IssueTracker

Thank you for reporting this issue. We’ve shared this with our product and engineering teams and will continue to provide updates as more information becomes available.

Our development team has been adding call recording APIs on their road map.  Its something that we would like to address in a future version of Android.  However due to the security and privacy implications of such APIs it is not something we can deliver for the Q release.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B9lYNNo0KifZc3RhcnRlcl9maWxl/view?usp=drive_web (Getting started)

For me Call recording was the main feature of android resonating with flexibility and even freedom. It kept me from switching to iphone.

Idem:   For me Call recording was the main feature of android resonating with flexibility and even freedom. It kept me from switching to iphone.

I require call recording for my business efficiency.
It is legal in my jurisdiction.
Please advise when available again.  I am hamstrung without it.

It sounds to me this more of a Google control issue than a security or privacy issue. If Google were concerned about our privacy and security the tracking features would't be so prevalent on the phone. Lame excuse.

why call recording is blocked, a feature that I have much appreciated on android ☹️☹️

The status is marked as fixed without the issue being fixed. This issue should be reopened.

Please put back call recording. It's a "live saver" feature that now its gone! Thank you NOT Google. You should pay me back the money I gave for the "pro" version of the call recording app! And I think if all will request back the money, not from the app producer because Google is to blame for the problem, I think Google will revise this more quickly.

I'm currently stuck on Oreo because if I upgrade my S8 to Pie I lose call recording which is frustrating as I use it extensively for work. I'm in the UK and in most EU countries it is entirely legal to record calls. Please can you release a patch or ask manufacturers to enable it in their ROM's built in dallier in all legal jurisdictions as at the moment in some places it's enabled and others it's not even when legal. Thank you.

Call recording required for Pie. Put it back please. We all need it!

It sounds so stereotypical, but I have to say it: Call recording is what kept me on the Android platform.
Breaking this feature is not well taken.

Please as long as an API is not available, let all apps have call recording functionality as before, using the normal API for recording.
Currently there is not even one app that I've found that can record calls on Android Q beta 3, even though it worked fine on previous beta versions:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/bpc7ka/
People really want it back...

Agreed this is very disappointing regression

I am a journalist in Canada. My colleagues and I feel forced to leave Android behind if this isn't fixed fast.

Call recording is *not* in fact illegal in Canada and is a key function of journalists' work. 

Can you kindly let me know when we can expect a fix on this? It's crucial for our work and a very big roadblock.

At least you guys at the Android team should have not blocked the ability to record calls entirely in Android 9 Pie. We use this feature with our own responsibility and it's not something that Google should interfere.

In Canada single party consent (call recording) is legal. I think it is legal in all but 8 US states as well, and is such a valuable business asset we have considered moving to iPhone because it is no longer available on Android. We record calls to ensure security for both our clients and brokers. This directly affects the quality of service we can offer clients. We can provide clients with measured statistics defending the use of call recording applications. If this is a business decision, it is questionable, if it is political, hello Apple.

Samsung apparently has a call recorder built into their dialer app which is enabled/disabled by stitches in the CSC file. This is however controlled by the carrier.
A user can change the switch with root access, but that introduces a bunch of new problems there.

Requiring for us to void our warranty is not acceptable. This type of functionality is a feature that many use as part of their jobs. Disabling it without any communication and refusing to enable it without reasoning affects our ability to continue to purchase these devices.

Please create a fix.

Kindly add the CALL RECORDING option in android by new Update... ASAP......it's very very important.

Google, this is a heavy-handed, unnecessary measure that puts unsuspecting customers in the position of losing a vital function, especially for those of us who rely on recording for work. You are aware that in Canada, recording calls only requires single party consent. Why then snatch a key feature from phones we've already paid for? Will you pay the device's we have to purchase to get around this ill-informed move? How many customers are you willing to lose over this? Fix this, fast. Or we'll all have no choice but to move on from Android.

