days already)
I can understand closing loopholes, but not giving *US* the choice on what to do with *OUR* devices is arrogant and offensive.
Android had a great development community because of it's openness. It's no coincidence the Unix hackers are giving up. "Send patches?" your chromeos team says... Why should we?
My CPU monitoring widget was really handy. You killed that (the required access to /proc could easily have been made into a permission). Now clipboard actions? Obviously your roadmap is to completely turn android into a dumb OS for dumb users, but you can do that without impeding things for those who want more than dumb.
What next? 'developers menu', adb? (of course adb has gotten more restrictive since the early days already)
pa...@btinternet.com
I've just updated my phone to a Samsung 10 and proudly placed clipboard - one of my most useful apps - on a prominent place on my homescreen. Only to find when - as often - I needed to use it to copy and paste preprepared and stored text, that Google no longer allowed it to be used for some reason. Please look into this. I use it a lot.
wo...@gmail.com
This issue has been lasting for far too long!
Google doesn't give a damn!
Google has become nothing, but a fascist controller and supporter for
fascist dictatorial regimes.
This is exactly how corporations work on the orders of the state
governments aiming to enslave their nations.
I stopped using Google services as much as I could, and I've been learning
how to degoogle any possible devices that still are using these despicable
Google services.
They're also other mobile OSs!
They're getting more and more popular.
Death to tyranny!
We're still fee people!
On Sun, Sep 4, 2022, 19:39 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
Google doesn't give a damn!
Google has become nothing, but a fascist controller and supporter for
fascist dictatorial regimes.
This is exactly how corporations work on the orders of the state
governments aiming to enslave their nations.
I stopped using Google services as much as I could, and I've been learning
how to degoogle any possible devices that still are using these despicable
Google services.
They're also other mobile OSs!
They're getting more and more popular.
Death to tyranny!
We're still fee people!
On Sun, Sep 4, 2022, 19:39 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
wo...@gmail.com
This needs to change NOW.
Like yesterday, actually.
Everybody can see why the G would've done this, it's so transparent to most.
Like yesterday, actually.
Everybody can see why the G would've done this, it's so transparent to most.
al...@gmail.com
Please google, just give users the choice. removing this will limit the customisability and easiness to use Android, do not remove this feature
ra...@gmail.com
Comment has been deleted.
ra...@gmail.com
There was a really helpful app for non-native English speakers like us. Where I could copy a word when reading a pdf book and it showed the meaning of that word in Bengali. But because of this restriction, the app doesn't work anymore. It is really affecting my reading and learning process. Because I can't see the word meaning directly. Please give an alternative way to get the permission
mr...@gmail.com
Refix this issue..allow aftermarket clipboards.we dont want system clipboard its boring
jb...@gmail.com
This is so frustrating and pointless. I have just upgraded my phone and discovered this. I can't use a clipboard manager. As many developers have pointed out over the last few years,the security problems did not need to have this functionality completely removed. Others have pointed out it makes android less useful and eventually less secure.
mn...@gmail.com
Please allow third-party clipboard manager apps to work again in android. I just upgraded my phone and use a clipboard manager frequently and now am unable to use it.
pi...@gmail.com
I wanted to have a shared clipboard for my devices so that I can copy paste from one device to the other. I think apple is the way for me now.
n3...@gmail.com
Comment has been deleted.
st...@gmail.com
Many of us have been begging Google to fix this issue of their own making.
They have ignored the users for years. They have no intention of doing
right by us.
On Mon, Oct 31, 2022, 7:23 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
They have ignored the users for years. They have no intention of doing
right by us.
On Mon, Oct 31, 2022, 7:23 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
no...@gmail.com
da...@gmail.com
The whole reason i choose Android over Apple is because, until now, it has been compatible with other apps. Restricting this access has ruined my access to some of my most used functions on my phone. I no longer feel safe and functional with google and will be looking into other options for my next phone.
st...@gmail.com
Google software design doesn't give a crap about the end user.
