Iguana Canary 2: Embedded Layout inspector spams logcat with `Invalid resource ID` errors [299309384]

Fixed

Bug

Status Update

No update yet.

Description

yo...@gmail.com

created issue #1

Sep 6, 2023 06:12PM

Embedded Layout inspector spams logcat with Invalid resource ID errors:

Looks like there is something on a half second loop printing these 5 lines over and over and over:

11:00:59.057  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
11:00:59.057  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
11:00:59.057  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
11:00:59.057  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
11:00:59.058  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
11:00:59.080  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
11:00:59.080  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
11:00:59.080  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
11:00:59.080  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
11:00:59.080  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
11:00:59.580  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
11:00:59.580  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
11:00:59.580  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
11:00:59.580  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
11:00:59.580  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.

Is layout inspector injecting code into my app process?

Build: AI-232.9559.62.2321.10749089, 202308312303

AI-232.9559.62.2321.10749089, JRE 17.0.8+0-17.0.8b1000.8-10699129x64 JetBrains s.r.o., OS Mac OS X(aarch64) v13.4, screens 2880.0x5120.0, 5120.0x2880.0; Retina

AS: Iguana | 2023.2.1 Canary 2
Kotlin plugin: 232-1.9.0-release-358-AS9559.62.2321.10749089
Android Gradle Plugin: 8.1.1
Gradle: 8.3
Gradle JDK: JetBrains Runtime version 17.0.8

Comments

yo...@gmail.com <yo...@gmail.com> #2Sep 6, 2023 10:31PM

Speeds up sometimes (see the timestamps):

5:29:15.858  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:15.859  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:15.859  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:15.859  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:15.859  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:15.903  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:15.903  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:15.903  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:15.903  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:15.903  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:15.926  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:15.926  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:15.926  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:15.926  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:15.926  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:15.960  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:15.960  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:15.960  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:15.960  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:15.960  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:15.994  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:15.994  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:15.994  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:15.994  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:15.994  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.025  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.025  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.025  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.025  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.025  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.059  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.059  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.060  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.060  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.060  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.093  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.093  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.093  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.093  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.093  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.137  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.137  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.137  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.137  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.139  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.159  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.159  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.159  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.159  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.159  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.192  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.192  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.192  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.192  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.192  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.225  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.225  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.225  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.225  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.225  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.258  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.258  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.258  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.258  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.258  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.293  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.293  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.293  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.293  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.293  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.325  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.325  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.326  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.326  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.326  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.366  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.366  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.367  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.367  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.367  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.375  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.375  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.375  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.375  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.375  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.409  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.409  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.409  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.410  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.410  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.442  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.442  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.442  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.442  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.443  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.480  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.480  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.480  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.481  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.481  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.492  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.493  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.493  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.493  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.493  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.526  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.526  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.526  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.526  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.526  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.559  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.559  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.559  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.559  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.559  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.593  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.593  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.593  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.593  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.594  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.608  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.608  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.609  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.609  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.
15:29:16.609  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000005.
15:29:16.642  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000002.
15:29:16.642  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000003.
15:29:16.642  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000001.
15:29:16.642  E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000004.

al...@google.com <al...@google.com> Sep 7, 2023 03:47PM

Assigned to an...@google.com.

gm...@google.com <gm...@google.com> Sep 11, 2023 02:57PM

Reassigned to ps...@google.com.

ps...@google.com <ps...@google.com> #3Sep 13, 2023 11:53AM

Hi, it would be helpful it you could provide more information.

When does this happen?
How can we replicate it?
Can you attach logs (idea.log and logcat)
Is this a compose project?

As for your question: yes, Layout Inspector works by injecting code into the app being inspected.

yo...@gmail.com <yo...@gmail.com> #4Sep 13, 2023 12:13PM

Yes, the app uses Compose.

This seems to happen when I run the app and then open the embedded layout inspector.

The logcat is just full of the logs seen above repeated over and over.

ps...@google.com <ps...@google.com> #5Sep 13, 2023 12:19PM

Could you provide idea.log when the issue happens?

Would it be possible to share the project you're working on? If not, could you attach a video so we can see exactly what's going on?

jl...@google.com <jl...@google.com> #6Sep 13, 2023 03:53PM

Reassigned to jl...@google.com.

It looks like the logging comes from the framework: https://android.googlesource.com/platform/frameworks/base/+/master/libs/androidfw/AssetManager2.cpp#590

The device must be using API 34 ?

I tried to add a few string resources to a small compose demo app. I got one message like this without opening the Layout Inspector:

E  Invalid resource ID 0x00000000.

And when I opened the Layout Inspector I got 4 more output lines and then it stopped - even when interacting with the app and the Layout Inspector.
To me that is acceptable.

If you are unable to share your app: can you think of what kind of resources the app is using ?

yo...@gmail.com <yo...@gmail.com> #7Sep 19, 2023 05:58PM

I can't share the whole app code, but I could probably do a screen share session if you want (you can email me).

There are lots of resources in the app, like any non-trivial app.

This happens when I am interactively using the Layout Inspector.

jl...@google.com <jl...@google.com> #8Sep 20, 2023 03:54PM

Is your app a mixture of views and compose or a 100% compose app ?

If it is a mixture: are the messages more frequent when clicking on compose nodes or views in the component tree.

Message last modified on Sep 20, 2023 04:49PM

jl...@google.com <jl...@google.com> #9Sep 20, 2023 07:58PM

Looking at the code:

The compose inspector does not deal with resource ids (directly) but the view inspector does.
So I think the messages are from getting attributes of views.
In that case: we should be able avoid the logcat entries.

It is also possible that some of the resource ids indeed are invalid in your app.
I believe you can see that by inspecting the generated R file.
There should be indicators if the an id is invalid.

jl...@google.com <jl...@google.com> Sep 21, 2023 06:22PM

Accepted by jl...@google.com.

jl...@google.com <jl...@google.com> #10Oct 19, 2023 03:25PM

Marked as fixed.

The fix is expected to be included with Android Studio Iguana canary 9.

an...@google.com <an...@google.com> #11Oct 26, 2023 09:01PM

Thank you for your patience while our engineering team worked to resolve this issue. A fix for this issue is now available in:

Android Studio Iguana | 2023.2.1 Canary 11
Android Gradle Plugin 8.3.0-alpha11

We encourage you to try the latest update.

If you notice further issues or have questions, please file a new bug report.

Thank you for taking the time to submit feedback — we really appreciate it!