One of the most important functionality that let me keep using android phone, is this function of call recording, due of my work it helped me a lot... when driving i don't have to stop the car and take a book to write the commands, all what i have to do is ask questions to the client about commands, and when getting at work, listening to the customers demands...

android must restore this functionality, or for sur, they will lose a lot of customers.

I need this for my safety so medical problems that occur during phone calls can be reported to my doctors. I also need it to take notes of information that people convey to me because my handwriting is illegible due to neuromotor problems. Please restore this ASAP.

What are Android dev teams formal "privacy & security" concerns?

The privacy and security concerns were about third party apps being able to access call audio in the background. While many users have specifically wanted an app to do that, other apps could do that without the user's knowledge, intent or consent. The way it was working was a workaround which could be used as an exploit by malicious developers. Many phones have the capability to record calls, but it is restricted by the carriers.

What is wrong with you about call recording?
"Privacy & security concerns" from mouth of Alphabet is bad joke.
You have technical skills to harden this feature.
You can block this feature per country or just consent of user (for example in Poland it is perfectly legal to record OWN calls, you are responsible for privacy of this recording).

Call recording was one most useful functions in RIP Android.

From my point of view Google says: becasuse we concern for your privacy, stop using non-rooted kosher OS and go buy chinese half baked phone with this function available. Thanks! :(

Call recording is very important  in my business. I would appreciate if it would be brought  back. Call recording is not illegal in Canada.

I've certainly not read all or even many of these comments, but I think I have a take on it I've not seen in those I've read.  I had my phone record ALL my calls...both incoming & out.  With the option of keeping a call record or deleting it after the call. If it was business I conducted (personal or not) & promises were made or dates & times set, I might opt to keep those.  In one case it was a company (a public utility) that announced (before someone live got on) that they MIGHT "for training purposes" be recording the conversation.  When the live person got on I mentioned it was no "might" to it; it was definite & I was recording it.  She told me in that case she had to hang up.  I asked before we disconnected, if they were afraid she might promise something that they'd rather not deliver on?  I got no answer.  I waited 10-15 minutes & called back & kept my big mouth shut.  I'm almost 70 & read about all the scams run on the elderly, mostly via phone.  Granted many if not most are from outside the country, BUT NOT ALL!  Those also are good to have on record, even if only to use as examples for other people's education on dangers that are out there.  In addition I have MS & certain cognitive disabilities, most notably (besides my "aging brain") my short-term memory left me LONG-TERM AGO.  I know the usual baloney... take notes, etc, ..yadda yadda bing bang.  But what if you forget to read the notes or even that you wrote anything.  [When you're downstairs & realize you've forgotten something you'll need; run upstairs & only seconds later, come to realize you've forgotten what you forgot.  To quote from Married with Children, "Welcome to MY world!"  There are a number of other reasons I have & had for call recordingn but it's late & my memory....well....you know.  I'll leave it at this.  I did & will do it as possible BECAUSE I "WANT TO".  If it's against the law, I'M the one recording it...NOT Google, not Android, not a judge or jury.  If it's a criminal court case I'm involved in, (real unlikely), I guess the criminal who's rights were disregarded will walk away free.  If it's civil, it's possible they too will get off, but "possibly" someone up the feed chain will prefer that others don't here it.. & I've found there are MANY such cases.  When dealing with businesses, especially big corp'ns, after you've gone through the layers of the helpless, there's the ones who MADE THE RULE the lower minions had to follow, & just sometimes he/she might understand your plight...or use that as an excuse to get rid of you quickly rather than wasting  more of "his valuable time."  Well...that'll complete today's novel.

Call Recording is an essential future for everyone who lives where it's allowed because this is extremely convenient for life!

This is affecting EVERY app and the instructions from makers of apps has been to root the phone to avoid this issue.  Which would void my warranty, which I will not do.

My state and Federal law allows single-party recording of phone calls without beeps or notifications required, so I am not violating the law to record incoming phone calls.  I am constantly harassed by debt collectors for junk debts from over a decade ago, and THEY routinely break the law by threatening to sue me on time-barred debt.  I NEED these recordings as evidence in court to show exactly how abusive these companies are.  Two calls today were clear violations of the FDCPA and if the call recording app had recorded both sides of the conversation, I could actually protect my legal rights.