On Fri, Dec 16, 2022, 7:19 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
On Fri, Dec 16, 2022, 7:19 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
de...@gmail.com
Please, give us permissions for clipboard managers or give is an android clipboard manager!
My phone is my most important business tool, and this is app (tiny clipboard) is a critical part of my workflow :-(
My phone is my most important business tool, and this is app (tiny clipboard) is a critical part of my workflow :-(
iv...@gmail.com
This really is disastrous; after such a long time still no solution.
It would be so easy and clean to let the user decide if an app may access the clipboard or not.
Google, please just solve it. Most certainly it would be regarded as a strength of yours to admit the mistake and just fix it.
It would be so easy and clean to let the user decide if an app may access the clipboard or not.
Google, please just solve it. Most certainly it would be regarded as a strength of yours to admit the mistake and just fix it.
th...@stellantis.com
Agree. This update is one of the most frustrating changes that was allowed. What a pain and there is no workaround that I can see. I have to email my self and copy and paste on my Windows PC then send it back sometimes to my phone, making simple tasks infuriating and time consuming. You are wasting.. So stupid. It is such a waste of time when you have to use your phone for work and personal use, making it very difficult to email business partners and do my job as well as just using my phone for personal use. . What a waste and it provide no security or warm and fuzzy for work applications. So stupid, why would you block anyone from copying and pasting from work related apps.
na...@gmail.com
I had an old outdated phone that had a clipboard that actually functioned, worked. now since buying a new phone and working with Android 11 supposedly new and better I have this ridiculously terrible gboard keyboard that does not work at all or tries to work so well that you can't even do your own work I eat try to predict what you'll type, Google wants access to all of your information but won't let other apps have it and can't figure out how to allow it to be private it's actually ours but my old phone worked in such a way that now I understand I can't use this one it's going to be basically dysfunctional and I'm going to go back to writing with a pen and paper or pencil and paper and unless I can get one of the independent non-google apps to work I just don't understand why I can't use my clipboard the way I used it for years and without it I find spending time on my phone completely useless-- because any meaningful thing that I write as a writer disappears --and I can't get it to save anywhere because it disappears without my permission, just automatically! ...it's like you're stealing my creative, work my intellectual property. please allow app developers to continue to let us decide what happens with our clipboard content and how to save it and when and under what circumstances! YOU, you, Google just figure out how to protect that content by not allowing other apps access to it that don't deserve access to our information --you created the system like a sieve to support advertisers and corporations mining information for making money-- this is your fault not independent app developers who are actually trying to create real tools that actually work for people! ...you fix the big system not by being in control of our intellectual property, but by protecting our intellectual property by allowing us to choose which apps to use that are safe and designating them as safe-- don't let other apps that have nothing to do with my clipboard see my clipboard-- just the ones I choose--if we can designate who can have the information on our clipboard and we have a honest developer that's making a good clipboard / copy pasta save app then we can use that one. You know it's not just the Bad actors trying to create apps that are collecting information to scam-- it's the big system itself you've got to fix that because it was designed, not for us --but for you and getting information so that you can make money-- that's the problem it's so prevalent that it is the only thing that actually is going on now all the big platform apps like Facebook--are basically entirely dysfunctional at this point, because they don't actually do anything other than try to sell people things and minimize actual human function-- it's disgusting you're partly responsible if not largely very much so responsible.
si...@gmail.com
Dear Google,
Let people choose. Secondly, if you want to block a thing, better provide a free better alternative and prove its better and then let people choose
Let people choose. Secondly, if you want to block a thing, better provide a free better alternative and prove its better and then let people choose
zi...@gmail.com
A clipboard manager has been an essential part of my workflow. I read stuff, copy what is interesting, and then join the snippets into Simplenote. The adb solution for clipstack works on Android 10, 11 and 12.
On 11, the version 1.8.1 or earlier, using accessibility settings, do not work reliably, contrary to what someone here reported. Same for Xclipper. On Android 13 people say adb will be needed after every reboot. Sad.