There are other people that have legal or medical reasons calls should be recorded.  People with stalkers, people who have memory issues and use the recordings to refresh their memory after dealing with business over the phone,

Require app developers to have a pop-up stating the call is being recorded, as all reputable call recorder apps do, and remove this inane restriction, if you are concerned about privacy.

But fix this flaw in the operating system of all Android phones using 9 or higher, because your policy literally cost me $1000 today.

I would truly appreciate if you would fix "Call Recording" application to work as before so we can use this great feature

How is this issue listed as "fixed"?  The call recording function still
does not work.

On Sun, Jun 30, 2019 at 7:54 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:

It is perfectly legal where I live and is extremely important to me and my work. Please bring back!

Why take it away!? Possessing a call recorder is not illegal and doesnt require a licence where i live. Otherwise owning a doctor would fall under the same rules. I got Android phone because it's system doesn't have the same f...d up restrictive design as Apple, and what do you know: couple months after update some dumb...s at google decides that he knows better and removes the API which was of paramount importance for me for record keeping on the go. I DON'T NEED YOU TO BABYSIT ME, WHAT I NEED IS FOR YOU TO DO YOUR JOB AND PROVIDE THE API FOR CALL RECORDING. You didn't solve any issue by removing it, you just created a problem. Please tell, why!? And if no particular reason of value, then please fix it.

Please add this functionally back

Still waiting for this 'feature' before upgrading my phone as I still have it on my current Marshmallow device.

Call recording options are very important for me. It needs to be started again.

Call recording is a must for those of us driving or are busy and need to recall details from calls received, or call centres interactions etc. One recording enabled me to cancel a cellphone upgrade which was sold to me under false pretences. Users should have the option to enable it otherwise Android becomes like iOS.

Why this have fixed status?

I am using OnePlus 3, OxygenOS 9.0.3 and Android 9 kernel version 3.18.120-perf+ #1 from Sat May 25 2019, the issue is still there I need call recording simply because it is convenient! Voiding my warranty & wiping all the data on my phone is totally not an option. Get your shit together, google.

I agree instructing users to void their own device warranties is a legal no-go. This is my progress with a Google lawyer about this, because it's an ADA violation. Call Recorder apps are assistive technology.

I emailed Google law department back on 4/4/19, explaining why them removing the call recorder function is a violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act.  They emailed back two weeks later clarifying the specific call recorder app I was using, then nothing. I sent reminder emails every few weeks. A few weeks ago the lawyer finally replied "I apologize, but I do not have an update for you right now." Which really means nothing has been done. She hasn't replied to my two emails since asking what action has been taken, who has the ball right now?

Why ADA violation? Not all disabilities are physical. Those with Traumatic Brain injury can cause mental cognitive declines including severe memory loss. Call Recorder apps are fantastic for us TBI-ers, because we forget what people said, what I was supposed to do or follow up, appointment dates and times, and in a dispute with a Bank of America when they wouldn't believe what another employee had promised and wouldn't honor it until they heard my recording. It's saved me time, money, sanity, and personal self-worth (knowing I've done something to help my memory without relying on asking other people for reminders).

If you or someone you know are in this same situation, jump on it quickly. I'm no lawyer. However, I think ADA violations are going to have the most leverage in fixing it.

Contact me for the email of the lawyer I've been talking with.

Contact you how?

I have a little boy with complex health problems, we live in the UK, the discussions with my sons plethora of specialist consultants are permitted to be recorded, covertly or overtly, as they are exempt from UK law under 'domestic purposes', they do not fall under the Data protection act or GDPR. The NHS information governance allows consultations and conversations to be recorded with my sons health care providers as it is no different to old fashioned writing minutes of what is discussed, those recordings form part of my sons medical records, it is only his data that is protected and as his sole guardian I can wave his rights under the data protection act.

Google in infringing on my rights as my sons sole carer to have a conclusive and factual record of his health and social care. Those subsequent call recordings could hold proof of an unlawful, or criminal, which exempts them from any form of data protection, act if my son is harmed or killed at the hands of his health care professionals actions.

I would suggest removing the blanket approach to call recordings, stop being lazy, and adjust to each Country or regions regulations or laws regarding call recording. Just because Germany has more stringent laws does not mean I have to be forced to comply with those laws when I factually do not live in that Country.

I have already contacted Google and raised this dispute some time ago, Google is not the body to Police this matter, subsequent governmental bodies, the ICO, and the civil, or criminal, Courts would deal with any subsequent unlawful or criminal act regarding the use of call recordings.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4093108/illegal-record-conversation-film-someone/

Is it illegal to record a conversation in the UK?
The rules vary between businesses and individuals, but in general it's not a crime to record a conversation without telling someone.

If you record someone's conversation in secret, it could potentially be considered a breach of their privacy.

But even so, it's not a criminal offence to secretly record calls for your own use - it's more of a potential civil wrong which can be redressed with a claim for damages.

The legal aspect comes in to the equation if someone shares the recording without the consent of the people in the call.

If you sell a recording to a third party or release it to the public without consent from the other person, this enters murky legal waters and could be a criminal offence.

However, journalists can publish secret recordings without a legal backlash, provided they can prove the released recording is in the public interest.

https://www.google.com/search?q=nhs+recording+health+care+professionals&rlz=1C1CHBD_en-GBGB748GB749&oq=nhs+recording+health+care+professionals+&aqs=chrome..69i57j33l2.22103j0j8&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8

Recording NHS staff in health and social care settings - Mid Essex ...
www.meht.nhs.uk/EasysiteWeb/getresource.axd?AssetID=23609...servicetype...
28 Aug 2018 - relation to patients who wish to record their medical consultations or ... the NHS professional's permission to record a medical consultation or ...

5.0 The Law
5.1 Overview • There are no specific legal requirements that govern an individual making a personal recording of their medical consultation or treatment, either overtly or covertly, for their private use. Recordings made to keep a personal record of what the NHS professional said are deemed to constitute ‘note taking’ and are therefore permitted when undertaken for this purpose. While a patient does not require permission to record their consultation, common courtesy would suggest that permission should be sought by the patient in most cases.
5 • The content of the recording is confidential to the patient, not the doctor or healthcare staff. The patient can waive their own confidentiality as they wish; this could include disclosing the details of their consultation with third parties or even posting and/or sharing the recording in unadulterated form on the internet through social media sites.
 
• The position may, however, change once a recording is no longer used as a record of the consultation, for example where the recording is disclosed or publicised in a modified way which is not connected to the consultation. This could include an instance where it is designed to cause detriment to or harass another individual captured in the recording. Any such disclosure or publication, depending on the nature and context, may attract a civil action for damages and may also be a criminal offence.
General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR) The recording of a consultation is likely to constitute processing of personal data under the DPA and as such it has to comply with the provisions of the GDPR. There is an exemption in the DPA where personal data is processed by an individual for their own personal purposes. In such cases, the ‘processing’ does not engage the data protection principles of the act (the ‘domestic purposes’ exemption). However, further processing of the data would have to comply with the DPA.
Potential legal action If any part of a covert or overt recording of the patient’s consultation or members of the public, visitor and relatives, is disclosed to a third party without the prior consent of the other recorded parties, then depending on the nature and the context of such disclosure, a criminal offence may be committed, civil legal action may be taken, or a breach of the GDPR may occur.
 
 

Sadly it seems Google will make the permission to record from calls only via system apps.
They added a permission "CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT" that can only be granted to system apps.
It can't be granted even via adb or rooted device. You have to somehow install your app as a system app.

https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/132754768
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/137210607

Please fix this,  it's really important for me

Please give us the ability to record our calls again... It was a main back in the day and the lack of a call recorder is becoming more and more of a hindrance.