I could use an app where selected text would be **silently** shared to a list, like it goes to Xclipper. But XClipper should add an option to define separators when merging clips.
Anyway, shame on Google to remove this feature.
On 11, the version 1.8.1 or earlier, using accessibility settings, do not work reliably, contrary to what someone here reported. Same for Xclipper. On Android 13 people say adb will be needed after every reboot. Sad.
I could use an app where selected text would be **silently** shared to a list, like it goes to Xclipper. But XClipper should add an option to define separators when merging clips.
Anyway, shame on Google to remove this feature.
ju...@gmail.com
Please unblock apps such as this. We want them and why you blocked them does not matter, as we want to use the apps at our own risk
st...@gmail.com
Been waiting around for years with not one action taken to remedy the
situation by the intrepid engineers on the team. It's almost as if the
corporation doesn't care about the customer. Yeah that's a lot of sarcasm.
On Mon, Jul 10, 2023, 1:32 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
situation by the intrepid engineers on the team. It's almost as if the
corporation doesn't care about the customer. Yeah that's a lot of sarcasm.
On Mon, Jul 10, 2023, 1:32 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
bo...@gmail.com
Please give us this feature back. This is very essential for us.
mp...@gmail.com
The ability to have a secure platform is a necessity; however, how one goes about it is the difference in usability, and practibillity, and workabillity.
Blocking apps from using establish pathways and methods, is not a good approach; rather there could be a much better and secure way. (Frankly, I have never understood why it was not done from the very beginning).
From the start to gain usefull access to one's device, one had to root one's device, which is stupid. (This also shows a lack of foresight on the part of the Android developers)
Rather than running and unsecured and vunerable Rooted device, the use and adoption of the Secured Linux command and technique of the use of su do and sudo (it should have been implemented, from the beginging).
Breaking someone else products and efforts, to secure Android is scurrilous. Rather by the implementation of the linux sudo or su do commands (as a standard practice and procedure) and the use of a app like Remote ADB Shell (no addional computer required) it would allow such (beloved and usefull) apps to still be used with little effort on the parts of the user and app creator.
Another, thing to consider is the marketing opportunities that would be openend to Alphabet.
Right now, users (with out rooting) can only backup thier apps (not apps data) and some of their library content, and when they are forced to do a factory reset, they lose mostly everything. (Which actually means in reality, the device is very insecured).
I imagine that the inabillity to do a true backup and recovery, (considering all the grief and cost, that this results in), could become the bases of a class action.
But, hey what do I know.
Thanks.
2023/08/21 12:21 Hrs EDT
Blocking apps from using establish pathways and methods, is not a good approach; rather there could be a much better and secure way. (Frankly, I have never understood why it was not done from the very beginning).
From the start to gain usefull access to one's device, one had to root one's device, which is stupid. (This also shows a lack of foresight on the part of the Android developers)
Rather than running and unsecured and vunerable Rooted device, the use and adoption of the Secured Linux command and technique of the use of su do and sudo (it should have been implemented, from the beginging).
Breaking someone else products and efforts, to secure Android is scurrilous. Rather by the implementation of the linux sudo or su do commands (as a standard practice and procedure) and the use of a app like Remote ADB Shell (no addional computer required) it would allow such (beloved and usefull) apps to still be used with little effort on the parts of the user and app creator.
Another, thing to consider is the marketing opportunities that would be openend to Alphabet.
Right now, users (with out rooting) can only backup thier apps (not apps data) and some of their library content, and when they are forced to do a factory reset, they lose mostly everything. (Which actually means in reality, the device is very insecured).
I imagine that the inabillity to do a true backup and recovery, (considering all the grief and cost, that this results in), could become the bases of a class action.
But, hey what do I know.
Thanks.
2023/08/21 12:21 Hrs EDT
28...@gmail.com
Please allow third party apps to monitor clipboard content, it's extremely important. With all work arounds it's still not like it was before Android 10!
ss...@gmail.com
Being a user of this product and the apps that enhance it bye. My bias is
towards the developer on this issue. That said, I'd like to understand the.