Our Company takes complex technical calls from customers in the field which need to be stored and transcribed later for quoting and servicing.  Call recording is both LEGAL and ESSENTIAL to us.

We will not upgrade our aging fleet of Samsung Galaxy S8 phones until we can be assured the Android version on any new phones we buy will allow us to record calls.

Please make call recording a priority fix.

Call recording required for Pie. Put it back please.

Need ability to record calls in order to later transcribe for work.  Cannot upgrade phone until this is added back to android functionality.

Come on Google! Why did you do this... this was a feature I was excited for my next upgrade from iPhone...

For me, living alone and facing dementia problems call recording was an essential tool. No more.

Не записывает собеседника...

Where the hell would you get the idea that blocking call recording was a good thing?  Your privacy of information excuse is pathetic.
When ever you call any large company or government dept your calls are recorded. But guess what you take that feature away from the individual who needs it for protection, legal reasons or to simply be able to recall informational a later date.
For such a usually switched on company you really switched off , treated your customers with absolute contempt and have really pissed them off.
My phone contract expires in a few months and if this is not fixed in any updates before then its definately bye bye.
Get with it and think about your customers, give them what they want and have some consideration and refund those that have paid for apps that you have made useless.

Ok, what's the alternative?

*An iPhone it is also not an (direct) option. In case you use an iPhone you
make 2nd call which is recorded by a remote service, where after you can
download the call afterwards.*

Op zo 28 jul. 2019 om 13:00 schreef <buganizer-system@google.com>:

--

Met vriendelijke groet,

*Mike Wes*
mikeewes@gmail.com

@56 Currently the only alternatives I see are:
1. Buy a smarphone that has it built in (Samsung or Xiaomi have it, I think).
2. Put a custom rom that has it.

@57
"1. Buy a smarphone that has it built in (Samsung or Xiaomi have it, I think)."

There is a Call Recorder App for Samsung S10 + using Android Pie. That app is records the microphone. What the app records from the other person depends on how much the microphone is picking up from the loudspeaker. So, actually this is *NOT* recording in-stream.

@58 Well that's what we have...
Do you say that if you use headphones (or their variants), it won't record?
Maybe they didn't implement it well?
Maybe it works better on other phones?

In any case, sadly, Google goes to a very restricting manner on Q . You can see many questions about this on Google's AMA here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/androiddev/comments/ci4tdq/were_on_the_engineering_team_for_android_q_ask_us/?sort=new

@59
"Do you say that if you use headphones (or their variants), it won't record?"

It records with poor quality. If picks up all noises around your microphone and actual conversation through the speaker will be picked up with a low volume.

@60 Too bad. I was hoping that when it's built in, it would work perfectly.

My old android phone had a perfectly good, free phone call recording app. As a financial adviser I have to keep detailed records of all client instructions, so having phone calls recorded so I could listen to the recording to make file notes after the call was one of the best features of my android phone, especially when getting a call while driving, on the train etc. which makes taking notes impractical.

After my phone broke I got a new phone, which came with the new android version. Having call recording no longer available REALLY SUCKS!

The available 'work arounds' (recording the call in speakerphone mode, feeding one earbud output into the headphone mic input, etc) are really not practical/reliable.

And having to 'root' the phone should not be required by a decent operating system in order to reinstate a feature that was working perfectly well in a previous version.

Once again, THIS SUCKS. Please fix this asap -- an update to the current android version, rather than forcing us to wait YEARS for some future version to reinstate this would be ideal.

+1

I am very disappointed with Google policy about call recording functions. Do not be APPLE, do not make frames for your customers. Google have very good tool - play market, where could block apps in regions, where call recording is prohibited. So please get recording function back!!!

If I wanted Apple. I would have bought an Apple. Call recording when used within legal parameters and in states with 1 party acknowledgement is one of the most useful tools. Users are responsible for knowing where and with whom conversations can be recorded. I don't need Google to babysit me.

Hi,
please return the call-recording feature back.
I'm really angry because of you deciding for me.
I'm the owner of the device and let me decide on my own whether I need to record calls or whether it is legal in my country or not.
If I'm enabling the feature I'm ready to take responsibility if you are afraid of being responsible for my actions.  

We want call recording!

Please bring back call recording

need call recording! pleas add!

I guess they won't bring it back because they do not want you to record all the crazy responses from their "experts" i India. When When some idiot  ported my phone number without my permission instead of adding a member to my plan and I completely lost my phone number they told me google does not allow phone calls to be recorded. Another idiot told me that they need to replace external my sim card to make my Pixel 3XL work, wne mu internal sim card got corrupted. I think adding call recording feature would me it easier to sue google for. Without it they are much safer to screw up people without any consequences.

Sorry for all the misspellings. But I am furious, because I lost my phone number that I had for many years and there is no way to get it. The port back process will take 3-5 days and this was my restaurant number so I have to change all the brochures, adds. there are articles in the newspaper they created a mess for me. If I have had the recording I could sue them, without it I am on my own. So don't expect it to happen. EVER.

Maybe a group law suit on Google to bring it back again?: https://piunikaweb.com/2018/04/23/breaking-details-of-lawsuit-filed-against-samsung-over-galaxy-s9-call-issues/

My boyfriend died in March and I am so glad that I was able to record the last conversations with him. Please give us this feature back

Please fix call record on android 10, it's really important for all of us

As a private investigator call recorder is very important to me.  It is one of the biggest reasons I don't have an iphone.   This needs to be fixed.

I will try to ask for a replacement on my galaxy as i bought it android 8.0 and it was not 'upgraded' with android 9.0 - samsung says they dont have tools to downgrade the OS, they cannot reverse android version. So just replacing (if there's any left) for another under 8.0. But call recording was a key feature that led me to buy android instead of IOS/iphone.
And so far, seems Android 10 will NOT have call recording back.

Where is it "fixed"? Please reopen.

Call recording needed. We own conversations in which we are involved.

Help us

Call recorder required

version11 addedd ACCESS_CALL_AUDIO permission :)

refer : https://www.xda-developers.com/android-11-call-recording/

@81 That's incorrect. It's only for apps that replace the phone app.
Those apps are very rare to find, and when you do find those, they are also usually have a poor implementation, and for good reason: It's tons of work to implement a replacement for the Phone app.
Not only that, but you will lose any special feature you have for the phone app, and as a user you will be more dependent on the new app, having to deal with its bugs instead of bugs on a recording app.

It's a very bad decision to force developers to implement the Phone app just for call recording. Call recording should be decoupled. There are already apps that specializes on this, and they have their own features without affecting the Phone app , without any risk for the Phone app, and without changing how a phone call UI looks like.

I made a request to de-couple those here:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/152068228

Call recording required for android 6,7,8,9,10........... Put it back please.

ACCESS_CALL_AUDIO is removed in DP4!

solicito grabador del lamadas  para mi samsung a30s lo necesito por favor por mi falta de memoria me ayuda a tener apuntes y direcciones k tengo al escuchar las llamadas k me hacen gracias

Will you please please please reinstate call recording on your next build of Android.
For me it is essential

Fucking put it back! !!! How much more do you need. Put it back!!!!!!!!!
It's not hard, I could do it myself, do it fuckers. You fucking suck so
bad. Fuck you.

On Sat, Jun 6, 2020, 1:32 AM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:

Call recording is essential if not basic. Even receipients of call have rights to record conversations.

A little phone like OPPO9 has inbuilt recording capability, why not Android 10.

Please enable this feature. Interestingly even Apps like Call Recorder are not working on Android 10.

It not fair

The "security and privacy implications" seem to be solved by Google Voice by installing their application, enabling the feature and pressing 4 during an incoming call. The solution seems to be add this feature behind a setting in the default Android system as this has already been resolved by Google.