Reasoning for a blanket restriction as opposed to the restriction Or ban.
for developers Who abuse it. Understanding the security risks. I would have
to know the numbers on the breaches Do to this.
Vulnerability. Thanks for any light. You can shed on this Issue.
On Wed, Feb 28, 2024, 1:02 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
towards the developer on this issue. That said, I'd like to understand the.
Reasoning for a blanket restriction as opposed to the restriction Or ban.
for developers Who abuse it. Understanding the security risks. I would have
to know the numbers on the breaches Do to this.
Vulnerability. Thanks for any light. You can shed on this Issue.
On Wed, Feb 28, 2024, 1:02 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
el...@gmail.com
Google is very annoying as always
el...@gmail.com
This is the reason why Google must become biggest looser in AI race. In case if Apple can give some flexibility with this usability function, I would be glad to use Android less, just because of this issue
rh...@gmail.com
Just another reason why I really truly hate Google and how it's monopolizing the android world. To restrict or deny a simple usage on an android device (phone, tablet, computer) is worse than the control of the government on the the rights of the people of the United States their constitutional rights. I can't copy my password from one app to another I can't copy a text or an email to a loved one even in an emergency situation. How dare you take away something that is just a simple time saving action available for people to use or not use. Restricting it to just system apps doesn't do a damn thing for anyone it's completely useless especially when Google can't even seem to autofill a code even though it turned on let alone save anything to the clipboard Google provides usage of its horrible programming in its finest
wo...@gmail.com
Total waste of time talking to this corrupt Google scam. It doesn't give a
shit about anybody's rights or thoughts.
I'm happy to see that corporate scumbag in the courts on the way of
dismantling it eventually.
Millions of people look to other opinions like total de- Google of their
phones, so do I.
I'm sick and tired of that communist Google tracking and spying on me for
years now.
On Mon, Jul 10, 2023, 16:32 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
shit about anybody's rights or thoughts.
I'm happy to see that corporate scumbag in the courts on the way of
dismantling it eventually.
Millions of people look to other opinions like total de- Google of their
phones, so do I.
I'm sick and tired of that communist Google tracking and spying on me for
years now.
On Mon, Jul 10, 2023, 16:32 <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
ma...@gmail.com
Ok
ni...@gmail.com
FUCK YOU GOOGLE
ni...@gmail.com
Like seriously, I wish the CEO or whoever makes these anti-consumer monopolistic decisions falls 30 feet onto a sharp pole that goes right up his/her ass.
ns...@gmail.com
I miss Clipstack and similar apps as much as the rest of you, but the good news is many keyboard apps these days include clipboard managing features. My favorite is FUTO keyboard
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.futo.inputmethod.latin.playstore
ni...@gmail.com
I'm just concerned with syncing with KDE Connect (to Windows (nope, refuse
to use Microsoft extra spyware Phone Link which is granted this permission
by Samsung as a preinstalled app), haven't switched to Linux yet). I
already have clipboard history. On the keyboard I'm typing this on. Futo
Keyboard. Yep, it's great. And I update all my apps using Obtainium so it
can even update stuff with just apks in GitHub releases without needing an
F-Droid repo (through it can also act as an F-Droid client).
On Thu, Oct 3, 2024, 8:08 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
to use Microsoft extra spyware Phone Link which is granted this permission
by Samsung as a preinstalled app), haven't switched to Linux yet). I
already have clipboard history. On the keyboard I'm typing this on. Futo
Keyboard. Yep, it's great. And I update all my apps using Obtainium so it
can even update stuff with just apks in GitHub releases without needing an
F-Droid repo (through it can also act as an F-Droid client).
On Thu, Oct 3, 2024, 8:08 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:
Description
Such a thing will break a lot of apps that rely on this permission, including apps that their whole purpose is to manage copied clipboard content and present us a nicer UI to choose from recent clipboard items, such as this app:
Please do not remove this, and do not grant this ability only to system apps.
It's not just damaging developers. It's damaging users, who will now have much less choice of what to use.