I need this feature for outgoing phone calls. I spent 3 years working with a bank (who had successful class action lawsuits against them for the same situation I had to face) to get a situation resolved because I didn't record my phone conversations to have the proof of what they told me. I am dealing with a similar situation with a medical billing department who is setting up payment plans without our consent and saying that we authorized them to do so.

To be clear in the United States recording calls from my understanding is legal depending on the consent and/or notification given to the parties involved. In my state I can call anyone else in my state and record the phone conversation as long as one of us knows the conversation is being records (example, I know the conversation is being recorded therefore it is legal to record my conversation). If I call other states I must make them aware that I'm recording the call as all parties in the conversation must be aware the phone call is being recorded.

Why is the Status fixed? While it says that it won't make it into "Q" (Android 10). Does this mean that the feature is fixed in Android 11 (R, or what ever it is being called)? I'm just looking on some clarification, I don't care if it announces that the call is being recorded since this is cover most people's legal obligations as I understand them in the US.

How come this topic marked as "Fixed"? What is fixed? At least not the call recording ability.
Google has/had mottos "Don't be evil" and "Do the right thing". By removing one core ability to record calls, which gave to simple users help do their work and to base their rights can't be considered anything else than evil or succumb to evil. At least it's not the right thing to do!

Seems it's not available on R beta 1.
I don't know how it's "fixed".
Seems more like they had it, and removed it for some reason. Probably again annoying laws in the USA.
I think Google HQ should move to some other country, with more freedom :)

Anyway, here, requested again:
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/158923887

Google marked multiple new reports as duplicates to this one.
I don't know what this means...

Call recording helps keep women safe. Check out this user story:
https://support.google.com/android/thread/38640488?hl=en&msgid=55137942

There is a ruling of the European court of human rights in which the recording of calls of oneself with a third party is totally legal, it is equivalent to taking note. What may be illegal is the use made of it. Only for own use, remember what was spoken, or judicial evidence. Not to be disseminated if it is not with the consent of the other party.

en México es muy común la estafa telefónica y la grabación de la misma me es como un respaldo para poder compartir con las autoridades competentes de estos casos, en lo particular me es de mas seguridad grabar las llamadas que dejar de hacerlo, por favor activen la grabación de llamadas.

Does anybody know someone who works at Google? I think it's time to start pushing Google through the real people to do the right thing to bring back the very essential functionality which is almost as elementary as making a call. It's utterly arrogant from Google's side to mark that feature request status fixed and ignore their customers' complaints.

To comment #97. Thanks for the explanation, but IMO people's resentment is fully justified as long as there's no call recording feature in OS (which was there to version 8).
The status "fixed" is just misleading if that also denotes an option that the request is under consideration. In such a case, there should be a clearer designation like "in process" or "under consideration" or "added to roadmap" etc.

Regarding comment #97: Your issue tracker statement is correct. But this is not a feature request. This is a bug entry because a working feature was removed. That means the feature is broken and so is the product. So this is a show stopper. In this case, all people have the right to complain about the "fixed" status because the bug is neither "fixed" nor "accepted". So it should rather be said that AOSP developers do not understand how issue tracks work.

Hi dear Google I am using redmi note 9 pro mobile
But call application is Google dialer beta but not record
Future in the app a I'm suggesting Google please give me
Record option and defult give me any phone Google dialer

"I am installation beta service in Google Play Store"

Ani call my owne divis phone imiditly give me please I want to information thanks you

I love my googole app & website

Нужна запись разговора до зубовного скрежета! Иногда посреди улицы нет возможности записать информацию. Тут помогает запись, прослушал позже и записал нужное. Какое нарушение прав тут? В суд эту запись не примут как доказательство. Верните!!!!!

Hiii sir please help me my device name relme narzo 20 pro call recording problem . How to speak call recording mode another device

When will call recorder function on the phone dialer for my pixel 6 pro be enabled. I'm in Canada where call recording is legal.

Right?

On Wed, Nov 2, 2022, 3:51 PM <buganizer-system@google.com> wrote:

Not call recording 😢

Not call recording 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

Андроид 9 Запись идёт, а звука нет, почему??? Может кто знает